A Squirrel Hill community group may revisit a key vote last month in opposition to the proposed height of a controversial eight-story residential complex at the site of the former Irish Centre on Forward Avenue.

The Squirrel Hill Urban Coalition will hold a special meeting July 31 to again discuss the project after the developer presented new information to the group’s built committee relating to the context and cost of the complex.

As a result of the presentation, the built committee recommended that the coalition board hold a special meeting to “reconsider” its June vote not to support the building height of nearly 88 feet.

The June vote was a setback for Toronto-based Craft Development Corporation, which plans to seek three variances from the Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment next month to build to that height. As Squirrel Hill’s registered community organization, the coalition’s position could hold sway with the zoning board.

Advertise with us
A Toronto-based developer is proposing an eight-story, 160-unit residential building at the site of the former Irish Centre at 6886 Forward Avenue, Squirrel Hill. The project is drawing opposition from some residents in nearby Swisshelm Park. (Indovina Associates)

While the built committee has recommended a reconsideration of the vote, the decision will be left to the full board itself, board President Martha Isler stressed Monday.

Another vote will take place “only if someone decides that there should be [one], someone on the board,” she said.

Still, the special meeting and a possible second vote have upset some of the opponents of the project, including those who live in nearby Swisshelm Park and are part of the Frick Park Friends group.

Vicki Yann, a Frick Park Friends organizer who lives minutes from the Irish Centre, said residents were told by the coalition after the first vote that there would not be a second one.

“We feel a little blindsided,” she said, adding that neither her group nor others opposed to the project were asked to sit in on the presentation made to the coalition’s built committee.

Advertise with us

Location of proposed eight-story residential complex

The Squirrel Hill Urban Coalition board is holding the special meeting even though Craft is not offering to reduce the height of the building at 6886 Forward.

Instead, the additional information Craft provided related to development costs “and the density/number of units required to achieve feasibility and obtain financing,” according to a posting on the coalition’s website.

It also involved the building’s context, including its size in relation to the height of a nearby Parkway East bridge and the “surrounding environment.”

For the first time, Craft stated at the committee meeting that the 160 units planned in the development would be condominiums.

In its presentation, the developer maintained that neither a three-story building with 80 condos nor a five-story one with 131 would be feasible even though they would generate surpluses of 6.07% and 10% respectively.

Advertise with us

The 160-unit project and another with 189 units were dubbed successes with surpluses of 12.39% and 13.45%, respectively.

Ray Baum, Craft’s attorney, said returns of 6% and 10% are not enough to justify such an expensive project, with a cost estimated at nearly $66.4 million.

“These people in business are not doing it to lose money or to give away money,” he said.

Mr. Baum, a Squirrel Hill Urban Coalition board member who has recused himself from discussions about the project, said he did, as Craft’s attorney, urge the built committee to recommend another vote. He said he did so because the board at the June meeting had concerns about the size of the building as it related to its surroundings, including adjacent Frick Park.

A Toronto-based developer is proposing an eight-story, 160-unit residential building at the site of the former Irish Centre at 6886 Forward Avenue, Squirrel Hill. The project is drawing opposition from some residents in nearby Swisshelm Park. (Indovina Associates)

In the presentation, Craft estimated that the building itself would take up only about 60% or so of the entire Irish Centre site and that the complex itself would stretch to just about the height of the Parkway East bridge.

Advertise with us

A big issue for the coalition board was that “the building is too big for the site. We were trying to convince them that they’re wrong,” Mr. Baum said.

However, Ms. Yann said parts of what Craft presented were “misleading at best.” She maintained, for instance, that a rendering showing the size of the proposed development in relation to the nearby Walnut Towers at Frick Park apartment complex was skewed and “not based on the actual dimensions of the site.”

As for a 6% or 10% return on the development not being enough, “if we got five percent on our savings account, we would be thrilled,” Ms. Yann said.

In a statement, Frick Park Friends said that Craft has not reached out to the group or other residents even though the developer cited as the reason for rescheduling a July 6 zoning board meeting a need to engage more with the community. The zoning board hearing is now set for Aug. 3.

Craft is planning to demolish the existing Irish Centre buildings and erect the eight-story building, with six floors above ground and two below for a parking garage with 182 spaces.

Advertise with us

Opponents of the project have raised concerns about traffic, safety, water runoff, potential landslides and the impact on Frick Park, which borders the site.

They also contend that using the variance process to build a multiunit residential building in a parks district where it’s not allowed amounts to spot zoning, an assertion Mr. Blum disputes.

He has said that Craft has taken steps to address many of the concerns, including the installation of underground storage tanks to control runoffs and a $100,000 contribution toward improving safety of Forward Avenue/Commercial Street running by the site.

He also has argued that the development would be a major improvement to what is now a blighted site.

During its June meeting, the Squirrel Hill Urban Coalition board voted in favor of variances to allow for the multiunit residential building in a parks district and a retaining wall higher than the maximum 10 feet.

Advertise with us

But it voted against allowing a proposed variance that would allow the 87 foot, 10-inch building in a district where the maximum permitted height is 40 feet, 3 inches.

While Frick Park Friends has collected more than 2,000 signatures from people opposed to the project, not everyone feels that way.

Jonathan Salmans, a Squirrel Hill resident who writes a Connect-PGH blog, has argued that the concerns about traffic are overblown, that the complex won’t hinder Frick Park users, and that it actually could help to improve snow removal on Forward since the development would generate additional tax revenue and more voters.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com