The owner of Downtown’s iconic Gulf Tower says a new tax abatement program approved by City Council this week could be a “game changer” — not only for his properties but for other developers seeking to rehab struggling office buildings.
Aaron Stauber, president of Rugby Realty, said Wednesday that with the passage of the legislation his efforts to convert the 44-story skyscraper to apartments and a hotel and another building to residential “can now move to the next step.”
“But for the passage of the abatement, I don’t think either of those projects could have moved forward,” he said. “Knowing what we know about the financial stack, it would have been too difficult of a hurdle to overcome.”
After weeks of debate, council approved the 10-year tax relief program in an 8-0 vote Tuesday.
Under it, full tax abatements are available to developers who commit to designating at least 10% of the residential units created as affordable to households at 50% of the area median income. A full abatement is also available for Downtown projects where at least 50 full-time jobs are created.
The size of the abatement declines from there depending on the number of jobs or affordable units created. On the jobs side, 40 to 49 jobs brings a 95% abatement and 30 to 39 gets 90%.
Read More
On the housing side, a 95% abatement is available if at least 10% of the units are earmarked for households at 60% AMI; 90% if 10% of the units are at 70% AMI; and 80% if 10% of the units are at 80% AMI.
In a statement Wednesday, Councilman Bobby Wilson, a Democrat who represents most of the Golden Triangle and who was the architect of the legislation, said that it would help to right a Downtown struggling with high office vacancies and a declining tax base caused by massive property assessment cuts.
“This LERTA program is a major tool that the city of Pittsburgh can use to stabilize the Downtown real estate tax market and incentivize the conversion of office towers to residences in our city,” he said.
Mayor Ed Gainey, whose office was instrumental in negotiating amendments to the legislation to strengthen affordable housing requirements, is expected to sign the bill.
The abatement applies to only the improved value of the property, not the current assessment, so the city won’t lose any tax revenue it now receives.
Larry Walsh, a Rugby Realty principal and chief operating officer in Pittsburgh, called the tax abatement program “one piece of the puzzle” in helping to reshape Downtown, adding there’s also a need for more public safety and street cleaning.
“It’s not the panacea that will solve everything but it is a very important step in the right direction,” he said.
At Gulf Tower, Rugby is proposing to convert the historic building into 226 residential units — 27 affordable — on floors 11 to 38, and a 126-room luxury hotel with 27 suites.
Although it is still finalizing plans for the redevelopment, the abatement will have a significant impact, Mr. Walsh said.
“Really getting this [tax abatement] in place was a threshold item,” said Mr. Stauber, who lobbied for passage of the legislation.
At the same time he stressed that it does not guarantee that the project will be completed, noting that many complexities remain.
“But everybody is moving in that direction to hopefully make it successful,” he said.
Rugby also is proposing to convert an eight-story building it owns at 933 Penn Ave. into 70 units with at least 10% and maybe closer to 20% affordable to lower-income households.
Mr. Stauber said he has already had meetings with various city agencies to get the project moving while trying to nail down additional funding sources. Assuming everything falls into place, Rugby hopes to get started on the work early next year, he said.
“I’m optimistic that it will happen,” he said.
Without the abatement, the Gulf Tower project would have been “dead in the water,” Mr. Stauber has said in the past.
He has said he would have had to empty out the building, board it up and shut down the famous weather beacon at its top,
Passing the abatement legislation shows that “the city and its leaders are very serious about supporting these kinds of projects,” he said. “It’s hard to bring developers into the community if everyone in the community is saying don’t come here [by not having such programs].”
Another who hailed the passage of the legislation was Izzy Rudolph, president and CEO of McKnight Realty Partners, which owns a handful of Downtown buildings, including the Heinz 57 Center, the Bank Tower, the Oliver Building, and the Grant Building, which is facing a possible foreclosure.
“We are thankful to council and the mayor’s office for being supportive of Downtown redevelopment and this is the first step of many in bringing Downtown back to its full potential,” he said.
The abatement, he added, provides developers “with a path forward to reinvest in Downtown Pittsburgh.”
Likewise, Michael Polite, senior vice president of development for Beacon Communities, called the new program “huge.”
Beacon is considering residential conversions to three Downtown structures, including the 11-story First and Market Building at 100 First Ave., where it is planning 93 units for seniors at or below 50% of AMI.
Others are the Pittsburgh Allegheny County Thermal complex at 120 Cecil Place and Fort Duquesne Boulevard, where it is proposing 89 units, mostly two and three bedrooms, and the May Building at 111 Fifth Ave., where 86 units are involved.
Beacon is seeking 4% low-income housing tax credits for the Cecil Place and First Avenue projects and 9% for the May Building.
The abatements, Mr, Polite said, will help Beacon “support a little more debt and remove some of the uncertainty for us and our investors” when considering financing requirements and operating costs.
He also said they would help to lower operating costs and make the projects stronger.
“The reality is that you’re serving people of modest incomes. There’s always pressure there. You need leeway in order to make the properties perform over the long term and the abatement gives us some of that leeway,” he said.
Without the abatements, “it would simply drive up the amount of money we would have been asking for,” he said, adding that the cost of debt has increased significantly in recent years.
“So it’s a big deal. It’s important,” he said.
Rick Belloli, Q Development principal, described passage of the abatement legislation as a “good move.”
“None of these things are silver bullet solutions but they all help to lay the groundwork for a more stable, balanced, and robust process and product in Downtown for the future,” he said.
Q did the 136-unit Eighth and Penn residential redevelopment in Downtown and has its eyes open for other possible conversions.
While the abatements represent a “good start,” he said other tools are needed to cultivate more building turnarounds in the city’s core. One would be to raise the amount of money available for historic tax credits in the state, he said.
Pennsylvania has about $5 million available while the pot in neighboring states like Ohio and New York is $50 million to $100 million, he said. The city also needs more secondary loan programs, he explained.
Coupled with the tax abatements, tools like that can make a difference, he said.
“One piece of the pie doesn’t solve it. That’s not to say the [abatement] is not important. It’s definitely important. It moves it in the right direction,” he said.
Mr. Stauber said another element that would be helpful would be to expand the length of the abatement from 10 years to 20 years. Under state law, it is limited to 10, but state Sen. Wayne Fontana, D-Brookline, has introduced legislation to increase it to 20.
“It will really motivate people to do more projects. That’s the goal,” Mr. Stauber said.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.