As a Pittsburgh Historic Review Commission meeting neared its third hour last week, chairwoman Lucia Aguirre was at a loss for words.

“I think — at least in my history as chair — this is the first time we’ve found ourselves in this place,” she said.

Minutes later, commission members made an unusual move: They voted to give “no recommendation” on whether Donny’s Place — a now-closed gay bar in Polish Hill — should become Pittsburgh’s first queer historic landmark.

The board’s decision left the fate of Donny’s Place, vacant and timeworn at the base of Herron Avenue, hanging in the balance.

Advertise with us

For six years, the bar’s future has remained uncertain.

Upper St. Clair-based Laurel Communities in 2019 proposed a townhome project at the site that would require it to be demolished. But the project has spurred two lawsuits and pitted representatives of the late Donald Thinnes — the former owner of Donny’s — against former patrons of his bar.

And at the Wednesday meeting, the issue confounded the commission.

(Click to enlarge)

“We’re simply not making a recommendation,” commission member Richard Snipes said. “We can’t agree.”

‘A nondescript place on purpose’

Today, bricks are missing from the plain facade of the Polish Hill bar, shuttered in 2022. But between its gated door and green awning, a red light remains.

Advertise with us

The light is no longer lit, but when it was, it signaled that Donny’s Place, established in the early 1970s, was open — a safe haven for the queer community, according to local historians. Today, a small sign, partially intact, displays the bar’s name.

Most of the city’s gay bars were once similarly unassuming, explained Timothy Haggerty, a Carnegie Mellon University history professor involved in the Pittsburgh Queer History Project, which researches Pittsburgh’s queer nightlife.

“Of course it’s a nondescript place,” he said. “It was a nondescript place on purpose.”

Originally a social club for Polish immigrants, Donald Thinnes’ eponymous bar operated under several names after he took ownership. For nearly half a century, it remained a cornerstone of queer life, circulating information about HIV/AIDS before it was widespread, serving as a meeting place, and hosting fundraisers and events.

The bar predated the founding of organizations like Shepherd Wellness Community, which supports people with HIV/AIDS in Western Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

“Donny’s was a site where queer and trans people and people with HIV/AIDS went to find each other and take care of each other when often, there was not enough of that care available elsewhere,” historian Dade Lemanski said at Wednesday’s meeting.

In October, Polish Hill residents Elizabeth Anderson and Matthew Cotter, a director of the Polish Hill Civic Association, submitted an application for the historic designation of Donny’s Place with support from Lemanski and Preservation Pittsburgh, a nonprofit focused on historic conservation. That came after a Change.org petition, which has nearly 300 signatures.

Historic designation does not prevent changes to a property. But it does subject exterior alterations — including demolition — to a city review. The Historic Review Commission evaluates applications and typically recommends that a property should or should not qualify. The Planning Commission conducts the next review before City Council makes a final call.

Last month, the commission voted that Donny’s Place potentially met two criteria: its association with important events in Pittsburgh’s history, and its connection to a person who contributed to the city.

‘Sites of gay life are threatened and disappearing’

At Wednesday’s meeting, commission members considered the arguments.

Advertise with us

“If I had a dollar for every time I rode past this place, I’d be a rich man. I wouldn’t be sitting here at this table right now,” Mr. Snipes said. “But I never knew it was a gay bar, and that’s my point — if we’re talking about the history of Pittsburgh, it should have meaning to a lot of people.”

Supporters countered that the bar’s discretion was intentional, and that the commission had received more than 100 letters pushing for historic status.

“It is not a remarkable building, and it might be in bad shape,” Polish Hill resident Caleb Gamble said. “But Pittsburgh's history is a history of people doing remarkable things in nondescript buildings.”

According to supporters, Donald Thinnes was a member of several queer advocacy groups, including the Pittsburgh Tavern Guild, an association of gay bar owners. He used Donny’s Place to recruit participants for the Pitt Men’s Study, a University of Pittsburgh initiative that has tracked about 3,000 men for HIV research since 1984, they said.

But some commission members wondered: Was Donny’s a trailblazer? Or one of many bars engaged in such work?

Advertise with us

“Is this the first in a series of dominoes?” commission member James Hill asked.

Other queer establishments have come and gone. The Holiday Bar in Oakland closed in 2007 and was torn down. A cigar lounge now sits at the site of the Traveler’s Social Club on Hamilton Avenue. David’s and Jazz’s on Liberty Avenue both are gone.

“If there were a bunch of bars that did [this work], that's fine,” Mr. Haggerty said. “But those bars are gone.”

With demolition on the table, commission members grappled with the finality of their decision, while nominators emphasized urgency.

