During a September hearing on the Pittsburgh Public Schools lawsuit to force a countywide property revaluation, a judge wondered whether the district could avoid budget woes caused by assessment-related inequities simply by raising taxes.

It’s not that simple, the district stated in its latest legal filing in the case.

Tax increases, it told visiting senior Judge Kenneth Valasek, are “not a viable long-term solution” to fix an Allegheny County assessment system that it describes as “broken and inequitable.”

School attorneys made the argument in objections filed this week in Common Pleas Court after Judge Valasek notified the district and the county in December that he may take into account the district budgets from 2022 through 2025 in deciding whether the reassessment lawsuit should proceed.

Advertise with us

In its filing, the district urged the Armstrong County judge not to do so even though it has argued that plunging property assessments, caused in part by a change in ratio used to calculate taxable value, are costing it millions of dollars in revenue each year.

The budgets, it asserted, “are not relevant for determining whether defendant, Allegheny County, currently maintains a constitutionally adequate tax assessment system under the uniformity or equal protection clauses.”

But if the judge decides to take the spending plans into account, he should pay particularly close attention to the 2025 budget passed last month, the district stated.

While that budget doesn’t increase taxes, it contains a $28.1 million operating deficit, one covered by district reserves. In its filing, the district stated that the operating deficits for 2026 and 2027 will be nearly $23.2 million and $26.4 million, respectively.

“As the Downtown commercial tax base continues to erode, these projected operating deficits will likely increase over time,” it added, noting that the district is limited by Act 1 on how much it can raise taxes.

Advertise with us

“Tax increases also do not bring stability or predictability to the overall tax base, which are necessary for accurately setting annual budgets.”

The district further stated in its objections that it was able to balance last year’s budget in part “through systematic understaffing.” It explained that it did not fill about 172 vacancies and that they “persist, to the ultimate detriment of plaintiff’s student population.”

“Chronic understaffing, the draining of fund reserves, and annual millage rate increases are not viable or sustainable long-term solutions for defendants’ illegal tax assessment system. The only adequate remedy is a county-wide reassessment, which is required by the Pennsylvania Constitution under the present circumstances,” it contended.

The county did not submit any objections to Judge Valasek taking into account the budgets in his deliberations.

During the Sept. 27 hearing on the lawsuit, the county argued that the district could resolve any budgetary shortfalls resulting from assessment appeals and refunds by raising taxes. It also maintained that the current system is equitable in the sense that it treats all taxing bodies the same.

Advertise with us

While massive reductions that some Downtown property owners have received — more than $500 million in all — have cost the city, county, and district millions in revenues, that alone shouldn’t be the basis for a full reassessment, the county contended.

A county attorney also stated at the hearing that it amounts to “speculation” as to whether the district would be in better shape financially with a reassessment.

The district has countered that it shouldn’t have to spend thousands of dollars a year filing or fighting assessment appeals to correct inequities in the system when that should be the county’s job.

It argued that the commercial property reductions, the steep drop in the ratio used to calculate taxable value, and other inequities are symptoms of an assessment system that is broken. The last reassessment in Allegheny County, ordered by a judge, was in 2012.

The district’s current lawsuit to force a reassessment could hinge on whether Judge Valasek determines that it had standing, or the right, to file the litigation.

Advertise with us

The county maintains that the district, as a taxing body, does not have the legal standing to do so. The district, of course, disagrees, arguing that as a taxing body that relies on property tax revenue, it has a vested interest in ensuring that the assessment system operates properly.

It also noted that taxing bodies in several other counties in Pennsylvania have sued to force reassessments and won.

Judge Valasek was appointed to oversee the case after all Allegheny County judges recused themselves.