The Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership is getting behind efforts to create a loan fund to help developers and Golden Triangle property owners convert failing office buildings for residential uses.
Jeremy Waldrup, PDP president and CEO, said in an interview his organization will be “staunch advocates” for the creation of such a fund and could even take a lead role in its development if required.
Some local stakeholders, including the owner of the Golden Triangle’s Gulf Tower, which is being considered for a residential and hotel conversion, have been pushing for the creation of a $55 million Downtown Emergency Impact fund that would provide below-market-rate loans to help fill gaps in construction financing.
The effort comes at a time when the central business district is reeling because of high office vacancies caused in large part by the COVID-19 pandemic and hybrid work policies as well as possible foreclosures as building loans reach maturity. In addition, nearly half a billion dollars in property assessment reductions caused by the various woes could cost the city, the Pittsburgh Public Schools, and Allegheny County millions of dollars in refunds and lost tax revenue.
During a recent meeting, the PDP identified the creation of a development fund as a “high impact” item in which the group could take the lead.
But Mr. Waldrup stressed that he’s not certain yet exactly what role the PDP will play. He said it has been discussing the idea with the city, the Allegheny Conference on Community Development, and other stakeholders.
Read More
He pointed out that operating a loan fund is not something that’s typically within the purview of the partnership, which is involved in initiatives to market Downtown and to keep it clean and safe. It also manages the business improvement district funded by Golden Triangle property owners to pay for services.
“We’re not looking to announce something in the next month. What we are committed to doing is getting these deals done and figuring out who’s in the best position to run the program,” he said. “We don’t operate loan funds now so it probably doesn’t make sense for us to operate one in the future if we can find a partner and the resources to do so.”
At the same time, Mr. Waldrup said that the PDP won’t shy away from a task if it believes it will help Downtown.
“We’re the doers. We want to get things done. If we see an opportunity and it’s in our wheelhouse, we’re going to be all over it,” he said.
He believes there’s a definite need for a loan fund, that office-to-residential conversions are complex projects, and that a loan fund could help fill the gaps in financing, particularly given high interest rates and construction costs and stingier bank lending policies.
“When you talk about this new investment fund, it is looking at what’s it going to take to get Gulf Tower to the finish line. What’s it going to take for 525 William Penn Place ... to convert at least half of that into residential. And that’s where there’s still a gap,” he said.
Aaron Stauber, president of Rugby Realty, the Gulf Tower owner, has said traditional lenders like banks are now offering loans at maybe 55% of a total project cost instead of 75% pre-pandemic.
Just how the loan program would be funded is still being ironed out, Mr. Waldrup said. The model, he said, is the Strategic Investment Fund, a revolving loan program created by the Allegheny Conference and overseen by an independent board.
It is financed through contributions from corporate and philanthropic groups. The fund, which is close to being out of money, is now engaged in another fundraising round.
David Malone, its board chairman, has questioned the need for another loan program, saying one focus of the Strategic Investment Fund is the central business district.
Mr. Waldrup acknowledged that a Downtown development fund would likely try to tap into the same funding sources.
“Is there enough support from the corporate community and the philanthropic community where those dollars exclusively have come from for something like that?” he asked. “And if not, is there an opportunity for something new?”
He added that to get any traction, the fund not only will need the support of developers and building owners, but other stakeholders like the mayor, the county executive, the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority, and the Allegheny Conference.
“We want to see more investment in the core. We think that Downtown has given a lot to this region and the city specifically from the tax base perspective for generations and it’s really important to kind of reinvest in this neighborhood and do so in meaningful ways,” he said.
Whether the PDP spearheads the effort remains to be seen, he added.
“It’s a very valid need and we’re committed to helping figure that out. Where that lands is very much unknown,” he said.
“Something like a fund is not something that we’re equipped to do tomorrow. So that’s going to take a little bit of thoughtful planning and making sure we are best equipped, but we are going to be staunch advocates.”
To some, the Allegheny Conference seemed to a natural to spearhead the creation of such a program given its involvement with the Strategic Investment Fund,
But during an interview earlier this month, Stefani Pashman, the conference’s CEO, said the group is currently focused on a plan to revitalize Downtown, one that is expected to include public realm and infrastructure improvements as well as investments to spur redevelopment.
Funding mechanisms, she added, would be explored once the plan — which could be announced next week — has been finalized.
One idea it has explored in conjunction with the city, the county, and the URA, is the creation of a Downtown Investment Zone funded by new taxes or fees enacted by City Council to help raise $200 million for conversions and public realm improvements.
Its creation would require action by the state Legislature.
In a statement Tuesday, Ms. Pashman said that a DIZ could be “one tool to help revitalize the urban core and its public spaces, support commercial property conversions to address future needs — particularly around a variety of housing options for everyone — and create the all-important balance between vibrant daytime and nighttime economies.
“We value that our state elected officials recognize the importance of many tools to continue the revitalization efforts that will ultimately result in a downtown of the future where people want to be — to live, work and play,” she said.
Mr. Waldrup said the proposed development fund isn’t the only initiative the PDP has been rallying behind in an effort to make it easier financially for Downtown property owners to convert obsolete office buildings to residential or other uses.
It also is advocating for an increase in state historic tax credits to help with such projects. The Pennsylvania program, he said, is currently capped at $500,000 per project and $5 million statewide. It’s “woefully underfunded” compared with such programs in Ohio, West Virginia, and New York, where there’s no cap.
Mr. Waldrup argued that the amount available statewide should climb to at least $50 million to $75 million. The PDP, along with other groups, has been lobbying Congress for federal support to help downtowns still struggling to overcome the pandemic.
“The pandemic has changed every single downtown in this country,” he said. “What are we going to do as a nation to support these vitally important economic” centers?
In addition, the PDP supported the creation of a new 10-year tax abatement program for developers and building owners interested in converting office buildings to residential or other uses. It was approved by City Council earlier this month.
Developers have said both the abatements and loan fund are needed to make conversion projects work on the operational and construction side respectively.
The PDP also has been at the forefront of efforts to clean up Downtown in response to rampant concerns about safety, crime, open drug dealing, lewd behavior, and homelessness, which have prompted some businesses to leave.
To help address such issues, the partnership has added more Downtown ambassadors to assist visitors, residents and office workers and to provide help to those in need; installed portable toilets; and beefed up cleanings in alleyways and other areas.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.