The pink house on Steuben Street might not be pink anymore, but it’s still selling the cake doughnuts it became known for in the early 1950s.
And a few miles east in the Strip District, though produce stands no longer line Smallman Street, Wholey’s Market is still selling lobster tails and swordfish steaks.
Across Pittsburgh, from the West End to the Strip District, businesses that opened half a century ago remain standing — beloved by many and woven into the fabric of the city today.
Over the coming weeks, the Post-Gazette will feature conversations with businesses like Better-Maid Donut Co. and Wholey’s as part of a series we’re calling “True Pittsburgh.” We talked to some of the region’s mainstays about how they’ve survived for so long, what keeps people coming back and why they feel at home in the Steel City.
“When you think about those businesses, how amazing is it that, as so much has changed, they have been able to pivot and migrate their businesses in ways that helped them to endure,” said A.J. Drexler, president and CEO of Entrepreneurs Forever, a small-business accelerator run by the Hill District-based Mansmann Foundation.
“I mean, that’s something that everyone wants.”
Read More
What it means to be ‘100% Pittsburgh’
At The Attic Record Store in Millvale, open since 1980, owner Fred Bohn said his shop is “100% Pittsburgh.” That means on Saturdays, you can find customers of all ages, who know each other and who sift through the store’s floor-to-ceiling shelves, who know Mr. Bohn and return every week.
Pittsburgh often feels smaller than it is thanks to tight-knit communities — and that helps longtime businesses here stay open, said University of Pittsburgh business professor emeritus James Craft, who moved here more than 50 years ago.
“I think people are passionate about the city because it’s interactive and small enough that you can get acquainted with your neighbors and so forth,” Mr. Craft said.
There’s also a great deal of pride in businesses that reflect the city’s history, built up by immigrants and steel workers — from Mineo’s Pizza House, started by an Italian immigrant in the late 1950s, to Colker Janitorial Supplies, founded by former U.S. Steel workers a few years later.
Over time, these lasting businesses in the heart of Pittsburgh’s shopping districts have become landmarks for both longtime residents and tourists.
“People visiting Pittsburgh and the opportunities to visit those interesting locations — the Strip or Market Square and other areas — keep the small businesses there,” Mr. Craft said. “They are profitable and it’s part of what the city is.”
Why do historic businesses matter?
A business celebrating its fifth birthday this year has already outlived more than half of its peers, according to data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Only 13% of private companies started 30 years ago are still operating in 2024. The half-century club is even more exclusive.
In cities like Pittsburgh, long-running businesses helped set the standard and usher in a steady rise in the number of small operations founded since 1980, Ms. Drexler said.
“They’re the leaders of the herd,” Ms. Drexler said. “And there’s resilience in a herd.”
Small businesses in Pennsylvania now account for more than 99% of all businesses in the state, the Pennsylvania Department of Community and Economic Development recently reported, and nearly half of the workers in the state are employed by a small business.
Many of those open for decades have been passed down to new hands — Allan Jewelers in Beaver and Colker Janitorial Supplies are on the second generation of the same family.
Keeping the doors open for years creates “generations of wealth,” Ms. Drexler said, which sustains employees and can lead to growth, new ventures and philanthropic spending.
Each of the businesses profiled in this series has adapted to downturns, natural disasters and changing times. Wholey’s, once just a small market, now ships online orders. The Attic, once known for doo-wop and jazz 45s, now sells those records alongside pop and metal albums.
At R.E. Jahn Auto Sales in McCandless, a used car lot once filled with gas-guzzling Oldsmobiles rotated to smaller Ford Falcons. When fashions changed again, Chevrolet Suburbans and pickup trucks took over.
The Grant Street Tavern has seen its name change several times and trends come and go. It has gone from a nondescript watering hole during the early days of steel to a cozy bar filled with Irish flags, sports memorabilia and a friendly neighborhood vibe.
“What happens is, you have to maintain your core business at the same time you’re reinventing for the next people,” Ms. Drexler said.
“That is very hard to do, and the way that they’ve been able to do it, typically, is by staying very close in touch with their customer, understanding that their customer is changing — and understanding how they might need to change to be as beloved to the next generation of customer.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.