Each year, Timothy and Diane Young select a Medicare Advantage plan for Diane's 81-year-old mother. Each year, the result of that process is the same: They pick a Highmark plan, because Diane’s mother likes her Blue Cross Blue Shield coverage.
This year?
“We've been on the phone all day,” Ms. Young said Tuesday.
The Youngs are in thick company, as seniors — and adult children who are helping them — are collectively trying to determine whether their primary care physicians and specialists are among the 700 UPMC doctors who, for now, have been fully removed from Highmark’s provider network.
That means neither under-65 commercial customers nor over-65 Medicare Advantage patients will be able to see those doctors, even though both Highmark and UPMC have promised for years that seniors wouldn't be affected by the break-up of the two Pittsburgh health giants.
The long-term, full-access commercial contract between Highmark and UPMC expires in 36 days.
Read More
This year, Mr. and Mrs. Young, who live in Glenshaw, thought about switching Mrs. Young’s mother to a UPMC Health Plan Medicare policy for 2015. But after investigating UPMC's offerings, the Youngs found that UPMC Health Plan didn’t cover her preferred blood-pressure medication.
Highmark’s plan did. So Mrs. Young’s mother, who lives in Bloomfield, subscribed to Highmark’s Security Blue HMO “Value RX” plan, at $52 a month.
That was Nov. 3.
Then, on Nov. 20, Highmark announced that it was severing its contracts with nearly 700 UPMC doctors. While Highmark says it has offered those same physicians Medicare-only reimbursement contracts, UPMC won’t let those doctors sign the revised contracts — meaning the doctors could be out-of-network for Highmark's senior customers.
“We're 11 days from the drop-dead date,” Mr. Young said, speaking of the federal deadline to switch or sign up for a new Medicare plan. The open enrollment period ends Dec. 7.
“You've got these folks who are 65 to 105 picking these plans,” which is confusing enough, Mr. Young said, even without Highmark and UPMC arguing about network access.
Mrs. Young said one of her mother's UPMC physicians appears to be in-network, based on information gleaned from phone calls to the doctors’ offices. Another doctor might be out of her mother's network, though.
In Verona, Claudia Broderick has the same concerns. The 79-year-old, who also signed up for a Highmark Security Blue plan, said she was alarmed by the robo-call she received from UPMC on Tuesday, warning about those 700 doctors — even though her primary care physician is independent and still in Highmark’s Medicare network.
“What are they trying to do? They're promising one thing. Then they're breaking their promises,” Ms. Broderick said. As for the robo-call, “They’re trying to scare everybody ... it’s not fair.”
While the Youngs would like to keep Mrs. Young's mother with Highmark, as is her preference, they are not opposed to a switch. In fact, this year, the couple — both under 65 — switched their own coverage away from Highmark to UPMC Health Plan.
Mr. Young, a former Highmark employee, had been covered by a Blue Cross plan "for 63 years, since I was an infant," but felt like his hand was forced by his longtime relationship with UPMC’s medical staff.
“It's been a long time [with Highmark], and I don't want to give it up,” he said. “But I don't want to give up my doctor.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.