“Sites of gay life are threatened and disappearing due to encroaching development,” their application argues.

Advertise with us

Lawyer Jonathan Kamin, of Goldberg, Kamin and Garvin, represents the estate of Donald Thinnes and Laurel Communities, the developers of the proposed townhome project, in a lawsuit arguing against the historic status. Laurel Communities plans to demolish Donny’s Place to make way for 19 townhouses on the bar’s nearly 2.5-acre lot.

The project is stalled. The lawsuit alleges that the nominators are using the historic designation process to intentionally “interfere with the development.”

The suit also claims the nomination goes against Thinnes’ wishes. He sold the bar in 2019 to Laurel Communities for more than $1 million, according to the suit. And he prepared the lot for development before his death, said Thomas Yargo, Mr. Thinnes’ friend and executor of his estate.

The suit seeks more than $50,000 in damages. It claims that Laurel Communities has already spent more than $250,000 on the development, and that the estate risks losing proceeds from the sale.

“It’s a very sad abuse of process that the petitioners are engaging in, and it is not at all consistent with the purpose of the Historic Review Commission,” Mr. Kamin said.

Advertise with us

‘People feel a little left behind’

The townhome project is part of broader debate over development in Polish Hill.

The Pittsburgh Planning Commission this month will consider zoning amendments that encourage development around transit sites, including Herron Station, next to Donny’s Place.

Many Polish Hill residents worry that increased development could affect the community’s character, affordability and environment, said Colleen Shuda, president of the Polish Hill Civic Association.

“I think people feel a little left behind,” Ms. Shuda said. “Can we get problems fixed that we’ve been asking for help with for so long before we start focusing on these pretty, new, big apartment buildings that will bring in people in a much higher economic status?”

Those concerns echo a 2021 lawsuit filed by the Polish Hill Civic Association against the redevelopment of Donny’s Place, arguing it violated zoning rules and could harm the neighborhood. The case became moot after Laurel Communities revised its plans, according to Mr. Kamin.

Advertise with us

The revisions reduced the number of townhomes from 27 to 19 — just below the threshold for inclusionary zoning in Polish Hill, which requires projects with 20 or more units to designate a set percentage as affordable.

“After all this time and aggravation and cost associated with their actions, we cannot afford to go ahead and do inclusionary zoning on the site,” said Mr. Kamin.

“I think there’s just a big disconnect,” Ms. Shuda said, “between what we’re seeing happening around the city and what we’d like to see happen.”

Historic designation could be step one in a larger plan for Donny’s Place, the nominators wrote in their Change.org petition.

The status offers a chance to “possibly reshape this impending gentrification” while honoring the bar’s legacy, the petition says.

Advertise with us

“We know there can’t be too many safe, affordable homes at this moment of critically scarce housing,” the petition says. “We also welcome other ideas to advocate for at the site.”

According to Mr. Kamin, the Polish Hill Civic Association several years ago turned down an offer to build housing on a small portion of the Donny’s Place lot.

‘Unsafe and severely compromised’

A fire damaged Donny’s Place in 2024, and at Wednesday’s meeting, Mr. Kamin argued the bar was “not appropriate to preserve for any reason.” He presented a structural engineer’s report on the fire damage.

“The building is in extremely deplorable condition,” the report said. “It is unsafe and severely compromised structurally. It is highly recommended the entire structure be demolished.”

Still, commission members said they have voted to preserve derelict properties in the past, including Victorian-era homes.

Advertise with us

“Historic designation doesn’t mean the building has to stay exactly as it is,” said Melissa McSwigan, a director emeritus of Preservation Pittsburgh. “There could be some compromise approaches.”

As the debate loomed over the meeting, commission members were at an impasse — until member Katie Reed, also part of the Department of City Planning, introduced a little-known provision of the city code: a recommendation of “no recommendation.”

The motion passed, 3-1. Ms. Reed abstained. Commission member Matthew Falcone recused because he’s part of Preservation Pittsburgh. Chairwoman Aguirre voted against the motion.

“When you have something that has been marginalized, anonymous on purpose, where, with whatever means they had, they tried to the best that they could and they supported people on and off for 50 years, I see that as something that I, at least, am interested to learn more (about),” Ms. Aguirre said. “I don’t want to be part of that erasure.”

The Planning Commission will discuss Donny’s again March 25.

Advertise with us

If nothing else, said Ms. McSwigan of Preservation Pittsburgh, the nomination has started a conversation.

“[We] hope to inspire people, to show them that it's not just the fancy, grand buildings that we want to help recognize and help to support and save,” she said.