The Pittsburgh Planning Commission put the brakes on a proposed $500 million expansion of Bakery Square Tuesday after disagreements arose over building step backs, limits on surface parking, and architectural treatments for parking garages.

Despite broad support for the project, commission members decided to delay a vote on whether to approve the 14-acre expansion until at least September while the planning staff and Shadyside developer Walnut Capital try to work out their differences.

The postponement came over the objections of Walnut Capital, which argued that many of the issues could be ironed out without the need for any further delay in a project that has been on the drawing board for more than two years.

“We just continue to kick the can down the road without making any decision,” Walnut Capital President Todd Reidbord said. “I think we’re 99 or 95% of the way there. I feel confident that we can work wherever issues out with the staff. I feel that’s something that would be a reasonable solution to this issue.”

Advertise with us

But commission members thought it was important to get the remaining issues resolved before backing the zoning amendments needed for the project as well as the proposed preliminary land development plan.

Chairwoman LaShawn Burton Faulk said the delay wasn’t “any reflection on whether we think that this is a good project or whether components of this aren’t exemplary.”

“What I’m feeling right now is that there may be a desire to come back with things a little more ‘I’ dotted ‘T’ crossed because you guys have done fine work and we don’t want it to blemish at the tail end, decision day, because that’s not fair,” she said.

“If you’ve been in this race for the last two years. A couple more weeks isn’t going to keep you from moving forward.”

The disagreements erupted over planning department staff recommendations to impose conditions involving surface parking, building step backs, and garage screening as part of the commission’s approval of the expansion.

Advertise with us

Walnut Capital is seeking a zoning change to extend the specially planned district created to build Bakery Square in Larimer and Shadyside to include the Village of Eastside shopping center and the former Club One fitness site, both of which it owns.

In addition, the commission also must approve a preliminary land development plan for the project.

The biggest dispute Tuesday appeared to involve surface parking. The planning staff sought to restrict all surface parking to on-street parking only, while Walnut Capital wanted to limit it to 25% of the total development.

Mr. Reidbord and Walnut Capital attorney Jonathan Kamin noted that they, too, wanted to limit surface parking as much as possible within the expansion. But they also argued there was a need to be flexible.

“It is important to have some surface parking, whether it’s drop off, pick up, folks that have 15-minute parking to take out an order. That convenience is important. We’re still in a mixed-use urban environment. We’re not a downtown CBD,” Mr. Reidbord said.

Advertise with us

“So to just arbitrarily sort of put a line in the sand and say no more surface parking at Bakery Square just doesn’t really fit in with the character of the development that we have,” he said.

He added that it’s not to Walnut Capital’s advantage to have significant surface parking because it’s expensive and ties up land that could be used for development. Limiting it to 25%, he said, was a “reasonable approach” given the circumstances.

But some commission members saw it differently. Commissioner Peter Quintanilla accused Walnut Capital of “suburban style thinking.” He said putting surface parking between buildings detracts from the architecture and the vibe of a well-planned mixed-use development and can be “detrimental to the urbanism.”

In terms of step backs, the planning staff proposed a 10-foot step back — or indentation — for buildings 65 feet high and another 10-foot step back for those that reached 85 feet. That’s in addition to a 15-foot setback from the street.

Walnut Capital, on the other hand, proposed a 10-foot step back, but only for buildings on Penn Avenue that reached 85 feet in height.

Advertise with us

Planning staff said that requirement was in keeping with buildings constructed in the city’s riverfront zoning districts and in Oakland. Kate Rakus, a senior planning manager, said the idea is to ensure that “it doesn’t feel like you’re walking, driving, or biking down a canyon.”

But Mr. Kamin maintained that such step backs for the types of buildings Walnut Capital is proposing don’t have any benefits for pedestrians or for the view corridor overall.

He also contended that they could make residential projects “economically unfeasible” because of the square footage that would be lost.

“It just seems to make everything more difficult and I’m not sure there’s any practical benefit for doing it,” he said.

In terms of architecture screening for parking garages, Walnut Capital proposed doing so on those sides visible to the public. But planning staff wanted all sides screened.

Advertise with us

Mr. Kamin said such screenings are costly, involving “seven figure numbers.”

“It’s a hard time to get projects to pencil,” he said. “We’re trying to figure out a way to make this thing work from a financial feasibility standpoint, and just adding a million dollars plus in costs is a challenge.”

After the lengthy meeting, Mr. Kamin said that he and Walnut Capital are hoping to “work expeditiously to resolve any outstanding issues so that we can move forward.”

The Bakery Square expansion includes the creation of three new subdistricts featuring a mix of commercial, retail, and residential uses along Penn Avenue, East Liberty Boulevard, adjacent to the East Busway, and across from Mellon Park.

Walnut Capital is planning to start phase one on the far west side at the Club One site. During Tuesday’s meeting, representatives said they hoped to work with tenants in the shopping center to include them in the redevelopment.

Advertise with us

The developer also is planning to keep the popular Trader Joe’s grocery, although there’s a possibility that it may have to move elsewhere within the development at some point.

In addition to the expansion itself, Walnut Capital is proposing nearly $50 million in infrastructure improvements, including two new streets.

The project also includes a community benefits agreement with the Larimer and East Liberty neighborhoods that features a commitment by Walnut Capital to provide $6 million to seed a $25 million fund that would be used to build or rehab for-sale housing in Larimer.

It also has agreed to set aside 15% of the 800 residential units planned on site as affordable and has been working with Mayor Ed Gainey to find ways to fill funding gaps.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.