An Allegheny County judge has rejected a bid by the operator of Pittsburgh International Airport’s popular airmall to stay on the job after being ousted temporarily in June.
In an order issued Wednesday, Common Pleas Court Judge Christine Ward denied a preliminary injunction requested by Fraport Pittsburgh after its contract was terminated by the Allegheny County Airport Authority on June 15.
The denial of the preliminary injunction apparently clears the way for the authority to remove Fraport, which has operated the concessions program at the airport since the midfield terminal opened in 1992.
With the ruling, the authority, which oversees Pittsburgh International, “will assume management of airport concessions operations to ensure a safe, secure and positive experience for passengers and staff at the airport,” according to a statement issued by solicitor Jeff Letwin. It is expected to do that Thursday, an authority spokesperson said.
“The safety and security of everyone at Pittsburgh International Airport is our top priority and cannot be compromised. We took steps to terminate our relationship with Fraport, which we are contractually allowed to do, because we documented a steady decline in their performance,” Mr. Letwin said.
“We are pleased that today Judge Ward agreed with our position and denied Fraport’s motion for an injunction to continue to operate our airport concessions program.”
Read More
In its own statement, Fraport said it was disappointed in the decision and will evaluate its legal options while reserving rights and remedies.
“This result puts Fraport Pittsburgh, its employees, as well as its vendors and suppliers in a difficult position. We would note that this decision will permit the airport authority to dismantle Fraport Pittsburgh’s award-winning program at the airport, potentially terminate valued and long-term business partners. This is not the result that Fraport Pittsburgh sought as we simply wanted to complete the remaining term of our commercial lease, which has been in place since 1991, and continue to serve the traveling public,” it stated.
In her five-page order and memorandum, Judge Ward said Fraport had not shown that the damage it would suffer if the preliminary injunction were not granted would be “irreparable,” a legal standard in such cases.
“Though the agreement at issue in this case is characterized as a leasehold, it is more in the nature of a commercial contract for services, the breach of which is adequately compensable with damages,” Judge Ward wrote.
Fraport has argued that terminating the lease would end its existence since the only airport it serves is Pittsburgh.
Airport authority officials, accompanied by the county police, evicted Fraport employees from Pittsburgh International on June 15 after claiming that the company was in default of its lease, in part because of alleged security breaches.
After Fraport filed a lawsuit over the action, Judge Ward issued a special injunction ordering the company back on the job until a hearing could be held on Fraport’s request for a preliminary injunction.
Fraport, under various names, has operated the airmall since its inception 30 years ago. The concept, which requires retailers and restaurants to charge the same prices they would at similar non-airport locations, has been well received by travelers.
But the company began falling out of favor with Pittsburgh International officials last year, with the authority claiming that Fraport was jeopardizing passenger safety by not performing required daily inspections or not doing them adequately — charges the operator has denied.
The authority has maintained that it took action to evict Fraport only after multiple attempts to address that issue and other alleged defaults dating back to September 2021 failed.
Fraport has argued that it took steps to correct all of the issues raised by the authority. It has charged that the airport was looking to "find something, anything" to unlawfully terminate its lease, which runs until the end of 2029.
It took a similar tack in its statement Wednesday.
“As the evidence at a three-day hearing demonstrated, Fraport Pittsburgh, which has never been cited by the airport authority or any other governmental body for security-related deficiencies, believes that the alleged ‘security incidents’ advanced by the airport authority were solely part of an effort to gain a commercial advantage over a long-time business partner. Fraport Pittsburgh is, and at all times has been, dedicated to the safety and security of the retail options provided to the traveling public,” it said.
In her memorandum, the judge stressed that while she had “serious concerns regarding the pretextual nature of the ACAA’s alleged defaults, those issues need not be addressed by the court now.”
“Whether the alleged events of default were material, whether they were sufficiently cured, or whether they were conjured by the ACAA to find a way out of its contractual obligations, are all issues that are better left to be resolved at trial,” she said.
She added, “The question facing the court presently is whether, having established a likelihood that the ACAA breached its obligations under the lease agreement, Fraport has shown that it will suffer immediate and irreparable harm that cannot be adequately compensated by money damages. However, Fraport has not shown that its harm is irreparable.”
Given that Judge Ward denied Fraport’s request for a preliminary injunction, that trial could be limited to what, if any, monetary damages the company is entitled to after being removed as the operator.
The judge noted that the authority at one point had offered Fraport $5 million to buy out the remainder of its lease. Mike Mullaney, CEO of Fraport USA, the parent of Fraport Pittsburgh, countered with an offer of $20 million. During three days of testimony on the request for the preliminary injunction, there was dispute over whether that offer later was reduced to $10 million.
If the authority does take over management of the concession program, it does not mean it would stay in that role long term, CEO Christina Cassotis testified during last month’s preliminary injunction hearing, saying that it’s "not our skill set and not our business."
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.