A high-stakes meeting of the Planning Commission of the City of Pittsburgh this week could help to set the course of development in Pittsburgh for decades to come, as well as influence the political fate of Mayor Ed Gainey. We urge the commission not to bow to political pressure, and not to choose between the pair of major zoning amendments before it. Both options are flawed enough to merit negative recommendations from the commission, which would render both dead-on-arrival in council.
This would force what should have occurred from a beginning: a collaborative, deliberative, good-faith policy discussion resulting in a compromise for the good of Pittsburgh.
No need to choose
At the Tuesday meeting, the commission will consider two mutually exclusive amendments to the city’s zoning code, both of which would represent significant overhauls.
The first is Mr. Gainey’s suite of zoning ordinances, which would make the city’s zoning rules less restrictive in several key respects, but would also impose onerous “inclusionary zoning” (IZ) requirements — that is, a minimum of 10% of units set aside as “deeply affordable” essentially in perpetuity — on new housing developments of greater than 20 units in each of Pittsburgh’s 90 neighborhoods.
The second proposal has been introduced by Councilman Bob Charland of the South Side. This would allow neighborhoods to opt into a flexible IZ program that would include significant incentives for developers to participate, including direct subsidies, while also allowing them to buy their way out of mandated affordability with a per-unit fee.
Both Mr. Gainey’s and Mr. Charland’s proposals are complicated changes to the most complicated aspect of city code: zoning. They will have enormous effects on land use, development and everyday life in the city — some predictable, many unpredictable — for decades to come. Neither has been comprehensively and independently vetted.
Mr. Gainey’s citywide IZ is clearly, at least in part, about scoring a political victory based on a campaign promise to enhance affordability, while he faces tough primary campaign; Mr. Charland’s counterproposal is clearly, at least in part, about denying him that victory and stopping what the councilman believes, rightly, to be bad policy from becoming law.
The Planning Commission has the authority to offer positive or negative recommendations on zoning code amendments. A positive recommendation serves as a public imprimatur and means the bill requires the typical simple majority, five of nine, to pass council. A negative recommendation, on the other hand, triggers a requirement to receive seven votes on council. It is unlikely that either bill can get to five. It’s certain that neither can get to seven.
There is no reason for the commission to grease the skids for either proposal, neither of which is ready for final passage. And there is every reason to force both sides back to the drawing board to craft a comprehensive compromise.
Wrong policy, wrong city
Inclusionary zoning may sound simple — Pittsburgh needs more affordable housing, so let’s just mandate it by law — but in reality its effects can vary wildly based on the way it’s crafted and the conditions of the location where it’s applied. On the balance, IZ programs tend to slow market-rate residential growth while having mixed effects on the production of affordable units. Those that succeed in triggering big gains for affordability without dampening the overall market tend to share several traits, but two predominate.
First, they’re in high-cost, high-growth markets. This does not describe Pittsburgh. It could describe neighborhoods within Pittsburgh, like Lawrenceville. Helpfully, this is also the neighborhood where IZ has been tested the longest, with a policy in place since 2019.
But the results are mixed at best. Different analysts with different methodologies have come to different conclusions, but the best comparative evidence shows that Lawrenceville has lagged the South Side — a neighborhood with similar characteristics but no IZ requirement — in overall residential development since IZ came into force. In other words, IZ has had ambiguous-to-negative results in the neighborhood where it’s most likely to succeed. That doesn’t bode well for extending it citywide.
Second, successful IZ policies are generously funded, so developers don’t struggle to finance their projects. This is especially important in a high-construction-cost, low-growth city like Pittsburgh. There are no direct subsidies in Mr. Gainey’s citywide IZ proposal, and the alternative — called “subsidy layering” by advocates — doesn’t add up.
IZ proponents claim that developers can be made whole by a combination of tax abatement programs and federal Housing Choice Vouchers (HCV, also known as Section 8). But the abatements they tout are 10-year programs, when the affordability constraints are in practice perpetual. And HCV is a notoriously difficult program to navigate: This board has documented the struggles of the Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh to administer it here.
Humorously, one of IZ’s most strident supporters, Councilwoman Barb Warwick, knows this first-hand: She and her husband own several properties, which he manages — as Ms. Warwick has said herself on the Bluesky social media platform — without accepting Section 8 vouchers because HACP is so incompetent. Yet she insists that developers participate in the HCV program, and blames them if they don’t.
The truth is that, nationwide, most IZ programs are in states which require landlords to take Section 8 vouchers. Pennsylvania is not one of them.
Back to the drawing board
It is possible and necessary to use the zoning code to encourage greater housing affordability in Pittsburgh. Many of Mr. Gainey’s other proposals — permitting accessory dwelling units, ending parking minimums, shrinking minimum lot sizes — will do that by encouraging more, denser construction around the city. Those should be greenlit by the Planning Commission.
But citywide IZ won’t have this effect. Mr. Charland’s bill, meanwhile, requires much more significant vetting and attention to detail. For policies whose effects are measured in decades, there is no rush. The Planning Commission should reject both IZ bills, so Mr. Gainey and City Council can collaboratively produce a consensus proposal that will enhance affordability while encouraging growth.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.