When two nurses at UPMC Magee-Womens Hospital posted on social media recently that they’re being run ragged and patient care is being strained by the Pittsburgh health system giant’s staffing practices, it highlighted a long-running national debate over the right patient-to-nurse ratios.
UPMC officials dispute allegations that their policies are a problem.
“Scheduling the right number of nurses to staff our units is a top priority for UPMC Magee and we continue to invest in building the pipeline for new nurses as well as focused recruitment and retention efforts,” spokesman Paul Wood said in a statement Monday. “Our approach to staffing is flexible and evidence-based in evaluating shift to shift circumstances.”
Appropriate staffing has emerged as a wedge in SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania’s longstanding efforts to organize Magee-Womens’ nurses after the union’s failure in 2023 to have hospital staffing minimums baked into state legislation, which Gov. Josh Shapiro supported. Only California and Oregon have such mandates.
Fewer patients for nurses to care for generally works out better for people admitted to the hospital, but research on the issue has sometimes been mixed — due in part to hospital policy differences in assigning aides and other personnel to help nurses.
Professional nurse organizations are split on the issue of mandating fixed nurse-to-patient ratios in hospitals.
Read More
The American Nurse Association — Michigan, for example, opposes fixed staffing ratios in hospitals because they oversimplify complex patient needs and can exacerbate nursing shortages. Meeting required staffing could lead to closed hospital units or reduced hospital capacity, according to the organization.
In February, a New Jersey group looking at proposed legislation to beef up hospital staffing with new requirements questioned the evidence supporting mandates.
“Fixed staffing ratios can impact other roles within the organization,” the New Jersey Collaborating Center for Nurses wrote in a final report. “Currently, there are shortages of other staff, including of unlicensed assistive personnel. It’s also unclear what evidence would support these ratios.”
In a Facebook post, Magee-Womens nurse Liana Montes said it was common for nurses to be assigned a 2-to-1 patient ratio for laboring mothers when the Association of Women’s Health, Obstetrics & Neonatal Nurses recommends a ratio of 1-to-1 for women in active labor or when they’re receiving certain medications.
“Yesterday I did not stop moving for almost 13 hours without a break and I left knowing there was more to do to provide the best care for my patients,” she wrote. “I can’t stress enough how adding more and more on nurses because of ‘the budget’ has a ripple effect on the care we are able to provide to all of our patients.”
Magee-Womens nurse Jean Cordisco Stone also posted on Facebook that it was typical for nurses to have a “2-to-1 ratio for most laboring patients when the standard is 1-to-1.”
“Standards and ratios exist for a reason,” she wrote. “Care is better. Quality of life is better. People are better.”
Both women support SEIU’s organizing drive at the hospital, but it was unclear whether either one backed fixed nurse-to-patient ratios; neither nurse was available for comment Monday.
Across town, contractually mandated nursing ratios have been part of SEIU’s labor agreement for nurses at Allegheny General Hospital for decades.
SEIU has petitioned the National Labor Relations Board to represent about 1,100 nurses and other medical professionals at Magee-Womens — the furthest the union has gone after years of campaigning. A ruling by NLRB Regional Director Nancy Wilson on the make up of the bargaining unit or units is pending, which follows hearings on the issue.
Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit educational and advocacy group AWHONN has issued baseline staffing guidelines for hospital nurses while supporting assignment flexibility based on patient conditions and other factors.
Other nursing groups, including the American Organization for Nursing Leadership and the Academy of Medical Surgical Nurses, oppose fixed ratios.
Magee-Womens is not the first hospital in Western Pennsylvania where the issue of nurse ratios has been raised.
Staffing ratios have been a hot button union issue for years, helping spur a five-day strike by nurses at Kittanning-based Armstrong County Memorial Hospital in 2022 and informational pickets at Butler Memorial Hospital in March.
Also, bills requiring minimum staffing levels for nurses have been introduced into the Pennsylvania General Assembly for at least 15 years — most recently in 2023 when the Patient Safety Act was approved by the House with the backing of SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania and Mr. Shapiro.
The legislation was referred to a Senate committee where it died. The bill would’ve set minimum nurse staffing levels for every hospital department in pre-set ratios.
And as early as 2023, bills requiring minimum nursing staffing requirements for various hospital departments have been considered by Congress.
In his statement this week, UPMC’s Mr. Wood said hospital supervisors work with nurses to optimize staffing flexibility.
“With input from our front-line nurses, we continue to develop strategies, such as our nursing actuaries workload tool, which helps us objectively measure how much staffing we need on a particular unit,” he wrote. “Unit leaders partner with their teams to determine the best approach to staffing based on the patient population and volume of each unit.”
No UPMC hospital with a nursing workforce represented by SEIU has contractually required nurse-to-patient ratios, Mr. Wood said.
In fact, only three Pennsylvania hospitals have such mandates: Temple University Hospital and Einstein Medical Center, both in Philadelphia, where nurses are represented by the Pennsylvania Association of Staff Nurses and Allied Professionals; and Allegheny General on the North Side, where the requirement became part of the SEIU nurses’ labor agreement in the late 1990s bankruptcy years of the Allegheny Health and Education and Research Foundation, AGH’s former corporate parent.
The Pennsylvania Association of Staff Nurses and Allied Professionals also represents nurses at Armstrong County Memorial and Butler Memorial hospitals.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.