Most health insurers in Pennsylvania are pressing for double-digit rates increases for Obamacare plan coverage starting in January, with Pittsburgh-based Highmark using its planned hikes as just one piece of a broader effort to stanch yawning losses in the government-subsidized marketplace.
Dispatching teams of health care professionals around the state to better track the medical claims of people with Affordable Care Act coverage is also part of Highmark’s renewed attack on expenses.
The Blues affiliate reported losing a total of $812 million on the insurance line in 2014 and 2015, and said losses would reach another $500 million by July. As it moves to stem the flow of red ink, Highmark is seeking state approval to boost rates for one of its Affordable Care Act plans by 48.10 percent effective in January — the highest rate hike sought by a health insurer doing business in Pennsylvania.
Pittsburgh rival UPMC Health Plan asked for rate hikes of 16.2 percent and 0.9 percent for two plans offered on the government exchange. The statewide average rate increase sought by health insurers was 23.6 percent, according to the state Department of Insurance.
By October, the insurance department will decide the rates each insurer is allowed to charge people who buy policies in the government marketplace.
Coverage for people using the insurance marketplace has been more costly than that for traditional patients because they have higher medical bills, said Alexis Miller, senior vice president of individual and small groups at Highmark.
Read More
Many had been without coverage until the program was put in place.
“Our experience with this population is that they are indeed sicker,” Ms. Miller said. “They utilize more services. For every dollar in premiums, there is $1.19 in claims, and that’s not sustainable.”
Newly insured people under the ACA had inpatient hospitalization rates 57 percent higher, 49 percent higher rates of chemotherapy treatment for cancer and 43 percent higher rates of congestive heart failure when compared with commercially insured members, Highmark President and CEO David Holmberg said earlier this month. Congestive heart failure is a leading cause of hospitalization.
A new report from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services found that proposed rate hikes were not a good indicator of the actual rates that consumers will pay. Tax credits go up along with premiums, and consumers can shop around for the best rates under the marketplace system.
Seventy-six percent of Pennsylvanians who shop on the government’s health insurance website receive tax credits, which are designed to soften the impact of rate hikes.
As part of its strategy to cut its losses, Highmark recently formed 15 teams of doctors, nurses, social workers and others to track Pennsylvania members with ACA coverage, contacting members when higher medical costs could be avoided without compromising care, Ms. Miller said.
Primary care office visits could replace multiple trips to the hospital emergency room, for example, reducing costs while improving a member’s quality of life.
The strategy, called intensive case management, has been successfully used by other carriers, including UPMC Health Plan and others with large Medicaid populations.
Highmark is among the biggest ACA insurers in Pennsylvania, with about 200,000 members. It has also asked for a 44.8 percent rate hike for its Highmark Choice Co. coverage and a 38.4 percent increase in rates for Highmark Inc. coverage.
It isn’t alone in seeking big increases. Other top rate requests include First Priority Life Insurance Co., 38.8 percent; Geisinger Health Plan, 41.23 percent; and Geisinger Quality Options, 40.68 percent.
In its battle to cut losses from ACA coverage, Highmark has also filed a lawsuit against the federal government over the failure to cover $223 million in losses in 2014 as part of a so-called “risk corridor” program meant to cushion insurers from losses through the first years of the program. The insurer has also reduced or eliminated broker commissions on its ACA plans.
UPMC Health Plan took a different approach, according to spokesman Paul Wood.
“UPMC Health Plan takes a prudent, financially responsible approach with respect to our product offerings and has never built our pricing around receiving risk-corridor reimbursements for potential losses realized as a result of participating in the individual exchange market,” he said in a prepared statement.
“UPMC continues to invest in our individual exchange products to ensure they are sustainable.”
Kris B. Mamula:kmamula@post-gazette.com, or 412-263-1699
Kris B. Mamula:kmamula@post-gazette.com, or 412-263-1699





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.