For more than a century, Downtown’s Grant Street has seen politicians rise and fall. But through change and turmoil, there has been one constant — a little bar next to City Hall.
Over the years, the Grant Street Tavern has survived the political coups and Machiavellian maneuvers across the street. It has been a shoulder to cry on, a back room to cut deals, and a refuge from the bluster and backstabbing in the halls of power.
Within its cozy confines, with sports memorabilia peppering the walls and Irish flags hanging from the rafters, judges have awaited the weightiest of verdicts. It’s a place that has celebrated Election Day winners and consoled the losers.
“We’re like priests, confidantes, and we enjoy it,” owner Cheryl White said. “It’s definitely not boring.”
The Grant Street Tavern has been around so long that it has witnessed the rarest of Pittsburgh events — a Republican in the mayor’s office.
As far as Ms. White can tell, the bar made its debut in the late 1800s or early 1900s when the GOP oddly enough dominated Pittsburgh politics. It arrived not as the Grant Street Tavern but as the Harlequin Lounge. It occupied the first floor of the three-story Marshall Building.
Read More
The Harlequin was a fairly bare-bones hangout, with a long L-shaped bar on one side and a few tables on the other. For entertainment, a toy monkey on a unicycle scampered across a wire.
In the late 1920s, the Harlequin itself was involved in a takeover of sorts. The Grant Building at 310 Grant Street rose up beside it and the bar ultimately became part of the 40-story skyscraper, though it is still housed in a separate structure.
While the Irish pub isn’t the political revolving door that is City Hall, it has changed hands several times over the years.
By 1979, the Harlequin turned into the Grant Street Inn, run by a man named George Barnes. He is responsible for the watering hole’s intricate wood bar area, one that dates to the late 1800s, and the exposed brick on the walls.
It was sold twice more over the next 12 years, with the latter transaction resulting in yet another name change — to the Grant Street Tavern.
In 2011, Ms. White bought the bar from a golfing buddy who happened to be one of the owners. At the time, she had been toiling in a corporate mortgage financial business for 35 years and was looking for a change.
“I said I was sick of corporate and he said he was sick of owning a bar. So I said I’ll buy it off you. He said I wouldn’t do that to a friend. I said I’m coming down and making you an offer. So I quit corporate and bought the bar off him,” she related.
In some ways, the bar business was in Ms. White’s blood. Her family owned a beer distributor in Regent Square. She recalls visiting the Elks and other clubs with her dad when she was young, playing pinball and drinking Cokes.
And as an account executive, she spent plenty of evenings in bars socializing with clients. “I would sit there and think, this isn’t rocket science. I could run a bar,” she said. “And I still love it.”
She describes the Grant Street Tavern as a “hidden gem.”
Over the years, it has been a favorite hangout of judges. It has been the one bar that countless lawyers couldn’t pass. Any number of politicos have dropped in, whether to drink or to wheel and deal.
But the bar that still dishes out complimentary chips, pretzels, and popcorn also has attracted accountants, construction workers, sports fans, and even flight attendants on layovers.
Ms. White said the secret to the tavern’s longevity and success is a simple one — keeping customers first, whether they’re power brokers or average Joes.
“We make everybody feel, as soon as they walk in the door, welcome, whether they’re from out of town or not. We pretty much know their life stories by the time they leave here. We really put an emphasis on personal care, the customer and making them feel good,” she said.

“I think we just listen. I mean, we know everyone’s first name as they come in the door. It’s like a Cheers kind of thing.”
Ms. White credits her bartenders with keeping the good vibes going.
“They make everybody feel like they’re number one. We laugh. Sometimes we give them a hard time. And they actually like being insulted sometimes. It’s like part of the game. And they know all of us,” she said. “We pour generous drinks. Our prices aren’t high. If you find a gem, you’re definitely going to come back.”
Scenes from two movies have been filmed in the tavern. And like City Hall, it has been part of some history-making moments, including a big one in 1999.
In the summer of that year, the tavern was a backdrop for the deal that saved the Pittsburgh Penguins, with hockey great Mario Lemieux emerging as owner of the team.
Attorney Doug Campbell, who represented Mr. Lemieux in the tense bankruptcy negotiations, said many a night was spent at the bar “after hours and hours of banging heads in the judge’s chambers,” to hash out the framework.
“It deserves credit for being one Pittsburgh institution that played a role in saving another,” he said. “It was a dark and soothing place to go during a process that was not easy on one’s nerves. You could go there for some medicine. Thank God, it worked.”
One reason the deal makers and politicians gravitate to the little spot is that it can keep a secret, Ms. White said. “What happens in the Grant Street Tavern stays in the Grant Street Tavern,” she stressed.
Among Ms. White’s favorite customers were Allegheny Common Pleas judges Jeffrey Manning and David Cashman, both of whom have passed away in the last two years.
“Dave Cashman always stood at the end of the bar. He never sat down. They’re all gone now. But I had them for nine years. And they sort of trained me. You know how judges are,” she said.
In the end, it’s the customers who make the bar special, she noted.
“It’s always something different every day. A lot of gossip goes around. It’s just interesting. It’s not boring. It’s not like I wake up in the morning and go, ‘Ah, I got to go to work.’ It’s not that way. I just love it.”
In many ways, the Grant Street Tavern is a throwback. It still serves lunch, with some tables available in a small room across from the bar. The walls are adorned with all types of sports memorabilia, including a Tony Dorsett Pitt jersey, an Andrew McCutchen Pirates jersey, and, of course, a Penguins jersey, as well as a set of antique golf clubs.
Customers navigate a narrow aisle with a sharp turn near the tavern’s entrance and exit (a good sobriety test) to saddle up to the long wood bar. It all makes for a homey and authentic atmosphere.
Attorney Harry Flannery, who stopped in the bar on a recent afternoon, said he has been a customer since the 1970s.
“It’s relaxing. It’s soothing. I have lots of memories here,” he said.
“The place is down to earth and non corporate. That’s what I like about the tavern. It’s not a chain. It’s for real,” Mr. Campbell added. “It’s the genuine spot that remains on Grant Street. I hope it survives.”
Over the course of its long history, the pub has overcome the Great Depression, two world wars, innumerable political battles, and the COVID-19 pandemic.
During the latter, Grant Building owner McKnight Realty Partners didn’t charge the bar rent. As the tavern started operating again, it just paid taxes and utilities until business picked up.
“They were very kind and understanding,” Ms. White said of the ownership.
While many Grant Street politicians have come and gone, don’t look for the bar’s long century-plus run to end any time soon. At age 66, Ms. White said she’s committed to keeping the place open “until I can’t walk anymore.”
“I love it too much. What are you going to do if you retire? Nope, not ready. I have too much energy,” she said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.