More than 15 years after the state’s highest court ruled that Allegheny County’s property assessment system was illegal, local officials intend to propose a major change.

Allegheny County Council members on Tuesday will introduce a bill that requires the county to periodically reassess all property values, beginning in 2028.

“The best time to do [this] was yesterday,” said Allegheny County Councilman and bill co-sponsor Dan Gryzbek. “The second best time is today.

“We can’t continue to choose inaction on this topic, because every day that we do so, there are people in Allegheny County who are paying too much in taxes, and people who are paying too little.”

Advertise with us

Allegheny County is one of several counties statewide that has not revised the taxable value of all its properties — including homes, office buildings and warehouses — in more than a decade. That’s because Pennsylvania is the only state in the country that does not require regular property reassessments.

As a result, property taxes across the state are based on outdated values.

In Allegheny County, the last reassessment took place in 2012. Since then, neighborhoods have grown and shrunk, homes have deteriorated, office buildings have been renovated — all while taxable values remain largely frozen.

The new legislation — sponsored by Mr. Grzybek and council members Bethany Hallam and Lissa Geiger Shulman — would change that.

The bill calls for required reassessments of all properties countywide every three years, with the first in 2028.

Advertise with us

That could create a quick turnaround for local officials: Allegheny County’s last reassessment took three years to complete.

Mr. Gryzbek said those numbers could change as County Council considers the legislation, but the councilman does not want to pass a bill that allows for “a delay in tackling this.”

“Reassessments are the number one thing that we need to be handling,” he said.

‘There really couldn't be much more urgency’

Per the legislation, property values determined during reassessments would take effect in the following calendar year. Those values would then be used to calculate property tax bills, until the next countywide reassessment.

“The more regularly we are doing reassessments, the less disparate outcomes that you have,” Mr. Gryzbek said.

Advertise with us

In the 14 years since Allegheny County’s last reassessment, neighborhoods across the county have shifted. Property values in, for example, the Mon Valley and Quaker Valley, and the Hill District and Squirrel Hill, have trended in opposite directions over time while assessments have remained unchanged.

In practice, homeowners in growing neighborhoods are getting “artificial tax breaks,” Mr. Gryzbek said, while those in stagnant areas — including many low-income Pennsylvanians — often pay more than they should.

“Every day you have people that are paying more in taxes than they should be,” Mr. Gryzbek said. “There really couldn't be much more urgency than that.”

As of 2023, lower-valued properties were assessed at higher levels than more-valuable properties in Pittsburgh and six of the county’s other 10 largest municipalities, a study funded by the Heinz Endowments shows. The current system, the County Council bill says, is inequitable and violates Pennsylvania’s constitution.

Claims of unconstitutionality have long plagued Allegheny County’s property assessment practices.

Advertise with us

Property owners in the early 2000s sued the county over a lack of regular reassessments, arguing that the system violated a section of the state’s constitution that requires all residents to be taxed in the same manner. Pennsylvania’s Supreme Court weighed in on the case, writing in a 2009 opinion that there was “ample evidence” that Allegheny County’s system is unconstitutional and would produce inequities that “tend to increase over time.”

Over a decade later, nothing has changed in Allegheny County, the new County Council bill opines.

“[This bill] should have passed in the past,” Mr. Gryzbek said. “We have gone through this process in Allegheny County a number of times at this point, and every single time, it’s abundantly clear that the way in which we do reassessments … is deeply unfair.”

Meanwhile, more and more appeals are filed as more time passes since the last reassessment.

Property owners and the taxing bodies can file appeals when they believe a property is over or undervalued, meaning taxes are too high or too low.

Advertise with us

A metric called the “common level ratio” is applied to properties to adjust their value during appeals. The ratio is set by the state of Pennsylvania, based on data submitted by Allegheny County.

A lower ratio means appeals result in larger tax cuts. In recent years, appeals have slashed the value of some of the region’s most lucrative properties, eroding Pittsburgh’s property tax base — a critical revenue source for the city and county.

In 2022, a court ruled that Allegheny County was submitting skewed data to the state in an effort to keep the common level ratio from dropping lower — and triggering greater tax losses. The new County Council legislation includes additional protections “to prevent that from happening in the future,” Mr. Gryzbek said.

Under the bill’s provisions, a county official who submits inaccurate data to the state would not be permitted to maintain their position. Those who intentionally misrepresent property values could face a fine or criminal charges.

No such consequences have existed in the past, Mr. Gryzbek said.

Advertise with us

‘Pushed out of their homes due to their taxes’

The proposed legislation comes as the push for a countywide reassessment ramps up.

At least four ongoing lawsuits could trigger reassessments in Allegheny County, with decisions expected this year.

Court-ordered reassessments leave little in the county’s hands, Mr. Gryzbek said. By passing a bill now, the county can establish a process and timeline for reassessments before the courts weigh in, he said.

Three months ago, other County Council members drafted, and then shelved, a separate bill on reassessments that struck a different tone.

Sponsored by County Council President Pat Catena and others, it authorized the county’s legal team to sue the state over its property reassessment system, calling on the state to mandate periodic reassessments for all counties.

Advertise with us

“Just because [the state is] choosing inaction as their path doesn't mean that we should do the same,” Mr. Gryzbek said.

For decades, few local officials have taken on the mantle of reassessments: The effort can trigger broad tax increases, a risk that’s made the issue a third rail of county politics.

In Allegheny County, the last reassessment caused “well-chronicled financial challenges” for some lower-income homeowners, a Heinz Endowments study found — despite state laws that restrict the amount of revenue taxing bodies can earn from the effort.

But in Allegheny County, local officials are taking steps to protect residents. Last month, County Council approved a bill that would shield the most vulnerable residents from major tax increases during a reassessment.

“We certainly don't want seniors on fixed incomes who have called Allegheny County home for the entirety of their lives to be pushed out of their homes due to their taxes doubling,” Mr. Gryzbek said. “That legislation really protects those folks.”

Advertise with us

The new bill will be introduced at County Council’s regular meeting Tuesday and referred to a committee for further discussion.

Meanwhile, an independent board convened to advise Allegheny County on local matters is also hearing from experts about reassessments and will provide recommendations this year.

That guidance could be incorporated into legislation as it progresses, Mr. Gryzbek said.

“The fundamental question here is one of fairness,” he said. “There is no reason why such similar properties should be assessed at such widely disparate values.”