Pittsburgh government spent more than it brought in last year, federal COVID-19 relief funding is about to expire and additional financial shortfalls are looming, city Controller Rachael Heisler said Wednesday as she unveiled the annual finance report.
Here are some of her key points:
A future tax increase could be necessary.
City leaders need to review all spending.
City residents may see a decrease in services they’ve become accustomed to. The projected budget for street paving, for example, has already been decreased by about 75% in future years.
“We have been buoyed by the American Rescue Plan Act for the last four years,” Ms. Heisler said. “I think starting to have a more realistic conversation — both among leaders within this building and then with the public and residents — would really benefit all of us.”
Read More
She said expenditures outpaced revenue last year by more than 2%. From 2022 to 2023, expenses increased by about 10.4%, a factor she called “a drastic change.”
“And that is accounting for the American Rescue Plan Act, and that money goes away in December, effectively,” she said. “The city will need to make that money up somehow.”
Later Wednesday, Deputy Mayor Jake Pawlak said the administration recognizes that the city has financial issues but said they are “manageable.”
“The city ended fiscal year 2023 with a $31.9 million cash surplus; the reserve fund balance at the end 2023 was over $200 million, nearly 1.75 times greater than where it stood in 2019; and first quarter revenue collections are on pace with our projections,” he said in a prepared statement. “We do not anticipate any effect of current economic conditions on city finances that cannot be addressed though normal fiscal management.”
There was no single thing the controller could point to as an explanation for the increased expenses. She said it was “just a general growth.”
Ms. Heisler said she “unfortunately” expects the trend to continue in 2024. So far this year, expenditures are up 125% compared to where they were at this time last year.
Part of that is due to a large pension payment made earlier in 2024 than it was in 2023, Ms. Heisler explained. But expenditures relating to personnel are likely to go up, as one union for city employees just ratified a new contract and another union is still negotiating.
City revenues in 2023 were below what was expected by about $9.5 million, Ms. Heisler said without explanation.
Real estate revenue was about $10 million lower than had been budgeted, and the deed transfer tax was about $21 million lower. The parking and amusement taxes have “effectively rebounded” to pre-pandemic levels, according to the annual report.
“The city has to continue to work on expanding tax base revenue while recognizing the changing market conditions,” Ms. Heisler said. “The last five years have demonstrated the importance of avoiding excessive reliance on any one revenue stream.”
Earlier this year, Ms. Heisler sent a letter to the mayor and City Council members warning about potential problems with two revenue sources: property taxes and the facility usage fees, often called the “jock tax.”
With major buildings in Downtown having their property assessments lowered, the city could see “as much as a 20% reduction in the value of this building stock,” she said in her letter.
The city has also resumed collection of the jock tax, which is paid by athletes and performers who use publicly funded venues like Acrisure Stadium and PPG Paints Arena. The fee is being litigated after Commonwealth Court ruled that it was unconstitutional. If a higher court agrees with that ruling, the city will have to refund at least a portion of the money collected.
“The big picture: Thank goodness for the American Rescue Plan,” Ms. Heisler said.
In previous years, former Controller Michael Lamb had echoed similar sentiments, noting that without the COVID-19 federal relief funding the city likely would have had to lay off workers and cut services.
That funding is also the reason the city “will not have an operating deficit in 2024,” Ms. Heisler said Wednesday.
But this is the last year of those benefits.
All money from the American Rescue Plan must be allocated by the end of this year and be fully spent by the end of 2026. Current budget projections show deficits in 2025 and 2026, when the federal funding is no longer there to boost the balance and the city has to pay off large debt-service bills.
In his statement, Mr. Pawlak said the city is planning for the end of the federal relief funds.
“As we begin the process of preparing Mayor [Ed[ Gainey’s 2025 Budget & Five Year Plan, opportunities to propose new spending will be limited, but the administration remains confident that current programs and initiatives, including those that were initiated in the 2023 and 2024 budgets, can continue, and core city services will not be affected,” he said.
Internal documents from the controller’s office obtained by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette said the city was barreling toward a “fiscal cliff” that could lead to city services being cut or, in the worst case scenario, the city being placed back under state budgetary supervision.
Mr. Pawlak said that won’t happen.
“The city is categorically not at risk of returning to financial oversight, a process that results from long-term, structural weakness, not economic headwinds.”
Ms. Heisler said she didn’t think services such as public safety or public works should be cut, but the city needs “to look at every single expense ... and determine whether or not it’s needed.”
If things continue as they are, some sort of a tax increase is not out of the question. The city gets the majority of its tax income from the earned income tax and property taxes, 23% and 26%, respectively. Currently, residents pay 3% for their earned income tax.
“I think everything should be out on the table,” Ms. Heisler said.
Before it comes to raising taxes, Ms. Heisler — like her predecessor — suggested that the city should work to get some sort of payment from large, local nonprofit organizations.
“We also need to have a conversation around how to grow our regional economy,” she said.
If 5,000 people moved to Pittsburgh over the next five years, “a lot of our financial issues would not be nearly as severe,” she said. “We need to do a better job of recruiting the thousands of college students that we have living within the city to stay.”
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.