Despite being dubbed “a political stunt” and in direct competition with legislation proposed by Mayor Ed Gainey to expand affordable housing, a new amendment to Pittsburgh’s zoning code is on the table.
The competing legislation was introduced earlier this month by Councilman Bob Charland, a vocal critic of the mayor. At the heart of the issue is an affordable housing mandate known as inclusionary zoning.
Bloomfield, Lawrenceville and Polish Hill already have an inclusionary zoning overlay district that requires developers to designate a portion of units in new developments to low-income residents.
Mr. Gainey’s and Mr. Charland’s bills differ on how many units should be included and at what level of affordability.
The largest difference is that Mr. Gainey’s idea, which was part of a package of zoning amendments he introduced in September, would require inclusionary zoning across all neighborhoods, while Mr. Charland’s would leave it up to residents.
Councilman Anthony Coghill, during debate last week, said he would vote for anything that blocked Mr. Gainey’s bill to ensure that inclusionary zoning would “not be forced on my district.”
Read More
Mr. Charland added an amendment to his bill last week that intended to grandfather in the neighborhoods that already have inclusionary zoning, so that they would not have to go through the approval process again.
In a 6-3 vote Wednesday, council recommended that Mr. Charland’s bill be sent to the Planning Commission. Council members Deb Gross, Barb Warwick and Khari Mosley all voted against the recommendation.
Mr. Gainey’s package of zoning amendments has been in the hands of the planners since late September, and debates about multiple portions of it are ongoing.
Mr. Gainey’s office did not respond to a request for comment Wednesday, but previously criticized Mr. Charland's bill, calling it a “blank check of city tax dollars” for corporate developers to “build units that over half of our residents cannot afford.”
In his statement, Mr. Gainey said the councilman’s proposal “is not reflective of the future that we envision for Pittsburgh, one where every resident is afforded an opportunity to thrive, but instead will continue to prioritize corporate interests over working families.”
During debate over Mr. Charland's legislation for the past two weeks, Ms. Gross and Ms. Warwick have been the most outspoken opponents.
Ms. Warwick said the amendment was a “political stunt intended to slow down inclusionary zoning.”
“I’m not in support of sending this to [the Planning Commission] because it has so many internal contradictions,” Ms. Gross said. “There are ideas that we absolutely should be exploring, but this language has got too many internal flaws.”
Other criticism raises concerns about the broad pool of residents eligible for affordable housing units. Mr. Gainey’s legislation is for people who make at or below 50% of the area median income, while Mr. Charland’s designates people making up to 99% of the AMI as eligible.
“It sets affordability at a level to serve the wealthiest renters rather than the poorest renters,” Ms. Warwick said. “The affordable housing we need is for our poorest renters.”
Additionally, council President Dan Lavelle criticized the bill during last week’s meeting for putting a financial burden on the city.
Mr. Charland’s legislation requires that any financial gap “burdening the creation” of the affordable units will be funded by the city, the Urban Redevelopment Authority or the Housing Authority of Pittsburgh.
But the city can’t compel the URA or the housing authority to pay for anything, Mr. Lavelle said during last week’s debate.
“That would literally almost bankrupt us,” he said.
The Planning Commission, which handles all zoning changes, will do its own review of the legislation and send a recommendation to council for a final vote.
Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith said there was a chance that lawmakers who voted Wednesday to send the bill to council won’t vote for it later on.
“We obviously feel different about what we’re doing here,” she said.
Regardless of what happens with the legislation, multiple council members agreed that there needed to be more conversation about inclusionary zoning and affordable housing.
“[This] really highlights the fact that this is a very big change to our zoning code and something that needs to be considered very deliberately and thoughtfully,” Mr. Charland said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.