A two-year-old fight over what number to use to calculate taxable value in Allegheny County property assessment appeal hearings is heating up again.

The Pittsburgh Public Schools is challenging the 63.5% common level ratio recalculated last month by the state tax equalization board, or STEB, for use in 2022 county appeal hearings.

In a seven-page filing before STEB last week, the district stated that it was seeking to remedy a “severe overcorrection” in the ratio, which is used to calculate taxable value after fair market value has been determined in appeal hearings.

The recalculation, ordered by state Commonwealth Court President Judge Renee Cohn Jubelirer, dropped the ratio to 63.5% from the 81.1% that was originally calculated by the tax equalization board three years ago.

Advertise with us

Ira Weiss, the district solicitor, said Thursday school officials filed the objections in a bid to correct a ratio recalculated on the basis of faulty data. The district could face big revenue losses if the lower ratio is upheld.

“This is basically an effort to get it right because so far that hasn’t happened,” he said.

But John Silvestri, attorney for a group of property owners who sued two years ago to lower the ratio, claimed the district had a different motivation.

“This is a hodgepodge of objections that are without merit only for the purpose of delaying fairness to property owners,” he said.

Under law, the district had the right to file objections with the tax equalization board over its recalculation of the ratio after the new number became official with its publication in the Pennsylvania Bulletin last month. Among its five objections, the district took issue with 750 sales included in the recalculation.

Advertise with us

It stated that Mr. Silvestri’s clients had convinced Allegheny County Common Pleas Court Judge Alan Hertzberg to use the taxable values on those properties set as part of the last countywide reassessment in 2012 rather than the current taxable values established through subsequent appeals.

In doing so, it “artificially decreases the ratio of assessed value to sales price,” the district contended in its objections.

“We want the correct ratio,” Mr. Weiss said. “We hope it is higher because we believe the data provided to Judge Hertzberg was flawed.”

Judge Hertzberg presided over the lawsuit filed by Mr. Silvestri’s clients and last September ordered the common level ratio reduced to 63.5% for 2022 based on a calculation of revised sales data submitted by the county. His order was issued before the tax equalization board did its own recalculation of the ratio using the same data.

Countering the district’s argument, Mr. Silvestri said the 2012 taxable values for the 750 sales were included in revised data rather than those set through subsequent appeals based on International Association of Assessing Officers (IAAO) standards. Mr. Silvestri said he intends to intervene in the school district’s case before STEB to ensure that the board has the information regarding the IAAO standards.

Advertise with us

But even if the other values were used, the change in the ratio would be less than 1%, he estimated.

The district also asserted in its objections that the STEB recalculation was untimely now that the 2022 appeal season has passed and that STEB law requires the board to automatically review the ratio any time it changes by more than 10%.

However, Mr. Silvestri noted that there are still thousands of 2022 appeals pending before the appeals board. The county in January offered property owners a second chance to appeal their 2022 assessments after Judge Hertzberg ordered the reduction in the ratio.

The tax equalization board is expected to meet in July to decide next steps. Mr. Silvestri said it could either dismiss the district’s objections or hold a hearing on them.

Mr. Weiss said the district also was compelled to file objections after Commonwealth Court had stayed its appeal of Judge Hertzberg’s order lowering the ratio pending the outcome of any challenges to the STEB recalculation.

Advertise with us

The court, in essence, was “directing the parties who had objections to the calculation to pursue that remedy with that agency that is provided for in the statute,” he said.

Judge Hertzberg ordered the change after Mr. Silvestri charged that the county had invalidated some valid property sales while validating others that should not have been in arriving at the ratio, resulting in an inflated number. The judge asserted that based on the evidence he heard, the county office of property assessment had been “cooking the books” on common level ratio data submitted to the tax equalization board for calculation.

However, county spokeswoman Amie Downs has objected to that, describing it as a “mischaracterization.”

"Mistakes were made by the Office of Property Assessment staff that have since been corrected," she said in November. "They were just that — mistakes."

Nonetheless, the district, Mr. Weiss charged, is left to pick up the battle because county officials “weren’t willing to defend their position in court. They folded like a cheap card table.”

Advertise with us

“It’s time that the mistake is corrected by the agency charged with doing this function,” he said, referring to the tax equalization board, which under law is responsible for calculating the common level ratio for counties.

At the 81.1% ratio, a house with a fair market value of $200,000 as determined on an appeal would be taxed at $162,200. At 63.5%, it would be taxed at $127,000.

While Mr. Silvestri claimed that the district is trying to deny fairness to taxpayers by filing objections, Mr. Weiss contended that it is just the opposite.

“It’s a cogent, clear statement of objections that is designed to ensure fairness for all taxpayers and other parties in the tax system because an unfair tax system hurts everyone,” he said.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com