The U.S. economy is looking good heading into the fall.

The labor market remains extremely strong with continued job and wage gains. Consumer spending is steadily increasing even after adjusting for higher prices, as is business investment. And inflation, although still well above the Federal Reserve’s 2% objective, has slowed noticeably over the past year.

Not all of the news is good, however. In particular, interest rates have risen sharply over the past couple of years to their highest levels in decades, leading to a substantial slowing in the housing market.

But even so, small businesses are feeling optimistic in the second half of 2023, according to the latest results from PNC’s survey of small and middle-market businesses.

Advertise with us

In fact, optimism is the highest it has ever been in the more than 20-year history of the survey (see chart). More than three-quarters (77% of respondents) were optimistic about their company’s prospects over the next six months, up from 60% in the spring and 49% last fall. This optimism was strong across all industries, but manufacturers were especially optimistic, at 85%. Another 21% of respondents were moderately optimistic about their company’s near-term prospects. And only 2% were pessimistic, including none of the 74 manufacturers interviewed.

A number of factors are behind this record high. Businesses are much more optimistic about demand for their products than they were in the spring and last fall. They are also more optimistic about their sales and profits. Their expectations for the U.S., global, and their local economies have also improved. And while cost pressures persist for both labor and materials, they are not as intense as they have been recently.

But there is an interesting dichotomy in the results: respondents are much more optimistic about their own prospects than they are about the economy, and in particular the U.S. economy.

While more than three-quarters of small businesspeople are optimistic about their own company’s near-term outlook, only one-third (34%) are optimistic about the U.S. economy over the next six months. This optimism gap between their own business and the U.S. economy is a long-standing feature in the data, but is especially wide now, at 43%.

A big reason why small business owners are so optimistic about the outlook is that they have been through so much over the past few years — with the pandemic, a very deep but very short recession, a strong recovery, high inflation and rapid increases in interest rates.

Advertise with us

The survey asked those respondents who were more optimistic about their own business than about the national economy specifically why that was the case. Almost two-thirds (65%) said that it was because they were confident in their own ability to run their business, by far the most common answer (respondents were allowed to give multiple reasons). This reflects the challenges that small and mid-sized businesses have successfully faced in recent years.

The labor market remains a concern for small and mid-sized businesses in the second half of 2023. More than one-quarter of respondents (28%) say that it’s tougher to hire qualified employees now compared to six months ago, while another 45% report it is just as difficult. Only 6% say it is easier to hire, even as job growth has slowed over the course of the year.

The availability of labor remains a significant problem: 45% of respondents who say that it is tougher to hire now report that there are not enough applicants, while another 22% say that candidates don’t have the necessary skills or experience. Because of this, two-thirds of firms report that they are taking affirmative steps to attract workers, including offering flexible work arrangements and revamping their benefits offered. This is consistent with data showing a very tight labor market and an historically low unemployment rate.

Although firms are feeling optimistic, there are big concerns ahead for the U.S. economy.

The rapid increases in both short-term and long-term interest rates are already weighing on the economy, most notably on the housing market. But tighter monetary policy from the Federal Reserve works with a lag, and the U.S. economy has yet to feel the full effects of the run-up in interest rates. Although inflation has slowed, it is still too high for the central bank, and interest rates are likely to remain elevated through the rest of this year and into 2024.

Advertise with us

Because of this PNC is expecting a mild economic recession starting in the first half of next year, lasting for about six months. Real GDP is forecasted to contract less than 1%, much milder than the contractions during the pandemic (down 9%) and the Great Recession from 2007 to 2009 (down 4%).

The unemployment rate will gradually increase through the rest of this year and throughout next, peaking at about 5% by early 2025. Slowing inflation and a deteriorating labor market will lead the Federal Reserve to cut interest rates by mid-2024, allowing for a modest economy recovery starting late next year and accelerating in 2025.

Gus Faucher is senior vice president and chief economist of The PNC Financial Services Group. He shares his insights on the regional economy each month.