During a time when it has taken some property owners more than a year to get the results of assessment appeals, Allegheny County Council is taking steps to expedite the decision making.
Legislation expected to be introduced Tuesday would require the Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review to issue a decision on an appeal within 60 days of the hearing.
And once the decision has been made, the property owner and taxing bodies involved must be notified within the next 30 days.
The effort to speed up the process comes at a time when the assessment board is still struggling to dispose of thousands of appeals dating as far back as 2022.
Last month, by the county assessment office’s own count, there were still nearly 4,000 appeals from 2022 and 2023 awaiting a final outcome. Of those, 1,489 hadn’t even been heard yet.
Delays in resolving appeals stemmed in part from the litigation over the common level ratio, or CLR, the number used in appeal hearings to determine the taxable value of a property.
Read More
Members didn’t decide until last May to use the 63.5% ratio after a round of local and state court battles and a determination by the state tax equalization board, which typically sets the CLR.
But even after that, decisions have been slow in coming. Mike Suley, a former county assessment director who was appointed to the board last fall, estimated that less than 17% of the 2022 appeals that were heard that year had been decided by July 2023.
County Councilwoman Suzanne Filiaggi, the lead sponsor on the legislation to expedite appeals results, said Monday that it is still taking about five months after a hearing to get a decision on an appeal.
“That is way too long. This is keeping property owners on pins and needles and not allowing them to get their own family budgets in line,” she said, adding that taxing bodies are facing the same challenges.
In some cases, school districts and municipalities are getting assessment appeal decisions that could affect their revenues after they’ve already passed their budgets, she noted.
While the controversy over the common level ratio was a big reason for delays, it wasn’t the only factor.
The county also has been using hearing officers to enter the results into the system. It’s part of a long process that starts with the appeal hearing itself, a hearing officer recommendation, a review of the decision, a board member sign off, and entry into the computer system. Assessment officials said the bottlenecks are a result, in part, of the decisions being entered into the computer once board members have signed off.
The proposed legislation stated that it had come to council’s attention that the appeals board had adopted procedures related to reviewing hearing officer recommendations “that are both redundant and time-consuming; and it is the judgment of council that the existing procedures function to delay appeal verdicts unnecessarily.”
Further complicating the efforts, Mr. Suley said, is that a hearing officer is tasked with manually calculating the taxable value of every property based on the common level ratio after a decision has been made on the fair market value. He argued that it all should be computerized.
“We’re using 19th-century technology to get this done,” he said.
While the legislation doesn’t specifically address that claim, it does attempt to streamline the review process.
For appeal hearings conducted by hearing officers, their recommendations would be reviewed by either another hearing officer or an appeals board member prior to a final vote.
In cases where a hearing is conducted by a board member, the recommendation would be reviewed by no more than one other board member before a vote.
Ms. Filiaggi, a Republican who represents District 2, said council is acting because many members are hearing from constituents who are frustrated with the time it has taken to get appeals results.
“There are thousands of appeals that are in limbo. In our districts, we’re all hearing from stakeholders — what can we do to make these decisions more efficient and come in a more timely manner,” she said.
Co-sponsoring the legislation with Ms. Filiaggi are Council President Patrick Catena and Councilman Bob Macey, both Democrats.
They decided on 60 days to render a decision after consultations with Mr. Suley. “We wanted to make it doable for the hearing officers and the board members. In speaking at length with Mike Suley, he felt that this was a good timeline.”
Wayde Fargotstein, assessment board chairman, could not be reached for comment.
The proposed legislation, Mr. Suley said, would bring Allegheny County in line with other counties throughout the state.
“You have an appeal and you usually get your results within a month. We are the only county that takes months to expedite appeals,” he said.
“It’s just frustrating. Thousands of taxpayers and taxing bodies are still waiting to receive dispositions.”
A separate piece of legislation expected to be introduced Tuesday would mandate assessment-related training for board members within six months of their appointment.
Once the training has been completed, board members would be permitted to conduct appeals hearings.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.