Mineo’s Pizza in Squirrel Hill has been defying expectations from the day it opened in 1958.

Back then, the building owner, who was Jewish, wasn’t so sure that Italian immigrant Giovanni Mineo was making a good decision signing a lease for the Murray Avenue storefront space.

“My dad told the landlord he was going to open a pizza shop,” Dominic Mineo said. “He said, ‘You realize this is an orthodox Jewish neighborhood? We don’t eat pork and stuff like that.’

“The landlord told my dad, ‘I don’t think that’s a very good idea.’ Well, 65 years later, I guess it was a pretty good idea, huh?”

Advertise with us

In part by enduring so long, Mineo’s — with its signature pepperoni pies and a menu as big as one found in a full Italian restaurant — has become more than just a pizza parlor.

It’s a slice of the city’s culture and history.

Giovanni Mineo forged ahead each day, rolling out the dough, ladling the sauce and piling on the cheese. He would tell people that he won the neighborhood over by providing great pizza and by being respectful of the culture in Squirrel Hill.

“For many, many years, we closed for Passover,” Dominic Mineo said. “And it got to the point where some of the other establishments on Murray Avenue that were owned by Jewish people were opening for the Jewish holiday. So, then we started opening for the Jewish holiday.

“But for probably 45 years, we were closed for Passover during the Jewish holidays.”

Advertise with us

Selling produce with a horse and buggy

Now run by third-generation family members, Mineo’s has grown from that single storefront to four locations.

From the original store, Mineo’s has expanded to suburban communities across the region, including Mt. Lebanon in the South Hills and Hampton in the North Hills. A highly anticipated Mineo’s Pizza in Pittsburgh International Airport is set to open in spring 2025.

It all started from a horse and buggy, Dominic Mineo said.

His father, who lived in Oakland by Forbes Field, would get up at 1 a.m. to walk to Schenley Stables. There, he gathered his horse and buggy and then went to the Strip District to load up fruits and vegetables that he could sell throughout Squirrel Hill, Shadyside and Oakland. It was how he became familiar with those neighborhoods, Dominic Mineo said.

When Giovanni Mineo first came here from Italy, he had planned to open a bakery. But a friend who had come to America with him moved to Chicago and opened a pizza shop. The friend encouraged Giovanni Mineo to do the same.

Advertise with us

“So, he said, ‘how many pizza shops are around Pittsburgh’ in 1958? And my dad says ‘Not many.’ Then he says, ‘how many bakeries are there?’ He says ‘there’s lots of bakeries.’ ”

Behind the hard work and decades of steady business lies a legendary pizza rivalry — a Pittsburgh-famous one with Aiello’s Pizza, which started not too long after Mineo’s, was founded.

Giovanni Mineo started Mineo’s Pizza on his own. A year later, he took on a partner, Eddie Balestrino, who later brought his nephew, Joe Aiello, to Pittsburgh from Italy and gave him a job at Mineo’s, according to Dominic Mineo.

The founder’s son doesn’t mince words when describing his understanding of what came next: “And then Joe Aiello turned around, stabbed him in the back and opened up up the street. That’s how it all happened.”

Aiello’s employees declined comment on the rivalry when contacted at the store.

Advertise with us

But, for decades, some Pittsburghers have loved both pizza places even as they enjoy debating which pizza is best — Mineo’s or Aiello’s? The feud between the two parlors has been described as Pittsburgh’s own version of the Hatfields and McCoys — just with pizza sauce instead of rifles.

Pepperoni, family and a few celebrities

When Mineo’s opened in the 1950s, there were only a handful of pizza shops in town.

The new pizza shop owner started just selling pizza. He sold slices of pizza and whole pizzas — large and small — with very few choices of toppings. Sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, green peppers and anchovies were among the first toppings.

Little by little, the operation expanded and added several different pasta dishes. Then hoagies, salads and different prepared foods.

The No. 1 seller is pepperoni pizza.

Advertise with us

“The menu now has evolved to pretty much almost like a full Italian restaurant,” Dominic Mineo said.

“We use the best ingredients that we can get and we don’t skimp,” he said. “That’s what we’ve done for 65 years. And we’re not going to change now.”

Today, many independent pizza shops thrive throughout the region, and Dominic Mineo says a lot of owners learned how to make pizza from working with the Mineo family over the years.

“There’s a lot of people that worked for both my father and my uncle and ended up opening shops,” he said. "My uncle had two stores in the South Hills for 30 years.”

Dominic and his brother, Giovanni Mineo Jr., have been running Mineo’s Pizza for almost 30 years. But several members of the family’s third generation are involved in it, including Dominic’s wife, his son, his daughter, a nephew and his son-in-law.

Advertise with us

Over the years, Mineo’s also has seen its share of celebrity customers, bringing a bit of star power to Squirrel Hill.

Hollywood actress Sharon Stone stopped by for a slice. Steelers legends Franco Harris and Lynn Swann have come through the iconic pizza joint, Dominic Mineo said.

But perhaps the most memorable celebrity visit came from Henry Winkler — better known as The Fonz from “Happy Days.” He didn’t just settle for eating pizza. He got behind the counter and had the Mineo’s staff show him how to make one.

“He was a stand-up guy — The Fonz,” Dominic Mineo said.