As many as 1,000 Allegheny County property owners may have to wait until the new year to get the results of assessment appeals filed in 2023.
Lori Brown, county property assessment office appeals manager, told board members Thursday that’s the number that could carry over depending on how many cases are postponed in upcoming weeks.
“One of the things we have to factor [in] is if this is the first time we’re scheduling the hearing. The property owner, school district and municipality do have the right to postpone the hearing,” she said. “So again we look at this number and hope that we can get them scheduled and heard. But there is always that possibility of the school district doing a postponement, the owner doing a postponement, or the municipality.”
Ms. Brown’s comments come as the property assessment appeals and review board is rushing to formally resolve more than 20,000 appeals dating to 2022.
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reported last week that as of Oct. 31, based on county data, 4,166 appeals have yet to be heard — 2,446 from this year and 1,720 from 2022, including 1,609 so-called second chance challenges.
Of the more than 20,000, the bulk — 15,103 — involved appeals that have been heard but were awaiting review by assessment board members before they can go before the full board for disposition.
Read More
That category included 8,189 appeals from this year and 6,914 from 2022. At the time, another 1,017 appeals from 2022 and 2023 were awaiting full board approval.
The delays have frustrated and worried scores of property owners who have yet to get results from appeals dating back more than a year.
Such situations can play havoc with mortgage escrow accounts since some property owners could be forced to pony up two years’ worth of back taxes if their assessments are increased back to 2022.
Likewise, taxing bodies could be faced with budgetary issues if forced to refund two years’ worth of taxes in cases where they lose appeals.
Ms. Brown stressed that the county is trying “the best that we can” to wrap up all 2023 hearings before the end of the year. But she added that much of that could depend on the availability of the property owner and representatives for the school districts.
In some situations, districts may not have enough representatives available to sit in on the hearings.
“So that poses a bit of a challenge for my department when we’re trying to schedule,” she said.
A property assessment office report reviewed by the board Thursday showed that there were still 357 appeals to be scheduled from this year. Another 79 had been postponed and 1,394 had been scheduled or rescheduled but have yet to be heard. Another 1,487 appeals for 2022 fall into those same categories.
But board Solicitor David Montgomery said he believes many of the 2022 appeals involve the same properties and could be heard at the same time as the 2023 hearings.
Assessment board chairman Wayde Fargotstein has vowed to have all of the appeals finished by early 2024 at the latest. Mr. Montgomery is confident the board can do so.
He noted another two days of hearings have been added in December. He estimated as many as 300 cases could be scheduled for those days.
But board member Mike Suley, a former county assessment director, has questioned the timetable, saying he sees no strategy nor any sense of urgency on the part of the board to complete them. He maintains 2022 and 2023 appeals could drag into February.
“I haven’t seen any evidence that there’s an end game,” he said Thursday.
He has threatened to go to court to find a way to speed up the process unless he sees big progress in the number of cases finalized within the next month.
Also Thursday, the board voted to appoint attorney Amy Schrempf to replace Mr. Montgomery, the longtime solicitor who is resigning effective Nov. 21. Ms. Schrempf served on the board from 2008 to 2020, including eight years as chair. Mr. Suley voted against the appointment, arguing that the position should have been advertised before being filled.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.