Pittsburgh’s school district is making one final plea to a judge not to throw out its lawsuit to force a property reassessment in Allegheny County, claiming that the system is broken and in need of repair.
In an 11-page supplemental brief filed in Common Pleas Court Wednesday, the district sought to rebuff claims by the county and Executive Sara Innamorato that it lacked legal standing to bring the lawsuit.
It argued that that county’s failure to conduct a reassessment since 2012 has led to a “rapidly shrinking commercial tax base,” one that has cost it more than $10 million in refunds for the 2022-2024 tax years.
Since the reassessment lawsuit was filed in April, “the school district’s refund obligations have continued to balloon at an alarming rate as more and more commercial property owners exploit defendant Allegheny County’s outdated, inequitable and broken tax assessment system through the administrative appeals process,” the brief stated.
“The school district’s interest in the stability and accuracy of the county’s tax assessment system, which is entirely unique from the interest held by the public at large, is of existential importance to the school district, its staff, and its students,” it added.
But in its own 11-page supplemental brief, the county maintained that the district has the means to remedy its financial predicament without a reassessment simply by raising taxes.
Read More
“First, this court should take notice that a school district is permitted to raise taxes for a given year to support its operating budget, as this is an important premise for preliminary objections and is easily ascertainable through publicly available documents,” it stated.
Visiting senior Judge Kenneth Valasek, of Armstrong County, requested the supplemental briefs before ruling on preliminary objections filed by the county seeking a dismissal of the district’s lawsuit.
During a hearing in September, the two sides sparred over whether the district had the legal right — or standing — to bring such an action.
At one point, Judge Valasek asked whether the state constitution’s uniformity clause as it relates to property assessments was designed mainly to protect taxpayers.
In its supplemental brief, the district maintained that it meets the legal standard of being an “aggrieved” party with a “substantial, direct and immediate interest” in the case since the assessment system serves as the foundation for property taxes, its chief funding source.
It found ammunition for that argument in the 2009 lawsuit filed to force the county to do its last reassessment. In that case, the county acknowledged, according to the brief, that “taxing authorities have a substantial interest in the county’s handling of its system.”
It cited the county’s assertion at the time that “municipalities and school districts are burdened by the difficulty in estimating the reserves needed for possible tax refunds and in calculating the millage rates” when the tax base is unstable.
In addition, it stated that there have been reassessment lawsuits brought by school districts or municipalities in other parts of the state have been allowed to proceed.
The county has argued that plummeting property values in Downtown resulting in millions of dollars in tax refunds and lost revenues have had more to do with fallout from the COVID-19 pandemic than anything else.
But in its brief, the district cited as the culprit the common level ratio, a number used to calculate taxable value in assessment appeal hearings. It noted that the ratio has fallen 81.1% to 52.7%.
In a footnote, it maintained that applying the ratio to the current market value of commercial buildings Downtown “leads to absurd results. The feeding frenzy of commercial appeal activity has contributed to an unstable and volatile tax base.”
“The school district’s commercial tax base continues to shrink at a rapid pace, which invariably (and unfairly) shifts tax liability over to homeowners who are properly assessed or over-assessed at this time,” it added.
“A countywide reassessment would prevent commercial property owners from exploiting the current 52.7% CLR by resetting it to a predetermined ratio of 100%. It would also provide the taxing authorities with stability and predictability for budgeting purposes.”
But the county stuck to its claims about the pandemic in its brief.
“The effects of the real estate market on the school district’s budget cannot be a surprise, and the increased strain COVID-19 placed on businesses since 2020 cannot only now be making itself felt by taxing bodies,” it stated.
“The county is simply not responsible for the market effects and global crisis that have led to a diminished commercial tax base, and the application of a CLR that reflects these real estate trends cannot be decried as unlawful, unconstitutional, or unfair.”
Though the school district may be “perhaps rightfully” frustrated by the “Commonwealth’s reassessment system that has been created and upheld by the legislature and the courts,” that “does not implicate the county in some unconstitutional property assessment scheme,” it contended.
It also argued that despite the falling common level ratio, the district has not come close to raising its millage to the amount permitted under the law and thus “has failed to exhaust available statutory remedies.”
School district solicitor Ira Weiss took issue with county’s argument.
“It’s unprecedented for one elected official to lecture another elected body on whether or not it should raise taxes. I believe that is the height of arrogance, frankly,” he said.
Ms. Innamorato has proposed raising taxes 2.2 mills to help balance next year’s county budget.
Judge Valasek has not indicated when he will make a ruling on the county’s call to dismiss the district’s lawsuit. He was appointed to preside over the case after all Allegheny County judges recused themselves from hearing it.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.