Organized labor’s long slog to unionize UPMC’s flagship Oakland hospitals continued Friday with a National Labor Relations Board hearing that picks up again Tuesday.

SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania petitioned the NLRB June 16 to represent 100 registered and some advanced practice nurses and others at UPMC Magee-Womens Hospital. They are employed by University of Pittsburgh Physicians, the health system’s subsidiary medical practice group, which staffs the hospital.

If successful, the unionization effort would be a setback for UPMC President and CEO Leslie Davis, who served as Magee-Womens president for 13 years, and a breakthrough victory for organized labor, which has been trying to unionize the Oakland hospitals for 55 years — decades before UPMC was born.

Coretta Scott King, widow of slain civil rights leader Martin Luther King Jr., rallied hourly hospital workers at Oakland’s Soldiers & Sailors Memorial Hall on March 19, 1970, the night before Presbyterian-University Hospital janitors and others, took up picket signs in the rain to demand union representation. Hospital officials were opposed.

Advertise with us

The drive for recognition by the Hospital & Nursing Home Employees Union folded.

In more recent years, SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania — backed by Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey, Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato and U.S. Rep. Summer Lee — has taken up the call for unionization at UPMC by targeting the system’s Magee-Womens, Presby and Shadyside hospitals, UPMC’s flagship institutions.

The NLRB’s Pittsburgh office opened the pre-election hearing Thursday to determine whether a unionization vote at Magee-Womens should be held at all, which UPMC opposes.

Testimony by two University of Pittsburgh Physicians human resource officials focused on job distinctions, work schedules, uniforms — even where different medical staff members go for breaks — so each side can make a case for why or why not the nurses comprise a bargaining unit.

Both sides came prepared.

Advertise with us

UPP was represented by Ogletree, Deakins, Nash, Smoak & Stewart, a union-avoidance law firm based in Atlanta with 60 offices in 32 states, Canada, Mexico and Europe. SEIU Healthcare was represented by Philadelphia-based Willig, Williams & Davidson, which has law offices in Haddonfield, N.J. and Chicago. The firm, which has posted “Workers inspire us” on its website, has represented the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers union for decades.

Challenging the scope and makeup of the proposed bargaining unit lays the groundwork for future NLRB appeals and could shrink the proportion of eligible union members and dilute support for organized labor, experts say.

“Staff, senior and expert level certified registered nurse practitioner: can you tell me why there’s a bunch of titles for CRNPs,” Ogletree Deakins attorney Sara E. Olschewske asked Zoe Ribar, UPMC assistant administrator.

“They’re different career ladders,” Ms. Ribar said. “Years of experience differentiate the three levels.”

“Do CRNPs wear uniforms?”

Advertise with us

“Generally, you can wear scrubs and business casual in outpatient settings; on the inpatient side, it’s scrubs,” Mr. Ribar answered.

Willig Williams attorney Ryan A. Hancock sought to paper over any differences among employees in the proposed bargaining unit.

“Are UPP employees subject to UPMC policies and procedures,” he asked Ms. Ribar.

“Yes.”

“Does UPP bill independently for services,” he asked.

Advertise with us

“Yes.”

“Do midwives practice team-based care?”

“They absolutely can,” she said.

In 2011, SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania targeted Magee-Womens, Presby and Shadyside hospitals for unionization. Once again, management pushed back.

“We do not want the SEIU here because we do not believe this union or any other union would be in your best interest or the best interest of UPMC and the people we serve,” then Magee-Womens’ president Leslie Davis wrote in a letter to employees.

Advertise with us

SEIU Healthcare’s latest petition comes at a fraught time at the NLRB.

Although NLRB’s 28 regional offices continue to investigate unfair labor practices and certify elections, the agency’s Washington D.C. headquarters has been in turmoil. The NLRB has been without a three-member quorum since May, after the U.S. Supreme Court prevented the reinstatement of board member Gwynne Wilcox while her legal challenge to her termination by President Donald Trump is pending.

That means the board can’t issue decisions on union representation or unfair labor practices. If either SEIU Healthcare or UPMC appeals a decision by the Pittsburgh office, the matter will be on hold until the NLRB board in Washington, D.C., has a quorum.