It’s possible that Pittsburgh-area seniors who subscribe to Highmark Health’s Freedom Blue or Security Blue Medicare Advantage plans and who visit a UPMC hospital may find that hospital is still in-network — but the physician who treats them there is not.
That’s one theoretical side effect of Highmark’s announcement last week that it would be terminating the commercial contracts of 700 UPMC physicians in order “to add a level of clarity to our members” concerning which doctors will remain in Highmark's network once the Pittsburgh insurer’s contract with UPMC ends Dec. 31.
Among those 700 are 160 hospital-based physicians, plus dozens of specialists. Highmark said it would offer the UPMC physicians Medicare-only reimbursement contracts, but UPMC says its doctors will not be signing those contracts — meaning, for now, they are out of Highmark’s provider network for both commercial products and Medicare products.
So if the contract cancellations remain in place — and that’s not a certainty, given the ever-shifting dynamics of the contractual relations between Highmark and UPMC — what happens if a Highmark Medicare Advantage customer goes to the hospital and is treated, for one reason or another, by an out-of-network hospitalist or specialist?
Naturally, the two Pittsburgh health giants disagree.
Highmark says the billing impasse would be governed by the consent decree signed over the summer by the two opposing entities. The decree says, “With respect to Highmark-covered [Medicare] populations, UPMC shall continue to contract with Highmark at in-network rates for all of its hospital, physician and appropriate continuity of care services.”
Read More
To Highmark, that means UPMC is required to bill any Medicare Advantage customer as in-network, regardless of the treating physicians’ insurance network affiliations.
“The consent decree is the road map,” Highmark spokesman Aaron Billger said. “We contend that these people will be in-network. The consent decree clearly protects the seniors.”
Yet the very same consent decree says that these Medicare and “vulnerable population” protections remain in place only “as long as Highmark does not make unilateral material changes to these programs. … UPMC reserves the right to withdraw from these arrangements if Highmark should take the position that it has the authority to revise the rates and fees payable under those arrangements unilaterally and materially.”
In UPMC’s view, Highmark — in terminating the existing contracts — indeed has moved unilaterally and materially. The region’s largest hospital system says it has no plans to agree to Highmark’s new Medicare-only contracts or to reward Highmark’s “illegal” behavior.
UPMC spokesman Paul Wood says it’s possible, given how hospitals bill for visits, that a Medicare patient could be billed for an out-of-network encounter with a physician.
“Generally, any patient-physician encounter in a hospital or clinic setting can generate at least two different charges: a physician charge and a hospital charge,” he said. “If a patient saw one of the doctors in Highmark’s ‘700 Club’ at an in-network hospital, presumably that could be out-of-network for the doctor but in-network for the facility.”
And that could — presumably — lead to higher medical bills.
Outside Pittsburgh, that sort of billing conflict isn’t unusual, particularly in emergency rooms but also in other areas of the hospital.
For example, radiologists, anesthesiologists and other specialists are commonly on loan to a hospital from out-of-network private practice groups. And as insurers try to cut back on cost by selling customers lower-priced, narrow-network health plans, confusion over which physicians and facilities are in-network, and which aren’t, is on the rise nationally.
In the Highmark-UPMC dispute, the summer consent decree requires that Highmark patients who end up in a UPMC emergency department will be treated at in-network rates, meaning there shouldn’t be any billing surprises for those seniors who enter the hospital through the ER.
But there are other routes into the hospital — a pre-scheduled surgery that results in a trip to the intensive care unit under the treatment of a hospitalist, for example.
The new dispute between Highmark and UPMC creates other complications for Highmark’s Medicare Advantage customers: The move seems to contradict earlier promises that at least some of the plans (though not the narrow-network Community Blue Medicare plans) would have access to all UPMC physicians. Also, seniors who selected a Security Blue plan two weeks ago thinking their primary care physician was in-network may now find that the doctor is out of network.
“The fact that Highmark undertook the terminations during the open enrollment period when some seniors have already made their choice for coverage” is duplicitous, UPMC says.
The Medicare open enrollment period, during which seniors can switch health plans, ends Dec. 7. UPMC has asked the state Department of Insurance and the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to intervene in the latest dispute, Mr. Wood said.
Highmark’s Mr. Billger said the confusion in the marketplace has been sown by UPMC. If UPMC wants to be in Highmark’s network so badly, it should have negotiated a full-access contract, he said.
“The reality is, UPMC has decided not to contact with Highmark,” Mr. Billger said. “By not contracting us, they’ve effectively abandoned Highmark members. … UPMC decided to walk away from a contract with Highmark,” not the other way around.
Highmark’s Medicare Advantage plans cover about 145,000 people in Western Pennsylvania.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.