Much of the public meeting Monday about proposed rezoning to allow redevelopment adjacent to Bakery Square was conducted civilly, as residents asked questions of developer Walnut Capital of its plans for a mixed-use complex.
Questions were asked about the businesses that were envisioned, whether Trader Joe’s would stay, and what type of transportation enhancements would occur in the area.
But then, state Rep. La'Tasha D. Mayes — whose district, the 24th, includes the proposed site — took a microphone and shared concerns that many other residents in the room shared, about the historical displacement of Black people and how such a project could exacerbate those problems.
“I think that Bakery Square is not for me,” Ms. Mayes said. “I don’t see Black people working at the stores, I don’t see Black people utilizing the attractions, I don’t think that Black folks are living in the existing tract of this [special planning district] ... that doesn’t instill confidence, as you want to expand this [district].”
Walnut Capital representatives had stressed to residents that no site plans or development had been made yet, as the City Council still needed to vote to approve expanding the special planning district — a zoning overlay that allows for mixed-use development in certain neighborhoods in Pittsburgh. That district would allow Walnut Capital to redevelop the site and connect it to Bakery Square to the east.

Todd Reidbord, a co-founder and president of Walnut Capital, disputed Ms. Mayes’ claim. He said Bakery Square was a diverse community consisting of people of varying socioeconomic backgrounds and ethnicities.
“I invite you to come to Bakery Square on a Sunday morning, and watch the people that go in and out, go to the restaurants and go to the shops,” Mr. Reidbord told Ms. Mayes. “Come on a Friday evening after work, and see the diversity of people there ... you see people of all different colors, sizes, shapes and ethnicities.”
After a brief back-and-forth, Ms. Mayes asked scores of Black people in the audience, who made a sizable portion of the 100-plus people in attendance during Monday’s meeting, whether the Bakery Square development was for them. Their response: “No.”
But Mr. Reidbord, who said his family goes back at least four generations in the area, kept challenging those in attendance to visit the development, and see who works and plays there.
That interaction was just one of several tense points during Monday’s meeting. Some residents, who were supportive of the rezoning and potential redevelopment, still had concerns about building heights, traffic impacts, and other logistical issues. But many, including several Black residents, remained concerned that any future redevelopment at the site would result in displacement of their communities, something they said they’ve experienced in prior decades.

Valerie Parm, president of the Village Collaborative of East Liberty, a registered community organization within the city where much of the rezoning would occur, repeated to residents that no proposed redevelopment had been introduced, because the City Council still needed to vote on the expansion of the Special Planning District.
The proposed expansion is currently being reviewed by the city’s Planning Department and Planning Commission, and there would be more public meetings in the future before any final vote on such legislation for the rezoning would occur. Ms. Parm said that questions about any proposed redevelopment would be more appropriate at a later venue.
But she emphasized that the Village Collaborative was “the voice of the people” and would be represented as such to Walnut Capital, city officials and elected leaders.
One aspect of the proposed rezoning and potential redevelopment that could help get the rezoning over the line is a community benefits agreement. Mr. Reidbord said after the meeting that he believed that agreement was close to being finalized.
Some of the proposals for that agreement include the construction or renovation of more than 100 homes in Larimer, and close to $5 million in funding for affordable housing, health and wellness, education, and workforce development in the communities. Mayor Ed Gainey and City Councilman Ricky Burgess, whose district includes the rezoning and potential redevelopment site, would need to approve.
Despite concerns about potential displacement, residents and Walnut Capital did agree that there needed to be better transit opportunities, along with friendlier pedestrian access, including how the site connects to Penn Avenue.
“Transit is one of the key components of Bakery Square,” Mr. Reidbord said. “We have to bring people by transit; we can’t park everyone there. So nothing is more important to us than having transit for the people of Bakery Square.”
But, like he had told several residents during the meeting, it was too soon to envision what any sort of development might look like, given the economic uncertainties regarding office space and development in the years following the COVID-19 pandemic.
“We’ve said from the very beginning that we envision a true mixed-use development,” Mr. Reidbord said. “There will be opportunities for retail, office [space], and grocery stores, locally owned businesses and nationally owned businesses. It’s just hard to tell today where the economy is going to take us.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.