Make an appointment with your doctor and chances are about 1 in 4 that you’ll be seen by a specially trained nurse or physician assistant instead. That ramped up from a 14% likelihood in 2013, according to a study.

And this a good thing: The boom in the number of non-physicians treating patients has tamped down overall health care costs while backfilling a shortage of doctors expected to stretch into 2032.

But lumping advanced practice nurses who don’t work together and likely don’t know each other into the same union bargaining unit while keeping out coworkers who do the same work for the same wages has raised questions at UPMC Magee-Womens Hospital.

The National Labor Relations Board has scheduled a unionization vote at Magee in Oakland on Sept. 6 and 9 for a bargaining unit comprising about 100 advanced practitioners, some of whom rotate through nonunion UPMC hospitals.

Advertise with us

The NLRB has ruled that Magee’s certified registered nurse practitioners, neonatal nurse practitioners, certified nurse midwives, nurse navigators and other registered nurses “constitute a readily identifiable group and share a community of interest” to create a SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania bargaining unit.

Jen Davison, a registered nurse practitioner who specializes in palliative care for women with cancer at Magee, disagrees.

“The situation makes no sense,” she said. “It’s just weird.”

UPMC spokesman Paul Wood declined to comment Friday. SEIU officials were not available for comment.

SEIU is trying to organize 1,100 nurses at the hospital, including about 100 advanced practitioners scheduled to vote next month. The other 1,000 registered nurses and others will finish voting on union representation Saturday. It’s uncertain when the results will be available.

Advertise with us

Earlier this month, about 75 Magee-Womens nurses, elected officials and other supporters rallied at a public park near the hospital to back the union drive, citing inadequate staffing and support for acceptable nurse-to-patient ratios.

An SEIU win would be historic, following decades of failed attempts to organize UPMC’s flagship Oakland hospitals. UPMC has said it is committed to a lawful election, but would prefer dealing directly with its staff instead of through a third party.

Ms. Davison, who works in UPMC’s Palliative and Supportive Institute’s outpatient clinics, said she doesn’t know any Magee midwives and has never worked with them, even though they work in the same building. The same is true for hospital nurses who specialize in caring for newborns and ones who guide patients through complex treatments, all of whom are also grouped in the same union bargaining unit.

It has raised questions for her about how the health system benefits that she has come to appreciate and how relationships with supervisors might change with unionization.

“Magee is a great hospital,” she said. “All the things I’ve worked for — will they go away?”

Advertise with us

The bargaining unit excludes physician assistants, who are salaried employees doing virtually the same work alongside advanced nurse practitioners like Ms. Davison. She believes, if unionization succeeds, it would fracture these relationships, which UPMC classifies as advanced practice professionals.

It would be awkward if nurse practitioners, working alongside physician assistants, were represented by SEIU and physician assistant coworkers are not, she said.

And what would union representation mean for advanced practice professionals who are assigned to work at UPMC Passavant in McCandless or other nonunion hospitals within the system?

Ms. Davison said she will be voting against union representation.

“It doesn’t seem like they know who they are representing,” said Ms. Davison, who previously worked at a unionized hospital in California and said she is not against unions. “There is a time and place for a union and I don’t think this is it.”