A judge has thrown out a Pittsburgh Public School District lawsuit trying to force a property reassessment in Allegheny County.
In a 27-page opinion and order issued Thursday, visiting senior Judge Kenneth Valasek in the county’s Common Pleas Court ruled that the district did not have standing, or the legal right, to bring the lawsuit.
The decision is a big victory for the county and Executive Sara Innamorato, who has fought the district’s attempt to correct an assessment system that it has described as “broken and inequitable.”
But Judge Valasek’s ruling does not leave the county entirely off the hook. It is still facing a separate lawsuit filed by Churchill homeowner Flavia E. Laun to force a countywide reassessment.
A county spokeswoman had no comment on Judge Valasek’s ruling. School District Solicitor Ira Weiss said he was surprised by the outcome and disagreed with the judge’s conclusions.
“We have an obviously inequitable, broken, unconstitutional assessment system in this county, which everyone recognizes except the county executive,” he said.
Read More
He added that the district will “consider its options and take the necessary steps to correct what is obviously an untenable situation.”
In his ruling, Judge Valasek appeared to side with the county in its argument that the school district could resolve any budgetary shortfalls by simply raising taxes, even though the deficit resulted from assessment appeals and refunds caused by a sharp drop in the number used to calculate taxable value.
The district has estimated that assessment reductions, particularly those involving Downtown office properties, have resulted in about $20 million in refunds over the past three years.
But Judge Valasek noted that the district had not raised taxes in four years. If it had done so by one mill this year, it would have generated about $19 million for the district, he said.
“The district allowed the refunds to impair its financial condition (the ultimate harm caused by the refunds) because it chose not to act. This choice in four consecutive years was the cause of any degrading of the district’s financial condition,” he wrote.
“Even a timely one-half mill increase would have prevented the impairment. The school district was not helpless at any relevant point in time to prevent this ‘harm’ from happening.”
As a result, the district has not demonstrated that it has a “direct interest” in the matter.
Mr. Weiss disagreed with the judge’s reasoning involving tax increases.
“To suggest the failure of the district to raise taxes to the level apparently acceptable to the court simply ignores the fact that raising taxes only worsens the problem and increases the unconstitutional burden on those owning lower valued properties,” he said.
Judge Valasek also concluded that the district had not successfully demonstrated that the violations of the state’s uniformity and the U.S. Constitution’s equal protection clauses it alleged because of a flawed assessment system “caused the problem of which it complains.”
He added that the uniformity clause was designed to “protect taxpayers, not taxing authorities.”
“As a result, the clause does not provide protection to the school district from the woes it complains of. Insofar as real estate taxpayers are concerned, the clause’s function is to ensure that owners each pay their proportionate share of the tax based on the actual value of their property,” he wrote.
Besides the lack of a direct interest, Judge Valasek found that the district had not proved that it had an “immediate” and “substantial” interest in the matter, also requirements needed to show that it was an aggrieved party.
In addition, he wrote that while taxing bodies like municipalities and school districts have won lawsuits to force reassessments in other cases, in none of those was the issue of standing ever raised.
He also stated that in two of those lawsuits, real estate taxpayers were co-plaintiffs “who undeniably did have standing.”
That statement could bode well for Ms. Laun’s lawsuit, at least on the question of standing. It also was filed by Mr. Weiss, who was the attorney in one of the lawsuits filed by property owners resulting in the 2012 court-ordered reassessment, the last in the county.
Another was brought by the Community Justice Project, a statewide public interest law firm with offices in Pittsburgh, charging that assessment non-uniformity harmed lower-value property owners, neighborhoods, and communities.
In his ruling, Judge Valasek emphasized that the “dismissal of the lawsuit brought by the school district should not be interpreted to mean that Allegheny County’s current assessments are constitutionally permissible. This issue has not been decided by the court.”
Judge Valasek was assigned to hear the case after all Allegheny County judges recused themselves.
The district has argued in court filing that it has been forced to balance its budgets by using reserves and through “systematic understaffing” to make up for funding shortfalls caused by plunging property values.
“While we respect the opinion of the court, we believe it incorrectly finds the district does not have a direct interest in having a legal constitutional assessment system and further incorrectly finds that the district has not been harmed,” Mr. Weiss said after Thursday’s ruling. “The unconstitutionality of the system constitutes harm in and of itself.”
Although there has been much focus on the massive assessment reductions some Downtown property owners have received — more than $500 million in all — that alone should not be the basis for a full reassessment, the county has argued.
It also has maintained that the current system is equitable in that it treats all taxing bodies the same and that they all have the right to correct inequities through appeals.
Ms. Laun’s lawsuit also claims that the county’s “outdated, discriminatory and non-uniform” assessment system violations state uniformity and constitutional equal protection clauses.
It argues that her $142,900 assessment is well above the average for her street even through her house is of similar value or “comparatively inferior to several neighboring properties with lower assessments.”
This story has been updated at 11:09 a.m. Friday, Feb. 14, to clarify the litigants involved in the lawsuits that led to 2012 Allegheny County reassessment.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.