Pittsburgh International Airport is urging the state Supreme Court to bar the return of the airmall operator it evicted last year, asserting that to do otherwise could pose threats to security and public safety.
In a 35-page petition filed Monday, the airport took its claims about alleged security breaches to new heights, maintaining that the precedent set in allowing Fraport Pittsburgh back on the job could have “grave repercussions for airports and people across the nation.”
The Allegheny County Airport Authority, which operates Pittsburgh International, is asking Pennsylvania’s high court to grant its appeal of a May 9 state Superior Court ruling that in essence ordered Fraport’s return to the job after it was ousted on June 15, 2022.
Airport officials are turning to the Supreme Court after the Superior Court denied its request for a reargument last month. The Supreme Court has the option of either granting or rejecting the authority’s appeal request.
In its brief, the airport argued that the case goes beyond a mere contractual dispute and directly to the heart of security — not only here but elsewhere.
“If left to stand, the Superior Court’s order would render meaningless federal security regulations that govern airports across the nation and that are designed to ensure the safety of the airport and the traveling public,” the petition asserted.
Read More
It also charged that keeping the ruling in place would trump an airport security plan approved by the U.S. Transportation Security Administration as well as other directives issued by the agency.
“Allowing a state court to substitute its own judgment on airport security for that of the airport operator would present a tremendous threat to not only the superseding federal authority of the TSA and other federal agencies but also to the safety of the public,” it stated.
In evicting Fraport, the airport authority used county police to escort employees from the terminal. It maintained at the time that the airmall manager was in default of its lease in part because of alleged security breaches — claims the operator has denied.
Among its charges, the authority contended that a closed restaurant and bar was left unsecured, with alcohol, metal knives and “caustic chemicals” accessible beyond the security checkpoint.
It also alleged that it found an unoccupied retailer kiosk with wall displays that contained “rows of removable solid metal rods and hooks for product display.”
Fraport, which under various names has managed the airmall since its inception in 1992, has vigorously disputed the airport’s charges.
It has stated that the authority was looking to “find something, anything” to pin on it to terminate the lease, which runs until 2029. It also has said that it took steps to resolve any issues the authority raised.
In fact, Fraport has stated that in one instance a pair of scissors was found in an unsecured maintenance closet controlled by the authority, not its employees.
In its May 9 decision, a Superior Court panel overturned county Common Pleas Judge Christine Ward, who had ruled against Fraport’s request for a preliminary injunction to stay on the job.
In reversing her ruling, the three-judge panel concluded that she had erred in determining that the master lease between the authority and Fraport was more a service contract than an actual lease.
In dismissing her finding, it stated that the agreement “is what it says it is — a lease.”
It also rebuked the authority for the “improper use of the Allegheny County police to advance its commercial interests” in evicting Fraport.
The panel added that the authority violated the Landlord Tenant Act of 1951 and the master lease with its “self help” provisions in evicting Fraport and that its conduct was “tantamount to harassment and its reasons for termination were essentially manufactured.”
But in its petition for Supreme Court review, the airport claimed that the Superior Court ignored federal security and safety requirements built into the lease and treated it “as though it were simply a typical commercial lease for a shopping mall or other common retail or commercial space.”
It maintained that the court “failed to acknowledge the serious public-safety and national-security implications that dictated some of the termination logistics.”
The authority also declared that the appellate court panel overstepped its boundaries by “substituting its own judgment for that of the trial court” in reversing the decision and returning it to Judge Ward with instructions to issue the injunction.
In seeking Supreme Court intervention, the authority insisted that the case met several of the tests for such a review — including a question of such substantial public importance that requires prompt and definitive resolution.
On that one, it claimed that it does so because the Superior Court ruling “contradicts federal security regulations in favor of state landlord-tenant law, thereby threatening the safety of the traveling public and ignoring the federal regulations incorporated into the agreement.”
The airport also suggested that the Superior Court departed from accepted judicial practices and abused its discretion in ordering the injunction.
In a statement released Tuesday, Fraport said it “remains confident that the Superior Court properly recognized Fraport’s property interests and the motivations behind the Allegheny County Airport Authority’s actions and allegations.
“Fraport is, and at all times has been, dedicated to the safety and security of the retail options provided to the traveling public. Upon our return to the Airport, we intend to continue in such manner.”
Bob Kerlik, airport authority spokesman, said the petition for review speaks for itself.
Since evicting Fraport, the airport authority has been overseeing the airmall and its mix of shops and restaurants. It at one point offered Fraport $5 million to buy out its lease, an offer the operator rejected.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.