Heading into the new year, homeowners in Pittsburgh are facing a tax hike as the city continues to lose revenue.

In 2025, thousands of property tax appeals cost Pittsburgh more than $3 million — the latest in a series of blows to the city’s once-strong tax base driven by appeals in recent years.

And another hit is likely coming soon: More than 6,000 appeals filed across the county this year could lead to even more assessment cuts in Pittsburgh in 2026, according to data from Allegheny County.

Meanwhile, the small county board tasked with hearing appeals is facing a possible staffing shortage, all as the push for a countywide property reassessment is ramping up.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh Public Schools Solicitor Ira Weiss is representing both the school district and a homeowner in separate lawsuits in Allegheny County — two of several playing out right now that could trigger a countywide reassessment. City Council in early December also urged the county to immediately begin the process.

“It’s unexplainable,” Mr. Weiss said. “One of my frequent pieces of advice to clients is, hope is not a strategy.

“I don't know what the county expects to happen by doing nothing, but it's a general unending burden on local governments,” he said. “The taxpayers they claim to care about are the ones paying the price.”

Pennsylvania is the only state in the U.S. that does not require periodic property reassessments. As a result, most counties have not reassessed in well over a decade, including Allegheny County, where the last reassessment was in 2012.

That means property taxes paid across the county are based on values determined more than 10 years ago — unless appeals trigger changes.

Advertise with us

Property owners and the taxing bodies — the city, county and school district — can file appeals when they believe a property is over- or under-valued, meaning its taxes are too high or too low. As property values today stray further from their worth in 2012, more appeals are filed across the county.

For years, revenue from property taxes bolstered Pittsburgh’s finances. The city’s largest Downtown office towers were its biggest cash cow — the Golden Triangle represents about a quarter of Pittsburgh’s tax base.

But during the pandemic, high-profile buildings emptied out as work shifted online, and many office towers are still recovering. That trend, paired with a major change in the way the county calculates taxable value, has caused the worth of Downtown buildings to plummet.

Altogether, thousands of appeals filed over the past several years have cost the taxing bodies more than $11 million in badly needed revenue, with some of the largest cuts concentrated in Downtown Pittsburgh.

“We have a clear pattern of large property owners filing appeals and getting their reductions,” Mr. Weiss said. “It’s like free money.”

Advertise with us

In 2024 alone, over 4,000 appeals filed by property owners across the county resulted in the loss of more than $3 million in tax revenue in Pittsburgh. That money could help fund overtime pay for public safety officials, street paving or several years of bridge maintenance in the city.

Some of that $3 million is being paid out now in tax refunds to property owners. A seven-member county board is responsible for hearing thousands of appeals filed annually before the next year’s tax bills are sent out. It’s a difficult task that, in the past, has caused a mounting backlog in appeals — meaning some are decided after property owners receive their bills.

In those instances, the city must refund residents who pay their taxes before receiving a reduction.

In an effort to shrink the backlog, the county in recent years moved up the deadline to file appeals, giving the board more time to hear cases.

That change has made a huge difference — this year, the county has heard about 90% of all appeals filed in 2025, a “historic” accomplishment, said Mike Suley, chair of the Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review, which hears appeals.

Advertise with us

Of those, more than 1,500 are awaiting signoff from a member of the board. Another 450 cases remain to be heard.

The board expects to hear more than 90% of all appeals filed in the city of Pittsburgh before tax bills are sent out in February of 2026, Mr. Suley said. That would result in a much smaller backlog of appeals than in previous years.

But a staffing shortage on Mr. Suley’s board could impact those plans. Members of the board are appointed to three year terms by the county executive and County Council.

According to Mr. Suley, one seat on the board has sat vacant for more than two years — a new member was appointed, but has not yet been fully approved by the county. And the terms of two current members will expire at the end of 2025, leaving more seats unfilled. The county has been notified “dozens of times” about the vacancies but has not yet made any appointments, Mr. Suley said at a recent board meeting.

County Executive Sara Innamorato will make appointments to the board “at the end of this year or early next year,” a spokesperson said.

Advertise with us

Still, even if new members were chosen today, it is unlikely that they would assume their positions before the new year begins, Mr. Suley said. Once selected, appointees must go through an approval process. County Council gets 45 days to approve or deny members.

Although the county is in better shape than in past years, with hundreds of appeals remaining to be heard and signed off on weeks before the new year, “there’s no way we get through them all,” Mr. Suley said.

“This does handicap us,” he said, noting that the board could move faster with all seven members.

Some of those appeals could deliver serious blows to a city already desperately searching for new revenue sources as it battles a financial crisis.

Taxpayers in Pittsburgh are now facing several new rate increases:

Advertise with us

• City Council on Sunday approved a 20% tax hike, which Mayor Ed Gainey has indicated he will allow to pass into law.

• Pittsburgh Public Schools approved a 2% tax increase as part of its 2026 budget.

• Allegheny County raised taxes by 36% last year for its first hike in over a decade.

City Council members have called for increased scrutiny of the city’s spending, with at least one representative warning that without the tax hike, Pittsburgh could fall back under state financial oversight.

“These tax increases you’re seeing are largely tied to this problem — the decline in revenue, the erosion of the tax base and these refunds,” Mr. Weiss said.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, from appeals heard in the past two weeks alone, all three taxing bodies stand to lose over $585,000 in tax revenue in the new year.

At least 66 of the hundreds of appeals remaining to be heard concern commercial properties in Pittsburgh with a combined assessed value of just under $1 billion, Mr. Suley said. That includes one building worth $120 million alone — which could lead to a major loss of tax revenue.

Many of those appeals will be heard in the new year, Mr. Suley said.

“How this all washes out, we’ll know within 60 days,” he said.