A developer pressed forward Thursday with a plan to build an eight-story condominium building at the former Irish Centre site in Squirrel Hill despite considerable opposition from nearby residents and others.

During a four-hour hearing before the Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment, Craft Development Corporation billed the proposed project as a “unique residential community” that would replace blighted vacant buildings.

Opponents decried it as a “detriment to the public welfare” that could alter the character of adjacent Frick Park.

Representatives of Craft urged the zoning board to approve a variance to allow it to build to eight stories and a height of nearly 88 feet in a zoning district where the maximum is 40 feet and three stories.

Advertise with us

In addition, it is pushing for another variance to build in a parks district, where multi-unit residential is not permitted.

Early on, zoning board chairwoman Alice Mitinger seemed to sum up the challenge facing Craft in developing the property at 6886 Forward Avenue just before it turns into Commercial Street.

“You're candid about saying that this is a multi-unit residential use that’s not permitted in a parks district and you’re also significantly exceeding the height limitation. So, okay. Carry on,” she said.

During the Craft presentation, architect Ryan Indovina argued that the eight-story, 160-unit building represented the “sweet spot” in terms of the project’s economic viability.

The developer looked at doing 10 to nearly 60 single-family houses at the site, but determined that neither would produce a profit.

Advertise with us

While 80- and 131-unit condo units would generate a 6% and 10% return, respectively, neither was deemed to be viable. The 160-unit complex would generate an estimated 12.39% return.

That, Mr. Indovina maintained, “is aligned with the realities of financing developments in today’s financial environment. So any third-party investor or bank would not invest in this development at 6% return, therefore the project would not be possible at the rate.”

Part of the challenge in developing the site is that running a water line to it will cost an estimated $4.5 million alone, he said.

While the complex will total eight stories, Mr. Indovina told the zoning board that two floors will “almost entirely” be below grade for use as a 182-space parking garage. While the tallest point of the building will be nearly 88 feet, another section will be as low as 59 feet, he said.

In seeking to address concerns about water runoff and flooding, Mr. Indovina said the developer is planning above and below ground retention tanks to capture stormwater. The existing site, he points out, has no stormwater controls.

Advertise with us

While there are community concerns that runoff from the development would negatively impact the park and Nine Mile Run, “in this case, I just want to be clear that it would not,” he said.

The developer also sought to dispel concerns about traffic safety. It estimated that the complex would generate 59 trips in and out at the morning peak hour and 62 in the afternoon peak.

Both are below the state threshold of 100 required to trigger a traffic study, according to Craft. It also presented statistics showing there were only seven accidents between 2018 and 2022 on the windy stretch of road that includes a hairpin turn at the site entrance. Only one involved a vehicle-to-vehicle collision.

“The combination of the additional 60 some vehicles during the peak hour to this roadway would have negligible, if no impact, to the traffic generation in this area,” Mr. Indovina said.

But more than 20 people who testified against the project pushed back against such claims.

Advertise with us

Geri Smith, a member of the Frick Park Friends group opposed to the project, said using the variance process to essentially rezone a parks district would “set a dangerous precedent” for the city.

She also argued that such a massive development on a winding road with a hairpin curve at the site’s main entrance would limit sight and stop distances and increase the danger of accidents.

“We do view this as a detriment to the public welfare,” she said.

Others testified that there were two accidents just recently on the stretch of Forward/Commercial near the site and that cars often get stuck there during icy weather. Motorists also use it to bypass Parkway East congestion, making the road even more heavily traveled.

In addition, Emily Constantine Mercurio, a licensed professional geologist, said the area surrounding the site is susceptible to landslides, in part because of “red bed” soil conditions that are crumbly and “notoriously known to fail.”

Advertise with us

Development of the site will only increase the risk, she argued.

“This is just simply not a good idea from a geologic and hydrologic perspective,” she said.

In rebuttal, a Craft consultant stated that the Irish Centre site itself was outside of the areas most prone to landslide and “red bed” soil conditions.

Another opponent, Melissa Rychener, a Swisshelm Park resident who lives less than half a mile from the Irish Centre, said she fears that the development will squeeze access to Frick Park trails because of the limited parking nearby.

“For all of us who use the park it would dramatically change the character,” she said.

Advertise with us

Attorney James Carroll also mocked the development team’s claims about the relatively small number of peak hour trips the complex would generate.

“Are you expecting that the residents of your structure will be unemployed?” he asked, noting that one would expect more trips with people going to and returning from jobs each day.

A Craft consultant countered that people leave at different times for work.

Beyond the opposition from nearby residents, Craft also suffered a setback earlier this week when the Squirrel Urban Coalition board refused to reverse an earlier decision to oppose the height of the project.

As the registered community organization, the coalition’s position could hold some sway with the zoning board.

Advertise with us

The coalition did support the variance to allow for multi-unit residential in a parks district as well as one for a retaining wall that would exceed the 10-foot maximum allowed.

Not everybody outside the development team testified against the proposals. A handful of people supported it, saying that it would bring needed housing to the area and improve safety with proposed traffic calming measures.

Jon Danzak, a founder of the Nine Mile Run Watershed Association, said the Irish Centre site has been an “eyesore” that the development will address. The plan, he said, also will alleviate stormwater runoff, a key to preserving Nine Mile Run.

He also believes all of the trees surrounding the site from Frick Park will obscure the building.

But Vicki Yann, a project opponent who lives in Swisshelm Park, said that she can clearly see the site from her backyard deck when those trees lose their leaves in the fall.

Advertise with us

“Even though the developer is citing that they need to go big or go home for financial reasons, ultimately we would prefer the latter,” she said. “We urge you to deny all requested variances.”

The zoning board gave no timetable for a decision. It gave all parties until mid September to submit proposed findings of fact and other information.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com