After spending more than two years on the drawing board, the proposed $500 million expansion of Bakery Square is nearly ready to go.
In a unanimous vote, Pittsburgh Planning Commission members on Tuesday backed a zoning change needed for the project and approved a preliminary land development plan after some last-minute fine tuning of the details.
The only other action needed is City Council approval of the zoning change, which would extend the specially planned district created to build Bakery Square in Larimer and Shadyside to the west to include the Village of Eastside shopping center and the former Club One fitness site.
Both are owned by Shadyside-based Walnut Capital, the developer behind Bakery Square and the 14-acre expansion.
Tuesday’s vote came six weeks after the commission held up its backing after disagreement over building step backs, limits on surface parking, and the architectural treatment of parking garages.

In the time since the last meeting, the two sides worked out nearly all of their differences with one still at issue Tuesday — whether buildings along Penn Avenue and East Liberty Boulevard should have 10-foot step backs — indentations — at both 65 feet and 85 feet or at just 85 feet.
Read More
Commission staff members argued that both are needed in keeping with buildings constructed in the city’s riverfront zoning districts and in Oakland. The idea is to prevent buildings from blocking out sunlight or creating a canyon effect.
But Walnut Capital representatives maintained that step backs of 65 and 85 feet are “not appropriate” for the section of Penn Avenue where most of the buildings — including the old Nabisco plant that is now part of Bakery Square — are at least 85 feet high with no lower step backs.
Attorney Jonathan Kamin said there is already a significant right-of-way width along Penn Avenue that allows for ample sunlight within the corridor. He also noted that there will be 15-foot sidewalks in place within the new development.
“So there’s ample room for us to just be able to step back once,” he said. “But it does become a real challenge for us to have the 10 feet and then the subsequent 10 feet at 85 and we’re not sure that it’s going to actually accomplish what we think it’s intended to accomplish.”
Walnut Capital President Todd Reidbord added that the 65-foot requirement is a “little bit arbitrary throughout the city.”
“The 65 feet is a number that, for purposes of this development, is just pulled out of the sky. It might be appropriate for the riverfront or for a different district. But in this particular district when you look at it from an urban planning standpoint, contextually the 85 feet is really what the height is.”
In the end, commission members sided with Walnut Capital, eliminating the 65-foot step back requirement before voting.
“If there is a place we should try to maximize density, I think this would be the place to maximize the density just because we have a lot more possibility for public transit,” Commissioner Peter Quintanilla said. “I understand that it works somewhere else but maybe in this case it’s one of those places where we should probably think about not necessarily enforcing the 65 feet.”
Commissioner Steve Mazza agreed. Requiring a 65-foot step back in a corridor where all of the other buildings aren’t built that way “is going to change the look,” he said. “I think the 65 doesn’t need to be there.”
Before the meeting, Walnut Capital and the Planning Commission staff were able to resolve their differences over the other big issue — surface parking within the expansion.
Planners had wanted to limit surface parking to on-street parking only, while Walnut Capital sought to have 25% of the parking being provided in each of the several phases of the development to be surface.
That was resolved in part by limiting surface parking to on-street or to single rows within the development. In addition, no surface parking can front Penn Avenue or East Liberty Boulevard.
Mr. Reidbord said afterward that he was pleased with the way things worked out.
“I think the Planning Commission took a well-reasoned approach. They listened to what we said and we’re very pleased with the outcome.”
The final plan, he said, is “good for us and great for the city” and will encourage “good urban development.”
Walnut Capital is already having preliminary meetings with the city on the first phase of the proposed expansion, Mr. Reidbord said. He is hoping to start the formal city public hearing and approval process in two to three months.
The expansion would incorporate both the shopping center and the Club One site. It would create three new sub-districts featuring a mix of commercial, retail, and residential uses along Penn, East Liberty Boulevard, adjacent to the East Busway, and across from Mellon Park.
Walnut Capital is planning to start phase one on the far west side on the Club One property. In addition to the expansion, it is proposing nearly $50 million in infrastructure improvements, including two new streets.
It also is planning to keep the Trader Joe’s grocery, although it could be moved elsewhere within the redevelopment at some point, and hoped to work with shopping center tenants to retain them.
The project includes a community benefits agreement with the Larimer and East Liberty neighborhoods, the centerpiece being a commitment by the developer to provide $6 million to seed a $25 million fund to be used to build or rehab for-sale housing in Larimer.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.