Pittsburgh International Airport is fighting a court ruling ordering the return of the airmall operator it evicted last year.

The Allegheny County Airport Authority is seeking a reargument before the entire Pennsylvania Superior Court, or reconsideration by the three-judge court panel that decided the case.

In an 18-page appeal filed Tuesday, the authority, which operates the Findlay airport, maintained the panel overstepped its bounds in ordering Fraport Pittsburgh back to work.

It also chided the trio for failing to take into account security issues that it claims were among the reasons for the eviction, charging that it was “flat-out dangerous” to second-guess that authority and a lower court on such matters.

Advertise with us

On May 9, the Superior Court panel reversed a decision by county Common Pleas Court Judge Christine Ward that denied Fraport’s request for a preliminary injunction to stay on the job managing airmall shops and restaurants.

It returned the case to Judge Ward for the issuance of a preliminary injunction “restoring Fraport’s rights in accordance with the master lease” — in essence putting the firm back on the job.

However, with the appeal, the panel’s ruling likely will be stayed, effectively putting the concessionaire’s return on hold while the decision is reviewed.

Fraport sought the injunction after airport authority officials, accompanied by county police, evicted its employees from Pittsburgh International June 15 after claiming it had defaulted on its lease, in part because of alleged security breaches.

Judge Ward refused to grant the relief, ruling that the master lease governing the relationship between the parties was more of a service contract than an actual lease — one that could be compensated by monetary damages if the authority acted illegally.

Advertise with us

But the Superior Court panel rejected that finding, stating that the agreement between Fraport and the authority “is what it says it is — a lease.”

In addition, the court ruled that Judge Ward erred in not finding that Fraport’s eviction would amount to irreparable harm, a legal standard used in deciding preliminary injunction cases.

It also criticized the authority for using county police “to advance its commercial interests” to remove Fraport, which under various names had operated the airmall since its inception in 1992.

That, the panel stated, should have been grounds alone to order the preliminary injunction.

However, in its appeal, the airport authority pushed back against such assertions.

Advertise with us

It maintained that the panel essentially substituted its own judgment for that of Judge Ward while “giving no deference to the trial court’s reasonable grounds for denying injunctive relief.”

That was particularly true, it argued, in the lease issue.

The authority accused the panel of a “cherry-picking of the language and provisions in the agreement that could evidence a traditional lease — to the express exclusion of the clauses and course of performance that Judge Ward found supported a services contract.”

“Contrary to the panel’s suggestion, Judge Ward did not ignore the lease aspect of the agreement. She simply found, based on the totality of the evidence she heard, that the services obligations and performance of the agreement outweighed its operation as a lease,” it stated.

It also chastised the panel for “allowing its opinions on the underlying merits of the authority’s removal of Fraport from the airport to improperly influence its decision.”

Advertise with us

The authority cited as evidence the panel’s statement that its conduct in evicting Fraport “was tantamount to harassment and its reasons for termination were essentially manufactured.”

“In addition to there being no basis in the record for such statements, whether the authority’s actions were ‘tantamount to harassment’ or its reasons for termination were ‘essentially manufactured’ has no bearing on the limited issue before the panel relating to whether or not the trial court had apparently reasonable grounds for finding that Fraport failed to establish irreparable harm,” it stated.

“Simply put, it was plain error for the panel to substitute its own judgment for that of Judge Ward. Doing so undermines the role of trial judges in our judicial system and should not be countenanced.”

But the authority saved some of its sharpest criticism of the panel in claiming that the judges ignored security-related regulations in the lease in deciding in Fraport’s favor.

The panel stated in its ruling that the authority, in using county police to evict the concessionaire, violated the Landlord Tenant Act of 1951 and “self help” provisions in the lease.

Advertise with us

The authority countered that the lease was written to give it discretion to ensure “that its judgment on security issues was respected,” as required under federal law.

“Yet the panel ignored the federal security obligations built into the agreement and treated the agreement as though it were a typical commercial lease for a shopping mall,” it said.

It said that the panel paid “inappropriate fealty to the Landlord Tenant Act above all else.”

“It is flat-out dangerous for the panel to second guess the authority’s and the trial court’s assessment that Fraport’s legal remedies would suffice and to order the authority to allow a party who has a track record of putting the public at risk back in the airport,” the authority claimed. “It flies in the face of the separation of powers, federal regulations, and the agreement’s own text for the panel to adjudicate Fraport’ safety record (under the guise of property law) when that job belongs solely to the authority. The potential harm to the public interest is tangible.”

In terminating Fraport’s lease, the authority accused the concessionaire of security breaches, including the careless handling of knives and other prohibited items. And the authority said it failed to perform required daily inspections, or do them adequately.

Advertise with us

Fraport, however, has rejected such allegations, arguing that it took steps to correct all issues raised by the authority. It charged that the authority was looking to “find something, anything” to pin on it to unlawfully terminate its lease.

It has maintained that the alleged security incidents were an attempt by the authority “to gain commercial advantage over a longtime business partner.”

In response to the appeal, Fraport stated Tuesday that it was “reviewing the ACAA’s latest filing challenging the unanimous decision of Judge [Dan] Pellegrini and the Pennsylvania Superior Court reinstating Fraport Pittsburgh at the Pittsburgh International Airport.

“We remain convinced that the decision is correct and well-reasoned. We will respond through our own court submission if needed,” it said.

Airport authority spokesman Bob Kerlik said the filing speaks for itself.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com