Another proposal is being advanced to help developers or Downtown property owners convert failing office buildings to residential — a $55 million loan fund to counter high interest rates and construction costs.

A group of stakeholders, including the owner of Gulf Tower, is calling for the creation of the Downtown Emergency Impact Fund, which would offer below-market-rate loans to help fill gaps in construction financing.

The proposal is separate from the 10-year Downtown tax abatement program approved by City Council last week to also assist in building conversions.

While the abatements would help to cover costs after buildings have been converted, the Downtown Emergency Impact Fund would aid in filling gaps in construction costs, particularly during a time when banks are being more cautious in lending money.

Advertise with us

The various initiatives come at a time when the Golden Triangle is reeling over high office vacancies caused in large part by the COVID-19 pandemic and hybrid work policies and property assessment reductions involving some of its biggest office towers totaling nearly half a billion dollars.

Among those pushing for the creation of the Downtown loan fund is Aaron Stauber, president of Rugby Realty, which owns a number of office buildings in the Golden Triangle, including Gulf Tower.

He said the program would help in a post-COVID environment buffeted by high interest rates and construction costs.

Traditional lenders like banks have become more conservative, offering to provide loans for maybe 55% of the total project cost rather than up to 75% pre-pandemic, he said. Developers typically account for another 20% of the funding. That leaves a gap in the financing.

“I think it’s a really important tool right now for any of these conversion projects that are slated to happen,” Mr. Stauber said.

Advertise with us

According to the proposal, the Downtown Emergency Impact Fund would start at $55 million — enough to “enable most, if not all of Downtown’s truly shovel ready conversion projects to move forward.”

They include Gulf Tower, which Rugby wants to turn into 226 residential units and a 126-room luxury hotel; City Club Apartments, the 300-unit apartment complex to be built at the former YWCA on Wood Street; and Three Gateway Center, which owner Hertz Investment Group wants to convert to 300 apartments.

Proponents are hoping to seed the fund through several sources — including $5 million each from five private and nonprofit stakeholders and $25 million through city and state matches.

Loans would be made at or below current market rates for five years, with the potential to extend if certain covenants are met.

The initial $55 million pot could drive as much as $550 million in investment in Downtown by enabling roughly nine conversion projects to get started, including Gulf Tower, City Club Apartments and Three Gateway Center, the proposal stated.

Advertise with us

But so far the plan doesn’t seem to be generating much enthusiasm.

Mr. Stauber said proponents are still looking for a quasi-governmental group like the Allegheny Conference on Community Development to champion the proposal to help bring it to fruition.

“Developers are waiting — I can’t say patiently — for leadership to come along and lead the charge,” he said.

But Stefani Pashman, the conference’s CEO, said Tuesday that the agency is focused right now on a plan to reimagine Downtown, to get it moving again, and to help position it for the future.

“We need a vision that we all can get behind,” she said.

Advertise with us

At this point, the conference is not zeroing in on funding mechanisms, she said. Once the revitalization plan has been finalized, it will move to exploring funding options, she pointed out.

Ms. Pashman said the conference intends to look at a variety of funding sources, both private and public, when the time comes.

One idea it has been exploring in conjunction with the city, county and the Pittsburgh Urban Redevelopment Authority, is a plan to create a Downtown Investment Zone funded by new taxes or fees to help raise $200 million for conversions and other improvements.

The proposed Downtown emergency loan fund would be similar to the Strategic Investment Fund created by the Allegheny Conference and overseen by an independent board. That loan fund is used to cover financing shortfalls for economic development projects in southwestern Pennsylvania.

Mr. Stauber said the need for the Downtown initiative became more evident when he applied for a Strategic Investment Fund loan to help with financing for the conversion of an office building at 933 Penn Ave. into 70 apartments only to learn that there was no money available.

Advertise with us

“That fund is completely depleted,” he said.

David Malone, board chairman of the Strategic Investment Fund, acknowledged that the money available is “minimal right now,” with the assets “close to fully deployed.”

The last loan, he said, involved $6 million for the conversion of the former GNC headquarters on Wood Street into apartments.

“The demands are high right now,” he said.

He added that the Strategic Investment Fund is in the middle of another fundraising round. He declined to give the amount involved but stated that it was “enough to get some things done but not enough to do everything.”

Advertise with us

At the same time, he questioned whether there was a need to create another loan fund when the Strategic Investment Fund already has a focus on the Golden Triangle. In fact, the fund was created in 1994 to stimulate the economy in Downtown, he said.

“I don’t know why we would create something that does exactly what the Strategic Investment Fund does,” he said.

Mr. Malone noted that he’d love to see additional money available for projects. “If that’s separate from the Strategic Investment Fund, that’s fine with me. I just don’t know why we would create another entity.”

However, Mr. Stauber believes there’s a better chance of getting funding commitments from the foundations and perhaps even the state if the focus is strictly on Downtown.

“My understanding is that these groups are willing to do it but want to have a commitment for Downtown,” he said.

Advertise with us

The city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority has created a $6 million fund to help boost the stock of affordable housing in Downtown. It requires a commitment to make at least 20% of the units affordable to those at 80% of AMI for at least 40 years.

But so far there has been only one taker as developers have shied away for the most part, arguing that the subsidies are not large enough to cover the cost of creating the affordable units. The URA also is seeking $30 million in state grants to help with office-to-residential swaps.

Efforts to do such conversions come amid a growing crisis in Downtown as office buildings struggle to regain occupants following the pandemic. One report estimated that the office vacancy rate — now at 27% with subleases factored in — could jump to 46% by 2028. It also estimated that some two dozen buildings could be in danger of foreclosure.

Adding to the woes is that property assessment reductions are cutting into the tax base and could force the city and the school district to issue millions of dollars in refunds while decreasing their revenues by millions more in the years ahead.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.