The taxable value of one of the Strip District’s newest and most highly occupied office buildings has fallen by more than 60% — a dramatic change that could cost the city, county and school district dearly, and lead to even more reductions, experts said Tuesday.
The Allegheny County Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review has approved major cuts to the taxable value of the Vision on 15th, an office building on Smallman Street that opened in 2022, after property owner NAI Burns Scalo appealed the property’s assessment twice. The real estate firm leases and operates the property.
The changes bring the property’s new assessment from around $61 million to nearly $22 million for 2025, a steep cut that experts say could spur another wave of appeals — and reductions — as pressure on the city of Pittsburgh’s strained budget continues to mount.
Downtown represents about a quarter of Pittsburgh’s tax base, and its property tax revenues for years propped up the city’s finances until a series of assessment cuts to high-profile office buildings after the pandemic cost the city millions of dollars in needed revenue.
But unlike the Vision on 15th, those buildings were mostly under-leased and struggling after companies ditched their office space during and after COVID-19 lockdowns.
“If you think you can only appeal a commercial property because you’ve had tenants move out, think again,” county appeals board chair Michael Suley said of the cut to Vision on 15th. “This is a new wrinkle.”
Read More
“Absent a reassessment, the trend will be less income [and] less tax revenues,” he added.
‘The antithesis of what has happened Downtown’
Pennsylvania is the only state in the U.S. that does not require periodic property reassessments. As a result, most counties have not reassessed in well over a decade, including Allegheny County, where the last reassessment was in 2012.
That means property taxes paid across the county are based on values determined more than 10 years ago — unless appeals trigger changes.
Property owners and the taxing bodies — the city, county and school district — can file appeals when they believe a property is over- or under-assessed, meaning taxes are too high or too low.
Because of recent changes to the common level ratio, a metric used to calculate taxable value at hearings, appeals today lead to larger changes than in the past. The ratio accounts for the widening gulf between the value of properties in 2012, when the last reassessment occurred, and sale prices today.
As those values stray further apart, the common level ratio drops lower. The metric, set by a state board, has fallen from 87.5% to 50.14% over a series of cuts in the past six years alone.
At the 87.5% ratio, the taxable value of a property worth $100,000 would be $87,500, for instance. Under today’s ratio, its taxable value would be just $50,140.
“What happens next year?” said Dominick Gambino, a former county assessment director who now is a consultant for school districts and municipalities. “It will fall lower and lower.”
Because the ratio has dropped so low, buildings that are performing well, with little to no vacancy, can now obtain drastic cuts to their taxable value via appeals, Mr. Suley said.
The Strip District’s Vision on 15th, a mixed-use building with office, retail and restaurant space, is almost fully occupied after months of strong leasing activity, according to the Jones Lang LaSalle real estate firm. The property has attracted companies from Downtown, including the financial services firm Wilshire, as firms continue to downsize in favor of higher-quality office space.
While the property’s market value has decreased slightly since it was last assessed in 2012 — in line with a national drop in the value of office space — the application of today’s common level ratio is what caused such a steep cut to the building’s assessment, Mr. Suley said.
It is “the antithesis of what has happened Downtown,” Mr. Suley said, because the Strip District is in the midst of a growth spurt. Thousands of residential units across the neighborhood are in the pipeline, while demand for the Strip’s modern, upgraded office space has outpaced supply, a Jones Lang LaSalle representative said.
“Everyone knows the Strip District is where all of the action is,” Mr. Suley said.
Still, properties in the neighborhood could now be “ripe for appeal,” he said, because the common level ratio has dropped so low.
‘Warning bells and flashing red lights’
A wave of successful appeals in the pandemic's wake already has cost the city tremendously.
As Downtown office buildings emptied out, their value plummeted, delivering the “biggest hit to city finances,” which were also impacted by overspending in recent years, city Controller Rachael Heisler previously said in a report.
Overall, assessment cuts in recent years have cost the city, county and Pittsburgh Public Schools more than $11 million in revenue.
Amid the loss, Pittsburgh Public Schools is proposing a 4% tax increase in its 2026 budget, while Pittsburgh City Council is considering a 30% tax hike and asking all departments to draft proposals to scale back spending. Allegheny County raised taxes earlier this year for the first time in over a decade.
On Tuesday, City Council introduced a measure urging the county to begin the process of a countywide reassessment.
“One could say that there have been enough warning bells and flashing red lights that the county administration would have come to a consensus and agreed to do a countywide reassessment,” Pittsburgh Public Schools Solicitor Ira Weiss said.
Mr. Weiss is representing the school district and a Churchill homeowner in separate lawsuits that aim to force the county to begin a reassessment, two of several ongoing suits with similar aims.
Critics have expressed concern that a reassessment could increase taxes for homeowners across the county and pointed to a state law that limits the amount of revenue local taxing bodies can collect from reassessments.
Others — including Mr. Weiss and Mr. Gambino — say the taxing bodies will continue to lose revenue without a change to the status quo.
“It's like the captain of the Titanic saying there’s no iceberg,” Mr. Weiss said. “The risk is continuing to grow.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.