Although recession risks are elevated in mid-2023 as the Federal Reserve has aggressively raised interest rates to fight inflation, the U.S. economy continues to grow.

In particular, the labor market is historically strong, with solid job growth and the national unemployment rate close to a 50-year low.

However, the situation is not nearly as good in the Pittsburgh area. While the local unemployment rate is at its lowest level since the series began in 1990 (4.1% in May), Pittsburgh-area job growth has consistently lagged behind the rest of the country throughout the current economic expansion following the coronavirus-induced recession. Even more concerning, local employment has been weak this year, even as the nation continues to add jobs at a steady clip.

The U.S. economy lost 22 million jobs in March and April 2020 as the pandemic took hold. But thanks to massive stimulus from the federal government and very low interest rates courtesy of the Federal Reserve, the economy has added back all of those jobs and more. Employment nationally is higher by about 4 million, or 2.5%, from before the pandemic.

Advertise with us

But the situation in the Pittsburgh metropolitan area is very different. As of June, local employment was below its pre-pandemic level by about 22,000, or 2%. Some of this is due to larger proportional job losses during the early stages of the pandemic in Pittsburgh (19%) compared to the country as a whole (14%) because of more local restrictions on economic activity compared to other parts of the country.

But the more important reason is a weak Pittsburgh recovery.

Some of this is because of the area’s industrial structure. For example, much of the national labor market recovery has been driven by leisure and hospitality services (such as hotels and restaurant) and manufactured consumer goods. The Pittsburgh area has below-average shares of jobs in these industries, and thus has benefitted less from their recoveries.

But there's also a bigger structural problem in the Pittsburgh labor market — the shrinking labor force, the number of adults either working or looking for work. Nationally, the labor force is growing because of population growth, including immigration. The U.S. labor force in June was about 1.5% larger than it was before the pandemic.

In Pittsburgh, the labor force in May was 3% smaller than it was before the pandemic (chart 1). Many older Pittsburgh workers decided to retire during the pandemic, some because they lost their jobs and decided not to go back to work, others because they were concerned about catching the coronavirus. But no matter the reason, there are many fewer people available to work right now in Pittsburgh than there were before the pandemic, making it much more difficult for firms to hire.

Advertise with us

As a result, job growth during the current economic expansion in the Pittsburgh metropolitan area has lagged well behind the rest of the country.

Even more ominously, employment was down slightly from February through May of this year according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, although employment increased by almost 6,000 in June (chart 2). The metro area numbers are volatile and there are often big revisions to the data, so the real picture may be different. But this is still a warning sign that the area’s contracting labor force remains a huge problem.

The dearth of available workers has been a problem in the Pittsburgh area for decades, exacerbated by the pandemic. But the lack of workers will be a significant deterrent to business expansion in the area in the future. If firms cannot find the workers that they need in Pittsburgh, they will hire in other parts of the country instead.

The Pittsburgh labor market does have some major advantages. The area’s educational institutions attract students from around the country and the world, creating a pool of highly skilled talent. Pittsburgh also has good concentrations in well-paying industries like tech, higher education, health care and finance.

But the shortage of available workers is weighing, and will continue to weigh, on industries such as construction, manufacturing, retail trade and leisure/hospitality services that provide opportunities for workers with less formal education.

Advertise with us

There is a silver lining to this. PNC is forecasting a mild U.S. recession to start at the end of this year. Older workers, who are disproportionately represented in the Pittsburgh labor market, are less likely to lose their jobs during a downturn. And many of Pittsburgh's key industries, most notably education and health care, are less exposed to the national business cycle. So if there is a U.S. recession in the near term, Pittsburgh will suffer less of a hit.

But over the long term,  the contracting Pittsburgh labor force will remain a significant drag on the local economy. Businesses will be looking for workers, and will turn to other parts of the country where the labor force is growing, not contracting. Growth will remain well below the national average unless and until Pittsburgh solves its labor force problem.

One possible solution is to attract more international immigrants. Historically international immigration has been a key source of growth in the area; think back to the expansion of the steel industry in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, when people came from all over the world to work in the local mills.

More recently, Pittsburgh has lagged behind the rest of the country in attracting immigrants, but they could be a key source of growth in Pittsburgh once again, especially if policymakers can figure out how to increase levels of legal immigration.

But absent that, the structural problems in the Pittsburgh area labor force will remain a significant drag on long-run local growth.

Gus Faucher is senior vice president and chief economist of The PNC Financial Services Group. He shares his insights on the regional economy each month.