Allegheny County will soon face a lawsuit from a small agency within its own ranks.

The Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review plans to sue the county within the next month, the Post-Gazette has learned.

Board Chair Michael Suley said the six-member county board unanimously voted in favor of the lawsuit during a closed-door meeting last week.

At issue is the independence of the board, which handles thousands of assessment appeals filed each year by property owners and the taxing bodies — such as the city, the county and school districts — when they believe a property is over- or undervalued, meaning taxes are too high or too low.

Advertise with us

For years, county law prevented the board from scheduling its own appeals hearings, hiring its own staff and managing its budget, a system that undermined a fair and efficient appeals process and confused property owners countywide, Mr. Suley said.

During that time, a different county department — the Office of Property Assessments — was responsible for receiving all appeals once they’re filed and scheduling hearings for the appeals board.

That was supposed to change in 2026, thanks to a bill passed by Allegheny County Council in May. But more than three months into the new year, the appeals board is still understaffed and lacks control over its workforce and schedule, Mr. Suley said.

“The appeals board wants the keys to its house,” he said. “Nothing more.”

The board hears and decides thousands of appeals each year, raising, lowering or leaving intact the value of commercial and residential properties, upon which tax bills are based.

Advertise with us

In May, Allegheny County Council passed legislation that empowered the appeals board to accept appeals, schedule hearings, set a budget and hire new staff members, beginning in 2026. The appeals board, in turn, submitted a budget to the county’s finance and budget department for approval that included additional staff members on July 31, 2025, according to board administrator Barbara Baldwin.

But more than six months later, “nothing has changed,” Mr. Suley said: The appeals board still has just one employee and lacks the staff to schedule its own hearings.

That’s because Allegheny County has not approved all of the staff members that the board requested, Mr. Suley said. Only one open position with the appeals board appears on the county’s online job board, posted at the end of last month.

Allegheny County spokesperson Abigail Gardner said that no county department who requested additional staffing received approval for every position.

“Everyone was asked to manage with what we could afford to give them — that includes BPAAR,” Ms. Gardner said, adding that the county has requested more information from the appeals board regarding the need for additional positions.

Advertise with us

Mr. Suley had hoped at least four additional employees would be trained and working for the board by now.

“[Some people have] failed to embrace the concept that we’re going to be independent,” he said.

With two different departments involved in scheduling and hearing appeals, property owners often do not know where to direct questions about the appeals process as they move through it, Mr. Suley said.

The bill that Allegheny County Council passed was supposed to fix that by giving the Board of Property Assessments the power to schedule its own hearings. That way, one department handles the appeals process from start to finish.

The legislation passed by council also was intended to address what it saw as a conflict of interest: the employees currently scheduling appeals work in the Office of Property Assessments — the department that sets property values.

Advertise with us

Staff members who help establish property values “should not be involved in the appeals that are attempting to alter” those values, the council’s bill states.

“Parties filing appeals must feel confident that an impartial tribunal is hearing and deciding” their cases, Mr. Suley added.

Soon, the next appeals filing period will begin: From July 1 through Sept. 1, property owners and taxing bodies can lodge appeals to alter their 2027 tax bills.

Once that period begins, the appeals board will have to schedule and hear thousands of cases in an effort to make decisions before next year’s tax bills are mailed out in early 2027.

Last year, more than 6,500 appeals were filed. The board heard the majority of those cases before tax bills were issued. It hopes to finish the rest before the next filing period begins, to avoid beginning a new cycle with a backlog of appeals.

Advertise with us

But without additional staff and the ability to schedule its own hearings, Mr. Suley is worried the board will struggle to meet that goal.

“Adequate staffing is everything,” he said.

Meanwhile, Allegheny County could be approaching a court-ordered countywide reassessment — or a required re-evaluation of the value of every property in the county.

Pennsylvania is the only state in the country that does not require regular property reassessments. As a result, many counties — including Allegheny — have not reassessed in over a decade; in some areas, it’s been more than 50 years.

That means property taxes are largely based on outdated values unless appeals trigger changes. In many cases, homeowners in growing neighborhoods get tax breaks, while those in stagnant areas — often low-income Pennsylvanians — pay more than they should.

Advertise with us

At least four ongoing lawsuits are pushing for an immediate reassessment in Allegheny County or statewide — and local experts say chances of success are high.

A reassessment would mean shifts in property values across the county, a sea change that could trigger an immediate surge in appeals, Mr. Suley said.

“We want to be prepared,” he said.

The Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review has not yet filed suit but expects to before the end of April.