In a major reversal, the operator of Pittsburgh International Airport’s popular airmall, evicted last June, could be returning to the job after a ruling Tuesday by a state appellate court.

The Pennsylvania Superior Court reversed an August decision by Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Christine Ward that denied a request by Fraport Pittsburgh for a preliminary injunction to stay on the job.

In doing so, the three-judge panel ordered the case returned to the local court “to enter a preliminary injunction restoring Fraport’s rights in accordance with the master lease” — a mandate that presumably could involve the company’s reinstatement.

And that’s exactly what the operator wants, Michael Mullaney, CEO of parent company Fraport USA, said in a statement after the ruling.

Advertise with us

“We look forward to further vindicating our rights as the case progresses, while expeditiously returning to our world-class management of the Pittsburgh Airport concession program and continuing to serve the Pittsburgh community in conjunction with our subtenant partners as we have done for the 30-plus years,” he said.

But the Allegheny County Airport Authority signaled Tuesday that it will fight to prevent that from happening, stating that it plans to appeal the Superior Court order. It maintained that the panel “incorrectly overturned” Judge Ward’s ruling.

If the authority does appeal, it could trigger a stay of Tuesday’s ruling, effectively putting the Fraport’s return on hold while the decision is reviewed.

Fraport sought the preliminary injunction after airport authority officials, accompanied by the county police, evicted its employees from Pittsburgh International last June 15 after claiming the concessionaire defaulted on its lease, in part because of alleged security breaches.

In arguing for the injunction, Fraport stated that terminating the lease would end its existence because Pittsburgh was the only airport it served. The firm, under various names, had operated the airmall since its inception nearly 31 years ago.

Advertise with us

Judge Ward, in denying the injunction, concluded that the master lease that governed the relationship between the parties was more of a service contract than an actual lease. If the authority illegally ended the contract, Fraport could be compensated through monetary damages after a trial, she ruled.

The denial of the relief cleared the way for the airport authority to remove Fraport and take over the concessions program.

But in its 19-page opinion, the Superior Court panel flatly rejected Judge Ward’s contention that the dispute involved a service contract, not a lease.

“Although the trial court characterized the master lease as predominately a services contract, the language of the agreement could not be more clear that the agreement between Fraport and ACAA is what it says it is — a lease,” Senior Judge Dan Pellegrini wrote.

He cited a number of references in the document that refer to it as a master lease or to the parties as “lessor” or “lessee.”

Advertise with us

“These are two sophisticated parties and if their primary intention was to craft a services agreement, they would have labeled the document a ‘Master Service Agreement’ and not a Master Lease,” he wrote. “Moreover, there is nothing in the master lease to even give a whiff that the [airport authority] and Fraport intended to do anything other than enter a lease.”

The panel also determined that Judge Ward erred in not finding that Fraport’s eviction would amount to irreparable harm, the legal standard used in deciding whether to issue a preliminary injunction.

It stated that where there is a real property interest, “the loss of that interest constitutes irreparable harm.”

After noting that Fraport had rejected a $5 million offer by the airport authority to buy out its lease, which expires in 2029, the panel stated that the authority “interfered with Fraport’s property rights and effectively forced the result it wanted.”

The court panel also harshly criticized the authority for the way it went about removing the operator, including the “improper use of the Allegheny County Police to advance its commercial interests to evict Fraport.”

Advertise with us

Even without the lease versus service contract issue, that should have been grounds alone to order the preliminary injunction, it stated.

In addition to using police to escort Fraport employees out of the terminal, the authority informed the concessionaires that Fraport oversaw that it was now “managing” the airmall, the panel pointed out.

By using the police, the authority violated both the Landlord Tenant Act of 1951, which sets forth procedures for eviction, and the master lease, which includes “self help” provisions to resolve potential problems.

“In this case, ACAA employed self-help by using Allegheny County Police, who are at the airport to protect the public safety, to advance instead its commercial interests to forcibly remove Fraport personnel from the property,” Judge Pellegrini wrote.

“By doing so, the [authority’s] actions were contrary to both the Landlord Tenant Act as well as the terms of the master lease limiting its remedies to only those available in law and equity, and constituted irreparable injury as a matter of law. ACAA’s conduct was a seizure of Fraport’s real and personal property, including the leases it had with its subtenants.”

Advertise with us

While Judge Ward had termed the airport authority’s grounds for evicting Fraport as “dubious,” the panel added that its “conduct was tantamount to harassment and its reasons for termination were essentially manufactured.”

In his statement, Mr. Mullaney said the operator was “delighted that the Superior Court has recognized the nature of Fraport Pittsburgh’s interest in the airport and further determined that the Allegheny County Airport Authority’s eviction by force and without utilizing the court process was improper.”

On the other hand, the airport authority, in the aftermath of the ruling, insisted that it had acted in response to security concerns.

“We previously terminated our relationship with Fraport — which we are contractually allowed to do — because we documented careless mishandling of knives and other prohibited items on multiple occasions that were found unguarded in the terminal beyond the TSA security checkpoint. Fraport misrepresented the quality of their services and their corrective action plan,” the authority stated.

It added that as an airport, “if we aren’t safe and secure — nothing else matters. We have no room for error when a partner chooses to misrepresent their actions and attitudes regarding ensuring the safety of passengers, airport staff and airline crews.”

Advertise with us

Fraport has rejected such claims, arguing that it took steps to correct all of the issues raised by the authority as well as alleged defaults dating back to September 2021.

It has charged that the authority was looking to “find something, anything” to unlawfully terminate its lease. It also maintained the alleged “security incidents” cited by the authority “were solely part of an effort to gain commercial advantage over a longtime business partner.”

In addition, the company has stressed that it “is, and at all times has been, dedicated to the safety and security of the retail options provided to the traveling public.”

“Fraport Pittsburgh, and all of the Fraport USA family of companies, strive to provide a high-end, and safe, shopping and dining experience for the traveling public,” Mr. Mullaney added Tuesday.

Richard Heppner Jr., an assistant professor of law at Duquesne University, said the airport authority could appeal Tuesday’s decision to the entire Superior Court or to the state Supreme Court, which has the option or either taking the case or disregarding it.

Advertise with us

In conjunction with that, the authority, he explained, likely will move to stay the panel’s ruling while the appeal runs its course. That would prevent the preliminary injunction from immediately going into effect.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com