For years, separate battles over inclusionary zoning have played out in City Hall and a federal courthouse — one to strike down the contested policy, and one to expand its reach.

But a federal judge on Monday changed that, issuing a ruling that ended a three-year effort to nix the housing policy.

Local developers had asked for the court to immediately halt inclusionary zoning, saying it violated state law and jeopardized several housing projects, including some already underway.

But U.S. District Judge Robert Colville disagreed, saying that halting the policy would be an “extraordinary remedy” only granted in limited circumstances. The Builders’ Association, Judge Colville argued, failed to prove that its members will be “irreparably harmed” if the policy is not paused right away.

Advertise with us

Additional legal challenges are possible; the city’s legal team could not be immediately reached for comment.

The inclusionary zoning debate

Inclusionary zoning requires developers to offer some reduced rents in all new buildings with more than 20 units. The policy was introduced in Lawrenceville six years ago, and has since expanded into Oakland, Polish Hill and Bloomfield.

Inclusionary zoning supporters have long argued that the policy increases Pittsburgh’s short supply of affordable housing units. But developers and some residents counter that it can also drive up costs, delaying construction starts.

In 2022, just after Mayor Ed Gainey introduced inclusionary zoning in two new neighborhoods, the Builders’ Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh filed a lawsuit against the city and local officials over the policy, kicking off a three-year courtroom battle. The association represents more than 400 builders, developers, realtors and more across Western Pennsylvania and claimed in the lawsuit that inclusionary zoning is unconstitutional.

The policy, the group maintains, violates state law and forces developers — who earn less from marked-down rents — to fund more affordable units across Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

Action in the suit increased this summer when the association called for the immediate pause on inclusionary zoning in all neighborhoods where it currently exists, arguing that the policy is causing “immediate and irreparable harm” to a developer behind an active project in Oakland.

An affiliate of Shadyside-based developer Walnut Capital is building a 160-unit, 11-story apartment building on McKee Place in Oakland, where the zoning policy applies as of 2023. The developer plans to market the building to college students, and each affordable unit can add between $400,000 and $600,000 in additional costs, Walnut Capital founding partner and president Todd Reidbord previously told the Post-Gazette.

Inclusionary zoning has stalled several other developments across the city, Goldberg, Kamin and Garvin attorney Jonathan Kamin argued in the lawsuit, representing the Builders’ Association. According to Mr. Kamin, at least three additional projects — including property sales and new residential complexes in Polish Hill and Oakland — have faced delays caused by inclusionary zoning.

In the case of both housing complexes, developers reduced the number of units planned in order to skirt affordability requirements because they could not afford mounting costs, Mr. Kamin argued. During a hearing last month, Mr. Kamin said that within eight months, Walnut Capital’s project in Oakland will be completed. The developer needs clarity on who can lease units, he maintained.

Heading to state court?

The judge’s decision leaves the door open for the Builders’ Association to file future lawsuits against the policy.

Advertise with us

Judge Colville declined to rule on the constitutionality of inclusionary zoning, claiming that the matter falls outside of the court’s jurisdiction and closing the case.

“Nothing in this ruling addresses the actual legality of the city’s inclusionary zoning requirements, which we think are, have been and remain 100% illegal,” Mr. Kamin said, adding that he intends to pursue the case in state court.

Since the decision was issued, several groups have contacted Mr. Kamin about joining the case as plaintiffs, he added.

The court’s decision comes as the city’s Planning Commission prepares to reconsider Mr. Gainey’s bid to expand inclusionary zoning.

Before launching his re-election campaign last year, Mr. Gainey proposed expanding the policy citywide, with limited exceptions. After months of heated debate and lengthy public meetings, City Council shot down an alternative proposal to the mayor’s plan.

Advertise with us

Councilwoman Erika Strassburger in October introduced critical amendments to the mayor’s proposal that allow developers a way out of inclusionary zoning: groups can pay a fee to evade the policy, but earn benefits if they opt in.

City Council narrowly passed the councilwoman’s amendments in a rare, narrow vote, sending them to the Planning Commission for further review. The commission has not yet scheduled a hearing on the proposal.

Mr. Kamin said he plans to bring his case forward regardless of the city’s decisions.