For thousands of Allegheny County property owners, the new year will start much like the last one. And even the one before that.
They’re still awaiting the results of assessment appeals.
By the county assessment office’s own count, nearly 4,000 appeals dating back to 2022 are still awaiting final disposition. Of those, 1,489 have yet to be heard — 660 from 2022 and 829 from last year.
In addition, another 2,370 still haven’t received a formal disposition, meaning they can’t be mailed out. Of that number, 839 date back to 2022.
With so many cases still pending, it likely means that those taxpayers — and the taxing bodies involved — probably won’t receive the results until sometime in the new year.
And that’s hard to swallow for one of the newest members of the board of property assessment appeals and review.
Read More
“It makes absolutely no sense why they’re still waiting to get the results of their appeal hearings,” said Mike Suley, a former county assessment director. “If I’m a taxpayer, I’m angry.”
During an assessment board meeting Tuesday, Mr. Suley pressed the county assessment office about the status of the appeals backlog. He maintained that about 9,000 appeals have yet to be finalized, based on his understanding of the numbers.
Lori Brown, county property assessment office appeals manager, said hearings were scheduled for Tuesday and Wednesday to address the backlog but that the next round won’t be heard until Jan. 8. At the same time, she disputed Mr. Suley’s claim that 9,000 appeals still need to be formally resolved. But she said she couldn’t give an exact count without doing further research after being out of the office most of last week.
“I do not know at this time and I do not want to be misquoted. So I’d rather, like I said, let me get caught up and do what I need to on this end so that these questions can be answered accurately,” she said.
The county has been using hearing officers to enter the results into the system. It’s part of a lengthy process that starts with the appeal hearing itself, a hearing officer recommendation, a review of the decision, board member sign off, and entry into the computer system. Assessment officials said the bottlenecks are a result, in part, of the decisions being entered into the computer once board members have signed off.
“It’s an incredibly convoluted process, but it’s the system,” assessment board solicitor Amy Schrempf said.
“I feel like we’re stuck in 1985,” Mr. Suley retorted.
He said afterward he believes the process needs to be streamlined to cut two of the four steps, leaving in place the hearing officer recommendation on the value and a review and signoff by a board member.
The backlogs have frustrated and worried scores or property owners who have been waiting months or even as much as two years to get results from assessment appeals. They also can have a big financial impact since property owners who lose their appeals could end up owing two years’ worth of back taxes — perhaps soon to be three — if the cases date back to 2022.
That’s what happened to Anthony Sappie, a local real estate attorney who owed nearly $8,000 in back taxes dating to 2022 after it took more than a year to resolve his appeal.
His hearing was held on Aug. 12, 2022, and he finally got the decision on Nov. 9 of this year.
“They were nice enough to send my wife and I the bill right before the holidays,” he fumed.
Mr. Sappie said he has clients who are also receiving “massive tax bills” for 2021, 2022, and 2023 after waiting more than a year for results.
“Right now, Allegheny County is the only county in Pennsylvania that operates in this manner. It is borderline criminal,” he said. “The county fails to do consistent countywide reassessments, so the school districts take matters into their own hands and appeal the assessments.”
The delays can also affect school districts and other taxing bodies. In cases where they lose appeals, they could be required to refund two years’ worth of taxes, which could have budget implications depending on the scale.
“We definitely want these dispositions as quickly as possible. It lets us know how big the tax base is. We need to know if it’s shrinking for budget purposes. The longer we go without decisions, it just invites more uncertainty,” said Lee Dellecker, an attorney with Weiss Burkardt Kramer, which represents the Pittsburgh Public Schools and other taxing bodies.
Mr. Dellecker said the good news is decisions on appeals have been picking up speed over the past few months. But, he added, there are still bunches that have yet to be issued.
Like taxpayers, the taxing bodies in some cases have waited more than a year to get results from appeals.
“It’s pretty clear that this train’s off the track,” Ira Weiss, founder and partner of the Weiss law firm, said of the county assessment system. “No one wins with this sort of dysfunction. The property owner, the taxing bodies, it’s not good for anyone.”
The assessment board has blamed the lengthy delays on the litigation over the common level ratio, the figure used in appeal hearings to calculate the value at which property will be taxed. Members didn’t decide until May to use the 63.5% value following local and state court battles and a determination by the state tax equalization board, which typically sets the ratio.
During Tuesday’s assessment board meeting, Mr. Suley said he didn’t understand why it took so long to issue determinations on so many appeals when the decision on the common level ratio came down in May. Assessment board officials had said that many of those cases had been decided and were simply waiting for the ratio to be applied.
But Mr. Suley said that 80% of the appeals he has signed off on over the past three months since joining the board have been from 2022.
“There was a six-month lag time between the time the common level ratio was certified in May. What happened in June, July, August, September, October and November?” he asked.
In response to some of the concerns, assessment officials and some of Mr. Suley’s colleagues noted that it has been anything but a usual year for them.
More than 12,000 assessment appeals were filed for 2022. That included nearly 7,000 that were added this year when the county gave taxpayers a second chance to challenge their 2022 assessments after Common Pleas Judge Alan Hertzberg lowered the common level ratio.
In addition, more than 11,000 appeals were filed for 2023.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.