Some of Pittsburgh’s top developers and building owners have a message for City Council: Ditch the rush to expand affordable housing mandates citywide for a more comprehensive approach.

During a private meeting last week, they urged council members to avoid a one-size-fits-all approach and to give neighborhoods the ability to craft their own solutions.

“It has to be a win-win for everyone. It has to be a win-win for the city, a win-win for developers, and a win-win for residents,” said Todd Reidbord, president of Walnut Capital.

Mr. Reidbord was among those who attended last week’s session, along with officials from Rugby Realty and Trek Development Group.

Advertise with us

The meeting was organized by Councilwoman Erika Strassburger after some developers voiced concerns that they were being left out in the discussions involving affordable housing.

It came as the city Planning Commission prepares to take up competing bills related to affordable housing at a public hearing later this month. One proposed by Mayor Ed Gainey would expand citywide affordable housing mandates known as inclusionary zoning, which are now limited to a handful of neighborhoods.

The other, through amendments introduced by Councilman Bob Charland, would do essentially the opposite, leaving it to individual neighborhoods to decide what mandates, if any, to impose.

It also would require the city, the Pittsburgh Urban Redevelopment Authority, or the Housing Authority to “fully fund” any financial gaps in projects involving the creation of affordable housing. Such a provision, council President R. Daniel Lavelle has said, would “literally almost bankrupt us.”

Mr. Charland made his case for his bill at a Planning Commission briefing Tuesday, arguing that current inclusionary zoning ordinances in Lawrenceville, Oakland, Polish Hill and Bloomfield have led to the creation of only 38 affordable units since 2019.

Advertise with us

He maintained that his bill would generate more affordable and market rate units overall.

“We need a program that will actually work, not just sound good,” he said.

During last week’s meeting with council, meanwhile, developers called on members to be more deliberate in determining what is best for the city, its residents and its neighborhoods, Mr. Reidbord said.

“This is just being rushed through. I don’t believe there’s been any forum for robust discussion for people to listen,” he said.

Bill Gatti, Trek president and CEO, said one goal of the meeting was to give council members a chance “to hear directly from developers about the challenges they were facing” in developing housing, whether it was affordable or market rate.

Advertise with us

The idea was to slow “this process down and not get something that leads to unintended consequences.”

“I think we all agreed that we need to be careful about selecting a solution that helps the city,” he said.

Mr. Gatti, whose firm has done a number of affordable housing projects in the city, said there’s no doubt that interest rates and high construction costs have impacted development. He said the average construction cost per apartment unit is now more than $350,000. That’s compared with under $270,000 before the COVID-19 pandemic.

While the cost structure for affordable housing is different, relying in part on tax credits, “the point is that it’s really expensive to build,” Mr. Gatti said.

Mr. Reidbord said Pittsburgh is now building fewer apartment units than cities such as Cleveland and Harrisburg. He added there needs to be more discussion on ways to stimulate additional construction, whether that involves incentives, tax increment financing, housing vouchers or other means.

Advertise with us

He maintained that there is “unanimous agreement” among developers that Mr. Gainey’s legislation to expand inclusionary zoning citywide “is not appropriate and would be counter-productive” in generating more affordable housing.

The legislation “would be a failure” in terms of growing the tax base and creating economic opportunities, as well as providing opportunities for lower-income people, he said.

“It’s just going to stop the pace of development,” he said, “and that’s not good for anybody.”

Walnut Capital currently is developing a 159-unit apartment building on McKee Place in Oakland with 16 units set aside as affordable for those at or below 50% of the area median income, as required under the zoning.

It also has reached a deal with Mr. Gainey to set aside 15% of the 800 residential units it is planning as part of a Bakery Square expansion as affordable.

Advertise with us

Another who attended the meeting, Larry Walsh, a principal and chief operating officer for Rugby Realty, which owns the historic Gulf Tower and a number of other properties in Downtown, said the city should leave it to the neighborhoods to determine where to impose affordable housing mandates.

Rugby is planning to convert Gulf Tower to a luxury hotel and 225 apartments, with 27 affordable to households earning up to 80% of the area median income.

“The goal is to increase the stock of affordable housing units in the city. The best way to achieve that is to increase the supply. Overlaying the entire city with another layer of mandates is inevitably going to result in them achieving the exact opposite of their stated intent,” Mr. Walsh said of the mayor’s proposal.

Ms. Strassburger did not return phone calls seeking comment on last week’s meeting. Mr. Reidbord said the meeting was conducted in a way that there were no more than four council members in the room at the same time to avoid running afoul of open meeting laws.

Under Mr. Gainey’s plan, developers who build at least 20 units of housing must set aside 10% of them as affordable to households at or below 50% of the area median income, or $40,500 for a family of two.

Advertise with us

Mr. Charland’s bill would broaden the pool to include residents from at or below 50% of the AMI to up to 120% of the AMI. Under both bills, the affordable units must stay in place for at least 35 years.

During Tuesday’s briefing, the councilman’s proposal drew both support and pushback from commission members.

Commissioner Phillip Wu said he shared many of the councilman’s concerns, adding that mandating inclusionary zoning citywide could be a “big risk.” He also said he believes there needs to be some type of market incentives to encourage developers to do more affordable housing.

“Not having a subsidy of some kind is going to be challenging,” he said.

But Commission Chairwoman Lashawn Burton-Faulk questioned whether there was adequate public engagement in crafting the bill, urging Mr. Charland to meet with the planning staff before the public hearing in two weeks.

Advertise with us

She also questioned a provision that would allow neighborhoods to opt out of inclusionary zoning while still allowing developers to build affordable units in those areas.

“Now you’re putting communities up against developers,” she said.

Like some of the developers, Commissioner Steve Mazza called for a deliberate process to determine what’s best for the city.

“I honestly believe we need to get this thing right the first time,” he said. “I don’t want a big miss.”

Mr. Gainey has blasted Mr. Charland’s bill, saying it “amounts to writing a blank check of city tax dollars to corporate developers, paying them to build units that over half of our residents cannot afford.”

Advertise with us

He also has argued that the councilman’s plan would continue to “prioritize corporate interests over working families.”

Mr. Reidbord said everyone agrees on the common goal of providing more housing for people of all income levels in the city. But ordering mandates while not recognizing the costs involved to builders “does not work.”

He called for more study and more deliberation.

“I don’t think the process has been as robust as it should have been. As a developer, we would have been criticized for going through a process like this,” he said. “What’s the hurry? We’ve gone 100 years without it. The mayor’s been in office four years. Nothing has happened. What’s the hurry?”

Mr. Gatti believes all of those involved in last week’s meeting are truly trying to figure out what’s best for the city and its residents.

“There were a range of opinions on the best way to do that. Is it the carrot or the stick? Is it to incentivize developers to do affordable housing or do you punish them to do it?” he asked.