Many Pennsylvania hospitals closed the books last month on a banner year, with combined operating revenue hitting a 15-year high of $66.6 billion, up 9% from a year ago. That surge came as their operating expense increases held to a 4% hike, according to a new report.
UPMC Children’s Hospital in Lawrenceville, for example, bested 30 hospitals in the Pittsburgh area with a year-end operating margin of 22.98%.
But it was a different story for nearly three dozen smaller, rural hospitals in Pennsylvania, which ended the year June 30, 2024, in the red, the Harrisburg-based Pennsylvania Health Care Cost Containment Council found.
Among those struggling were hospitals in McKeesport and Natrona Heights, as well as in Greene and Fayette counties. In the eight counties surrounding Allegheny County, 10 hospitals reported negative operating margins for the 12 months starting in July 2023 and ending in June 2024.
“Pennsylvania’s hospital community continues to experience significant strain, largely because reimbursement does not reflect the cost of providing care,” Liam Migdail, vice president, strategic communications, Hospital and Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania, said Friday in a statement.
And, he predicted, the situation could further deteriorate going forward.
Read More
Pennsylvania lawmakers from both parties have raised concerns about changes approved recently by Congress that would cut more than $1 trillion from Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program over the next decade, and shift substantial Medicaid expansion costs to the states.
The impact of those changes may take time to play out, but the latest numbers from the hospitals reflects more immediate trends.
In an interview Monday, hospital association President and CEO Nicole Stallings credited the hospitals that performed well in the past fiscal year with having the “scale and resources to respond to the pressures of running hospitals today.”
After taking hits during the pandemic and coping with rising labor costs, some are making changes that appear to be resonating — such as reducing temporary staff, which drove up costs during the pandemic.
“We are seeing financial recovery, but it’s uneven,” she said. “Many hospitals in the red have continued to see their margins worsen.”
Ms. Stallings worried about the rising number of hospitals that are showing losses for the three years ending in 2024 as compared to the three-year period 2021 to 2023.
The Pennsylvania Health Care Cost Containment Council is an independent, state-funded agency that researches hospital finances, cost trends and other health care issues. The report issued Friday was the first of a series of three that are planned to gauge the financial health of the state’s general acute care hospitals, surgery, rehab and other medical centers.
Of 153 acute care hospitals in Pennsylvania, just under half ended the year with operating margins over 4%. Operating margin reflects revenue vs. costs.
That boosts the statewide average operating margin to 6.8% in 2024, up from 2.26% the year before, according to the report.
At the same time, 37% of hospitals in the state — most of them rural — posted negative operating margins for the year, meaning spending exceeded revenue.
Some hospitals — about 14% — were running close to breaking even, with an operating margin of 4% or lower.
Margins less than 4% can mean delayed capital improvements such as sophisticated scanning equipment purchases, which hospitals need to stay current with medical advancements.
Virtually all nonprofit hospitals are required by federal law to treat patients, regardless of the patient’s ability to pay.
An operating loss may not spell fiscal catastrophe if the hospital can cover the red ink with investment returns, donations or other non-medical revenue sources.
But because medical care is a core service for hospitals, an operational loss can signal bigger problems at the institution.
In the eight counties surrounding Allegheny County, 10 hospitals reported negative operating margins for fiscal 2024, including three operated by UPMC — UPMC Greene in Greene County and UPMC McKeesport and UPMC Mercy in Pittsburgh.
Penn Highlands Healthcare Connellsville Hospital in Fayette County reported the highest operating loss for the year at 16.95%, followed by Allegheny Health Network’s Allegheny Valley Hospital in Natrona Heights, 13.72%; and Heritage Valley Sewickley, 13.09%.
On the horizon are the recently approved federal cuts that will make it harder for hospitals to operate, the hospital association’s Mr. Migdail said.
“While the hospital-level financial data does not fully capture significant losses to health systems, the fiscal year 2024 data shows that less than half of the commonwealth’s acute care hospitals are operating with margins necessary for long-term stability and more than a third are operating at a loss,” Mr. Migdail said in the statement.
“Federal cuts will accelerate these challenges by cutting Medicaid payments that have been necessary to stabilize some hospital margins and reducing health care coverage, resulting in more uncompensated care.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.