For health insurers, selling coverage in the new government marketplace has been a little like playing blind man’s bluff.

Almost nothing is known about members’ likely claims, many of whom never had health insurance. The result: Carriers nationwide sought double-digit rate increases for 2016 to cover unexpectedly high claims costs for this year.

But UPMC Health Plan came out swinging for the Affordable Care Act’s third open enrollment period that opened Nov. 1, offering some of the lowest rates in the country for a benchmark silver plan and holding rate hike requests to less than 10 percent.

Insurance brokers and others say the Pittsburgh insurer’s secret sauce is sophisticated software that allows the carrier to forecast the kinds of medical care a member is likely to need, even before the first doctor’s visit.

Advertise with us

“This is the future and we’re learning to thrive in this environment,” UPMC CFO Robert DeMichiei said. “It’s part of our strategy.”

All health insurers use predictive modeling and other analytic tools to forecast the cost of claims, but not all health insurers have done well in the individual market. Highmark, for example, lost $318 million in the government marketplace for the year ending June 30, blaming unexpectedly high claims costs for people who previously did not have health insurance.

UPMC doesn’t break out financials for its insurance arm, but Mr. DeMichiei said its government marketplace products are essentially a break-even business.

In the new open enrollment period for individual health care coverage, UPMC offered the lowest cost benchmark silver plans in Pennsylvania, including $146.58 for a 21-year-old nonsmoker and $187.33 for a 40-year-old smoker in the western part of the state. UPMC Health Plan doesn’t sell the coverage in several parts of the state, including the Philadelphia area.

UPMC’s monthly $187.33 premium is among the lowest in the country for the silver plan, based on Medicare data.

Advertise with us

Getting an early heads-up about a member’s likely claims allows the health plan to intervene early, say, reach out and encourage the member to get medical attention for diabetes, for example, before serious health problems arise.

Clues about likely claims come from a simple blood test or history of prescription drug usage, experts say. And insurance brokers say they are told by UPMC that the insurer has invested heavily in analytic tools.

In trying to make up for losses racked up in the individual market, Geisinger Health Plan asked state regulators to lift rates 41 percent for 2016. Highmark sought rate hikes ranging up to 36 percent.

UPMC Health Plan held its requests to less than 10 percent, sidestepping state Insurance Department review.

Mr. DeMichiei said maintaining low rates and breaking even in the government marketplace is part of UPMC’s strategy to attract consumers into the system, providing an array of services from health insurance to medical care.

Advertise with us

It’s not an easy balance, said Sabrina Corlette, research professor at Georgetown University Center on Health Insurance Reforms.

“The plan that gets the most enrollment tends to get the most risk,” she said, “not just the healthy people, but a lot of sick people.”

The Affordable Care Act was designed to change the way health insurers do business, encouraging carriers to embrace risk instead of avoiding it to keep a lid on claims, Ms. Corlette said.

“If you have really good data, you could use that as a foundation to try to price as accurately as possible and accurate pricing is key to the game here,” she said. “Not every company is set up to do that.”

Kris B. Mamula:kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412.263-1699.

Correction, posted Nov. 5, 2015: In an earlier version of this story, Robert DeMichiei’s title was misstated.