Pittsburgh International Airport has lost its latest bid to block the court-ordered return of the airmall operator it evicted 13 months ago.

The Pennsylvania Superior Court, in a one-sentence order issued last week, denied a request by the Allegheny County Airport Authority for a reargument of its May 9 ruling related to the case.

In that decision, a three-judge court panel reversed a ruling by county Common Pleas Court Judge Christine Ward last year denying the request by airmall manager Fraport Pittsburgh for a preliminary injunction to stay on the job after its eviction.

The panel returned the case to Judge Ward with instructions to issue the injunction — in essence, putting Fraport back to work.

Advertise with us

With the denial of the request for reargument, the airport authority, which operates Pittsburgh International, is left with just one other legal option in an effort to prevent Fraport’s return — an appeal to the state Supreme Court.

“We are very pleased that the full Superior Court has refused to revisit the decision reinstating Fraport as master tenant. We look forward to returning to the Pittsburgh International Airport and resume providing a best-in-class retail and consumer program for all travelers,” Fraport said in a statement Wednesday.

The airport authority, on the other hand, vowed to head to the next level even though the high court is not required to take the case.

“We plan to appeal the Superior Court’s decision, which we believe incorrectly overturned the lower court’s previous ruling, as it heard the facts of the case first-hand,” it stated.

The authority ousted Fraport on June 15, 2022, using county police to escort employees from the terminal. It maintained at the time that Fraport was in default of its lease, in part because of alleged security breaches — claims the operator has denied.

Advertise with us

It continued to try to paint Fraport as a security risk in its statement Wednesday.

“As an airport, if we aren’t safe and secure — nothing else matters. We have no room for error when a partner chooses to misrepresent their actions and attitudes regarding ensuring the safety of passengers, airport staff and airline crews,” it stated.

“We previously terminated our relationship with Fraport — which we are contractually allowed to do — because we documented careless mishandling of knives and other prohibited items on multiple occasions that were found unguarded in the terminal beyond the TSA security checkpoint. Fraport misrepresented the quality of their services and their corrective action plan.”

However, the operator has repeatedly rejected the authority’s contention that it was responsible for multiple security breaches.

It has stated that airport officials were looking to “find something, anything” to pin on it to terminate the lease, which runs until 2029. It added that it took steps to resolve any issues the authority raised.

Advertise with us

After being evicted, Fraport sought court relief through the preliminary injunction to return to work. It argued that terminating its lease would end its existence because Pittsburgh was the only airport it served.

The firm, under various names, has managed the airmall since its inception in 1992.

In overturning Judge Ward, the Superior Court panel concluded that she had erred in determining that the master lease between the authority and Fraport was more a service contract than an actual lease.

In succinctly dismissing her finding, it stated in its May 9 ruling that the agreement “is what it says it is — a lease.”

It also chastised the authority for the “improper use of the Allegheny County Police to advance its commercial interests” in evicting Fraport.

Advertise with us

The panel stated that act alone was grounds for the preliminary injunction. In taking the action, the authority violated both the Landlord Tenant Act of 1951, which sets forth procedures for eviction, and the master lease, which includes “self help” provisions to resolve potential problems, the panel determined.

It added that the authority’s conduct toward Fraport “was tantamount to harassment and its reasons for termination were essentially manufactured.”

The authority, in making its case for reconsideration or reargument, accused the panel of “a cherry picking of the language and provisions in the agreement that could evidence a traditional lease” while ignoring those that Judge Ward believed supported a services contract.

It also maintained that the judges ignored federal security obligations built into the lease, adding that it was “flat-out dangerous for the panel to second guess” its and Judge Ward’s assessment of what legal remedies were required in the case.

Since evicting Fraport, the authority itself has been overseeing the airmall and its mix of shops and restaurants. It at one point offered Fraport $5 million to buy out its lease, an offer the operator rejected.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com