Less than two weeks before the Medicare open enrollment period for 2015 closes, UPMC and Highmark officials still disagree about which UPMC physicians will be in Highmark’s network next year, or whether the absence of signed contracts will even matter for Medicare recipients.
Highmark last week terminated the commercial and Medicare contracts of 689 UPMC physicians who it says practice solely in UPMC facilities in the Pittsburgh region, so new members would know those doctors will be out of network.
At the same time, the insurer offered new Medicare contracts to those physicians. The contracts would give seniors continued access to the UPMC physicians and facilities, as required under the state-brokered consent decrees reached last summer.
The contracts remain unsigned and UPMC spokesman Paul Wood said Tuesday, “UPMC will not sign these new contracts as we have no guarantee that by signing Highmark will be any more trustworthy to honor them than the contracts they terminated last week.
“We’re telling our patients that as a result of Highmark’s action, all Highmark Medicare Advantage products [including Security Blue HMO and Freedom Blue PPO] are now ‘No UPMC’ products, joining Community Blue Medicare Advantage HMO which excludes all UPMC physicians and facilities.”
Tom Fitzpatrick, Highmark’s senior vice president of provider contracting, said UPMC must include its Medicare members under the consent decrees’ continuity of care and vulnerable populations provisions.
Read More
“[UPMC’s] best friend is confusion right now, so they will do everything they can to add confusion to the marketplace,” Mr. Fitzpatrick said. “This is a big blow up about nothing.”
Under the vulnerable populations clause of the consent decrees, UPMC agreed to continue contracting with Highmark at in-network rates for seniors “as long as Highmark does not make unilateral material changes to these programs.”
Do the contract terminations constitute a “unilateral material change?”
UPMC thinks so, and chief medical officer Steven Shapiro has vowed “to vigorously oppose these illegal selective terminations.” Mr. Wood said Tuesday that includes “fully briefing all the regulators, including [Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services], about this hot mess Highmark has created for seniors.”
Dennis Gabos, a cardiologist at UPMC Passavant, is among the physicians whose contract Highmark has terminated. Dr. Gabos has criticized UPMC in the past for not negotiating a new contract with Highmark, in the belief that nonprofit hospitals are community assets that should be open to everyone.
He sees this latest development, however, as just the latest in “a series of unfortunate events from both parties that serves no good for patients.”
Under the spirit of the consent decrees signed last summer, he said, “there should be unimpeded access for patients with Highmark under the continuity of care.” He hopes state officials will take what he considers long-overdue steps to intervene.
“My position is that this should have never been allowed to happen if the governor, the attorney general, the insurance department and the state Legislature had any respect for its constituents,” he said.
Allegheny County Councilman Ed Kress, R-Shaler, who chairs the council’s insurance committee, also is calling for state officials to intervene following a public hearing Monday at which he brought the two parties together in an attempt to bring clarity to the UPMC-Highmark dispute.
After listening to testimony from Mr. Fitzpatrick and UPMC’s chief legal officer, Tom McGough, Jr., Mr. Kress said the proceeding “actually added to the confusion.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.