As discussions surrounding Pittsburgh's finances continue to dominate Grant Street, city lawmakers are close to passing legislation that would offer tax relief for developers looking to revamp empty Downtown buildings.

The new tax abatement program would provide tax relief to developers who convert vacant office space for commercial or residential use. The new development would either have to create jobs or set aside some of the housing units for low-income residents to qualify for the abatement.

Supporters see it as a good first step in revitalizing Downtown, but critics believe the affordable housing component could be stronger.

Cities across the country are grappling with what to do with their downtowns as the pandemic has left many office spaces empty. Pittsburgh is no different; a recent real estate report warned that nearly half of the city’s Downtown office space could be empty by 2028 and two dozen buildings could be in danger of foreclosure.

Advertise with us

That ominous projection could have a lasting rippling effect on the city’s finances, which officials are already projecting will be lean in the coming years. About a quarter of the city’s tax base comes from Downtown, with vacancy rates growing, population shrinking and the largest buildings seeing cuts in their property assessments, city lawmakers and Downtown stakeholders have been having conversations about how to stop the bleeding.

“We’re at a moment in Downtown where we really need to reposition for the future, not only to make Downtown relevant for all, but also to make sure from an economic perspective, we don’t face a real estate collapse like we’re seeing in other cities,” said Stefani Pashman, the CEO of the Allegheny Conference on Community Development.

The Allegheny Conference was one of many partners brought together to help develop and share input on the tax abatement legislation, introduced in March by City Councilman Bobby Wilson, who represents most of Downtown.

“What we’re trying to make sure happens is that we really push for tools that work on all fronts,” Ms. Pashman said. “The purpose of [this program] the way we see it, is to help some of the significant, large multi-use and skyline projects get moving.

The tax abatement would apply to any Downtown development that creates jobs or designates some of the units to be for low-income residents.

Advertise with us

“This is not going to be the magic cushion that makes it all work,” Mr. Wilson said during a previous council meeting, but this could be “one tool to save Downtown.”

Aaron Sukanik, the vice president of the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership said at a council meeting last week that this legislation could help developers close a financing gap that has prevented some of them from starting construction for about two years.

“Downtown’s tax base and its commercial real estate viability need help and need solutions like [this] now,” he said.

The exemption will be applied to the increased value of the property, not the assessed value before any construction, which means the city won’t lose any tax revenue it’s currently making. It will apply for 10 years.

The legislation lays out a step down scale of how much abatement the project can receive. If a developer decides to go the jobs route, they will receive 100% of the abatement for creating 50 full-time jobs. If they created between 40 and 49 jobs, they’ll get 95% and for 30 to 39 jobs it will be 90% of the abatement.

Advertise with us

As for affordable housing, the legislation only requires that 10% of the units be set aside for affordable housing. A developer will get the full abatement if those units are designated for people earning at or below 50% the area median income (AMI). For units at or below 60% AMI, the developer will get 95%, at 70% AMI they’ll get 90% and at 80% AMI they will receive 80% of the exemption.

Experts from Good Jobs First, a Washington D.C. based nonprofit that tracks statewide and local economic development subsidies said that to make any significant impact on the need for affordable housing, setting aside only 10% of the units was too low a goal.

“That’s really just cosmetic,” said Anya Gizis, a research analyst at Good Jobs First. “That’s too low of an amount to make these tax breaks make sense. If they make 200 [units] that’s 20 more units of affordable housing. That’s nothing.”

In a council meeting last month, Councilwoman Barb Warwick said she believed the legislation required a “modest” number of affordable units.

Greg LeRoy, the executive director of Good Jobs First, suggested that rather than offering a variety of incentives, it be “strict across the board.”

Advertise with us

“Make everybody do the same thing so that it’s not wishy-washy,” he said.

Council members too have raised concerns that while this new program will likely help spur development Downtown, the commitment to affordable housing is lacking.

“We want to see hundreds of both market rate and affordable apartments built Downtown, so that we’re repopulating Downtown,” Councilwoman Deb Gross said during a council meeting in April. “I fear that we haven’t really put in as much guarantee as we might have for that public policy outcome.

“But … this is a start,” she said.

Ms. Pashman, of the Allegheny Conference, said that their organization doesn’t see the tax abatement program as “definitively just for housing.”

Advertise with us

“This is a tool that will spur job creation and investment, but it’s one tool. It is not the decisive tool for affordable housing in any way,” she said.

In previous discussions of the legislation, Ms. Warwick said the way the legislation is written, there is “no requirement to build any housing Downtown – affordable or otherwise.”

Developers can receive the full abatement by creating 50 jobs, according to the legislation.

“We are offering to give away millions of tax dollars with zero requirement that they produce any housing at all,” she said.

Washington D.C recently revamped a similar tax abatement program, but it is specifically focused on converting office space to residential. The Pittsburgh program would allow developers to convert the empty offices for commercial use like real estate or into hotels.

Advertise with us

In D.C. to receive the full abatement, 10% of the housing units must be designated for people earning at or below 60% the AMI or 18% of the units have to be for people at or below 80% the AMI.

A final vote on Pittsburgh’s legislation is scheduled for Tuesday. After debates over multiple amendments to the legislation, the bill was preliminarily approved last week in a 9 to 0 vote by council members.

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com