When Mike Mullaney huddled with Christina Cassotis, the top official at Pittsburgh International Airport, last September over the operations of the popular airmall, she quickly cut to the chase.
Ms. Cassotis, CEO of the Allegheny County Airport Authority, made it “abundantly clear” she wanted to end the lease of airmall operator Fraport Pittsburgh and take over the concessions operations, Mr. Mullaney testified Friday.
During the meeting, Ms. Cassotis stated there “wasn’t a single contract that she couldn’t get out of if she wanted to,” recalled Mr. Mullaney, CEO of Fraport USA, the parent company to Fraport Pittsburgh.
Before that sit down, the Pittsburgh airport authority had even proposed a buyout amount — $5 million, with the airmall operator countering at one point with $20 million, according to testimony.
The details emerged during a hearing on Fraport’s bid for a preliminary injunction to keep it on the job after the authority tried to terminate its lease last month. In seeking to evict its longtime tenant — whose contract goes back to the opening of the midfield terminal in 1992 — the authority claimed the airmall operator was in default of its lease in part because of security breaches that jeopardized public safety.
After filing a complaint over the eviction, Fraport got a special injunction from county Common Pleas Court Judge Christine Ward to remain in place while its request for an emergency preliminary injunction is decided.
Read More
The airmall has been a popular attraction at Pittsburgh International since it was first conceived in 1992 after the late county commissioner Pete Flaherty complained about a high priced cup of coffee at the old terminal. The airmall was a departure from other airports’ concession programs at the time, with retailers and restaurants required to charge the same price for food and services as they would at similar non-airport locations.
Before the pandemic, there were 72 airmall concessionaires with 550 employees. That since has dropped to 54 vendors with about 375 employees. Stores at the airmall sell everything from Primanti’s sandwiches to shoes and clothing.
During about three hours of testimony Friday, Mr. Mullaney recounted a series of meetings and events last year involving the airport authority that led up to the June 15 termination.
They started in mid-June 2021 when Eric Sprys, the authority’s chief financial officer, told him the authority wanted to end the lease, which runs until the end of 2029, and offered a $5 million buyout.
Fraport rejected the offer, with Mr. Mullaney testifying Friday that wasn’t “anywhere near fair commercial compensation” for a lease that still has seven years to run — particularly after his company had invested the same amount in airmall improvements.
In meetings about the lease, Ms. Cassotis said at one point that Pittsburgh International should have a concessions program similar to that at “some of the largest airports in the world,” he stated, and that it should include “high end retail.”
During questioning from counsel for the airport authority, Mr. Mullaney conceded that the airmall operator did at one point suggest $20 million as a possible buyout amount. Asked if that was later reduced to $10 million, he replied, “I don’t recall that.”
“There’s nothing in this contract that contemplates that we could be bought out,” he said.
About the same time as the meeting with Ms. Cassotis, Fraport began receiving a series of letters from the authority raising complaints about its performance, including a lack of required daily airmall inspections, possible security breaches, and alleged defaults. Those letters continued into January, when the authority stated that it would be filing a lawsuit over the various issues.
In each case, Fraport sought to address the complaints, Mr. Mullaney testified. After the January letter, “We believed all of the items had been addressed and cured,” he said.
In its response to the airmall operator’s complaint, the authority has alleged that it sent a notice of default September 2021 only after Fraport failed to rectify multiple breaches, including several involving safety. Among the most serious, it stated, involved failure to make daily airmall inspections required under its lease.
It also detailed instances when metal knives, hammers, screwdrivers, a pair of scissors and caustic chemicals were left unsecured in the airside building, where travelers get on and off planes.
Amy Saylor, who headed Fraport’s operations at Pittsburgh International from July 2019 to June 5, 2022, testified that the first time the authority raised safety and security issues was in its September 2021 letter.
In 2019, before the pandemic, relations between the two parties were “very cordial, cooperative” with any issues typically resolved through phone calls, texts, or emails, she said. Asked if the authority ever accused the company of jeopardizing public safety during that period, she replied that it had not.
Fraport has painted some of the breaches alleged as “minor operational issues,” claiming that the authority was trying to “find something, anything” to give it cover to unlawfully terminate the lease.
But during questioning by Joseph Valenti, the authority’s attorney, Ms. Saylor acknowledged that an unsecured knife or unsecured caustic chemicals were not minor issues.
The authority also alleged numerous instances when the company didn’t do daily inspections as required under its master lease, including 14 after the September 2021 letter. In investigating, Ms. Saylor testified that she found notes or reports indicating that inspections were in fact conducted on 12 of the 14 days cited by the authority.
The hearing on the request for the preliminary injunction is scheduled to continue July 13 with more testimony. The airport authority has yet to put on its case.
In its filing in response to the Fraport complaint, the authority argued against a preliminary injunction, claiming that it should not be forced to retain the operator “to the detriment of ACAA or, more importantly, public safety.” It alleged that it took the action to evict the company only after trying to work with the operator for more than nine months to rectify the problems.
But Fraport attorney Thomas Jones, in his opening statement, charged that the authority acted as “judge and jury” in trying to evict its airmall operator.
Mr. Mullaney testified that Fraport Pittsburgh would suffer irreparable harm if the eviction stands since it operates only at the Findlay airport. “Unfortunately, it will cease to exist,” he said.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.