Pittsburgh City Planning Commission members on Tuesday and into the early morning hours Wednesday backed legislation proposed by Mayor Ed Gainey that would extend inclusionary zoning requirements citywide.

Here’s what that means.

What is inclusionary zoning?

In basic terms, inclusionary zoning is intended to either require or incentivize new housing projects to include a level of affordable housing for low- to middle-income residents. In Pittsburgh, the model is in place in Lawrenceville, Bloomfield, Polish Hill and areas of Oakland.

 
 
 
View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (@pittsburghpg)

What inclusionary housing practices are proposed for Pittsburgh?

Under Gainey’s proposal, developers who build 20 or more units of housing would be required to set aside 10% of each development as affordable for households at or below 50% of the area median income, or $40,500 for a family of two.

Advertise with us

While the commission backed Gainey’s plan, it rejected a proposal from Councilman Bob Charland that would have left inclusionary zoning implementation up to each neighborhood and tasked the Urban Redevelopment Authority to “fully fund” financial gaps in projects involving the creation of affordable housing.

While not up for vote in Pittsburgh after the rejection of Mr. Charland’s measure, under various unique policies across the country, inclusionary zoning is sometimes incentivized rather than required. It can partially offset the cost of providing affordable housing through measures like tax abatements, parking reductions, or approval to build at higher densities, according to nonprofit advocacy organization Grounded Solutions Network.

Councilman Bob Charland listens to residents speak during a Planning Commission public comment session Tuesday. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

What is the intent of inclusionary zoning?

The concept was first implemented in Fairfax, Va., in 1971 before it was struck down in court as unconstitutional, according to The National Housing Coalition. It was first realized in 1974 in Montgomery County, Md.

Since then, more than 1,000 similar programs have been enacted in 700 jurisdictions over 35 states, plus Washington, D.C.

In essence, it’s a check against gentrification.

Advertise with us

Policies are typically implemented in rapidly growing cities and neighborhoods (with rising housing costs) with the intent of creating communities of mixed income earners and heading off impending flight of native residents potentially priced out of developing markets as new residents move in.

In maintaining income diversity in a given area, the policies are also intended to effectually maintain racial and ethnic diversity in affluent neighborhoods, providing low-income and minority populations with better access to high-quality schools, hospitals and transportation and increasing their chances at positive life outcomes.

Proponents also say it helps keep housing prices down due to predicted increased supply.

What do opponents say about inclusionary zoning?

Opponents on Tuesday said inclusionary zoning hasn’t worked in the four neighborhoods where it has been implemented — Lawrenceville, Bloomfield, Polish Hill and Oakland — and that it’s unproven as a concept.

Some in attendance indicated mandating inclusionary zoning will hinder development due to lack of incentives provided for developers in Gainey’s proposal that might encourage them not to place a given building project in another city where they could reap the highest possible rent across their new build.

Advertise with us

Tom Frank — chapter executive director of NAOIP Pittsburgh, a regional association of developers, owners, investors and commercial real estate professionals — predicted that developers “will simply flee to other areas” to get better deals.

Residents line up to speak during a Planning Commission public comment session regarding inclusionary zoning on Tuesday. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Representatives from Lawrenceville United community group refuted that notion, stating that since inclusionary zoning was implemented there in 2019, total housing production is up 96%.

Planning Commission member Steve Mazza, who abstained from vote on Gainey’s measure due to affiliation with the Greater Pennsylvania Council of Carpenters, said he feared that the expanded zoning would hurt his industry.

Additionally, in areas where a policy is incentivized rather than required, inclusionary zoning could potentially lead to the unintended consequence of an older unit containing ample affordable housing unit being razed to make room for a new development with comparatively less affordable units based on a new minimum requirement.

What’s needed for inclusionary zoning to pass?

The Planning Commission sent Mr. Gainey’s bill to City Council with a positive recommendation, meaning it will require only a majority vote to pass.

Mr. Charland’s amendments, rejected by the Planning Commission, go before City Council with a negative recommendation, requiring votes from seven of the nine members to pass.