For a grocer stocked to the gills with centerpiece poultry and pollock, the recipe for success at this 112-year-old Strip District staple is surprisingly simple.

“Create happy customers by selling the freshest products at the best prices in a friendly, fun atmosphere,” read the business cards and signs adorning 1711 Penn Ave., better known as Wholey's Fish Market.

If the first part of that message has kept the cod and compound butter churning over the years, it’s the second part — the “atmosphere” — that has charmed generations of Pittsburgh shoppers. Here, a model train encircles the sushi station and a family of animatronic pigs serenade the soda pop.

Much of the whimsy was the brainchild of patriarch Robert Wholey, who was himself inspired by a similarly trademark store in Connecticut.

Advertise with us

Seasoned regulars will note slight changes over the years. The cow hanging from a wall and overlooking the meat department has a new moo, designed to be more kid-friendly, co-owner Sam Wholey said. But, for the most part, it’s business as usual, even during the holiday rush.

“All good so far,” Mr. Wholey said as he loaded an industrial juicer with a box of fresh oranges. A moment later, he was boogieing to the shop’s Christmas tunes.

With 52 years of service this year, Mr. Wholey is thinking about how to keep the family legacy going. He said it’s always harder, no matter the business, to get the next generation on board.

“They don’t all live here,” he acknowledged with a bit of a grimace.

Wholey’s Fish Market got its start selling live chickens, and in the 112 years since, it’s followed a simple mission to provide fresh ingredients in a fun atmosphere. (Evan Robinson-Johnson / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

During the lunch rush, Mr. Wholey and his brother and co-owner Jim — working the floor well into their 70s — are inundated with questions. “Escargot, without the shells?” one woman asked. “Hush puppy mix?” another man asked. Picking up a jug of cider harvested from apples grown in Butler County, an older gentleman asked, “does this have any sugar?”

Advertise with us

This time of year, families travel in small packs, clustered over premium cuts of meat or fish that will form the backbone of Christmas feasts and other holiday festivities. Come New Year’s Day, they’ll be back for pork and sauerkraut, Mr. Wholey said.

Although much hasn’t changed inside the shop over the decades, Wholey’s has made a few pivots behind the scenes to stay with the times.

In the 1980s, it launched an international wholesale division that catered largely to global demand for whiting fish. More recently, the brand moved online and expanded to offer home delivery.

Orders over $250 get free shipping, and Jim Wholey said they get a fair number of orders that large.

As the broader grocery industry has faced consolidation, pushing the government just this fall to oppose the latest proposed merger between between Kroger and Albertsons, Wholey’s tries to keep its costs competitive. It sources directly from farms and fisheries, cutting out middleman costs. And to ensure those relationships last, Jim Wholey said, they “try to trade with long-term people.”

Advertise with us

That loyalty seems to reflect on the customer side of the equation, too, although Jim Wholey declined to name a favorite long-timer. “They’re all important,” he said.

As two such shoppers weighed the merits of smelts versus squid, Sam Wholey was manning his regular post by the orange machine. In the two years since its last upgrade, the juicer has squished its way through 906,000 oranges, he said.

Once poured and capped, the juice goes into a soft bed of ice — one of several snowbanks throughout the store, which produces close to 40,000 pounds of fresh ice per day. The frozen bays chill everything from eel to turkey necks.