The Planning Commission on Tuesday voted against establishing Donny’s Place — once a safe haven for the queer community — as the city’s first official LGBTQ+ historic landmark.

The decision — after nearly two hours of public discussion — could fast-track the shuttered bar’s demolition, but leaves the door open for memorializing its history in other ways.

Up for debate Tuesday were both the bar’s role as a longtime anchor of queer life in Pittsburgh and its current condition after a fire tore through its interior late last year.

“It's clear there's a lot of history at this site, and that it probably deserves a respectful and meaningful recognition of its historic significance,” commission Chairwoman Lashawn Burton-Falk said. “That's much more likely to be accomplished through a historic marker or other sort of exhibit than designation for a building that has been through a fire.”

Advertise with us

The vote was the latest development in a six-year saga over Donny’s Place. The city’s Historic Review Commission, in a rare move, issued “no recommendation” on the bar’s future after commission members reached an impasse at the tail end of a lengthy meeting last month.

Developers Laurel Communities in 2019 proposed a townhome project that requires the bar’s demolition. The development has prompted two lawsuits and put representatives of the late Donald Thinnes — Donny’s founder — at odds with former patrons.

Pittsburgh City Council will make the final call on the bar’s status at a meeting yet to be scheduled.

Last October, Polish Hill residents Elizabeth Anderson and Matthew Cotter submitted an application for the historic designation of Donny’s Place, with support from local historian Dade Lemanski and Preservation Pittsburgh. In a presentation Tuesday, nominators said that the bar served as a meeting place for queer organizations and helped spread information about HIV/AIDS before it was easily accessible.

“Anything of comparable longevity and historic value really has already been ground down by development,” the historian Lemanski said Tuesday.

Advertise with us

Historic designation does not prevent changes to a property, but it subjects future exterior alterations — including demolition — to a city review. The Historic Review Commission evaluates applications and recommends that a property should or should not qualify; the Planning Commission’s review comes before City Council makes the final call.

While the last review focused on the building’s significance to Pittsburgh history, the Planning Commission evaluated how historic designation fits into the city’s land use goals.

Nominators argued that past city plans have set standards for development that support Donny’s historic designation, but others disagreed. The city will soon consider zoning amendments to encourage development around transit sites, including Herron Station, just steps from Donny’s Place. Historic designation would contradict that effort, speakers said Tuesday, stalling projects like the Laurel Communities complex.

“This is exactly the type of location where the city has sought for quite a while now to build more housing,” Pro Housing Pittsburgh representative Nick Rizzio said.

Plans to raze Donny’s Place and build 19 townhouses on the nearly 2.5-acre lot have been stalled for years, first by a lawsuit over the development’s impact on Polish Hill, and then by the historic status nomination.

Advertise with us

Last month, it became the subject of a new case. Goldberg, Kamin and Garvin attorney Jonathan Kamin is representing the estate of Donald Thinnes and Laurel Communities in a lawsuit against the historic status nominators. The suit alleges that the historic designation process is being used to intentionally “interfere with the development.”

Thinnes sold his bar in 2019 to Laurel Communities for over $1 million, according to the suit. The late bar owner was preparing the lot for development before he passed in 2022, his friend and executor of his estate Thomas Yargo said. The suit seeks over $50,000 in damages.

Ms. Anderson and Matthew Cotter, the historic status nominators, filed a motion to dismiss the suit last Tuesday, claiming that it violates their freedom of expression. Mr. Kamin said he intends to file a response.

“I sat in a room with Donny a year or two ago where he had tears in his eyes because he was in the process of dying penniless because this property has been held up,” said Marty Healey, one of several friends to speak out against historic designation. “Now we're here today after his death, trying to parse this out.”

Mr. Healey argued that amidst rising homophobia, the city’s queer community cannot afford to “divert resources” toward restoring a derelict building, and should instead focus on supporting LGBTQ+ causes in other ways.

Advertise with us

Before he passed, Thinnes donated archival materials from Donny’s Place to the Heinz History Center. Speakers argued that those files honor the shared legacy of the bar and their friend.

Still, some queer residents of Polish Hill and across the city stood on the other side of the aisle.

“We are facing a bad time as a community because we have been told throughout history that we don't exist or are forced to hide again,” said Pittsburgh resident Jacob Klinger, speaking in support of historic status. “With all due respect, when people walk down the sidewalk or get off a bus, they don't see those photo albums, however wondrous they are. I wish they did, but they do see buildings … and that's crucial.”

Ultimately, commission members zeroed in on the wish of Thinnes, who was ostensibly opposed to preservation.

If Laurel Communities proceeds with their townhome project, commission member Phillip Wu said, they will appear before the Planning Commission again. That could create an opportunity for an interpretive sign, monument or other historic marker, he said.

City Council’s hearing on Donny’s Place will be scheduled within 120 days. Nominators will need at least six affirmative votes for a historic designation.