The final number is in. But — no surprise — it still might not settle the two-year-old battle over property assessment appeals in Allegheny County.
State Tax Equalization Board members on Wednesday approved a 63.5% common level ratio for use in 2022 assessment appeal hearings to calculate the taxable value of properties.
And at the same meeting, they approved an even lower ratio — 54.5% — to be applied in appeal hearings next year.
The 2022 recalculation, ordered by state Commonwealth Court President Judge Renee Cohn Jubelirer, affirms the decision by Common Pleas Judge Alan Hertzberg in September to mandate the use of essentially the same ratio — 63.53% — in 2022 appeal hearings.
With Wednesday’s action, the 63.5% ratio — substantially lower than the 81.1% originally calculated by the board for use in 2022 — will become official with its publication in the Pennsylvania Bulletin this weekend. The tax equalization board is charged with computing the ratio for counties.
The 63.53% ordered by Judge Hertzberg was calculated by experts for a handful of county property owners who sued two years ago to lower the ratio, charging that the 81.1% was inflated.
Read More
“We were right all along,” said Mike Suley, a consultant for the plaintiffs.
With Wednesday’s action, “It’s over. It’s done. It’s finished,” he said.
Well, not so fast.
Robert Max Junker, attorney for the Pittsburgh Public Schools, said objections can be filed with the board over the recalculated number. He noted that the district had an issue with about 750 property sales that were included in the recalculation.
He said he wasn’t sure at this point whether the district would file objections.
In addition, the district is still awaiting word from Commonwealth Court on its challenge of Judge Hertzberg’s order requiring the use of the 63.53% ratio.
One of its main arguments in that case is that only the tax equalization board had the authority to calculate the common level ratio, which is used in appeal hearings to determine the taxable value of a property after the fair market value has been established.
But John Silvestri, attorney for the plaintiffs who sued to lower the ratio, said the district’s challenge is now moot given that the board has done exactly what it wanted.
“That argument has been taken away,” he said, adding that he will ask Commonwealth Court to dismiss the district’s appeal.
Mr. Junker, however, said there were other outstanding issues still to be decided in the Commonwealth Court case that didn’t involve the tax equalization board. “We’re still waiting to see what Commonwealth Court has to say about all of this.”
Nonetheless, even if the district files objections with the board over the 63.5% recalculation, that ratio would still stand as the official number to be used in appeals hearings at least until the agency rules on the challenge, Mr. Silvestri said.
He also pointed out that even if the 750 sales the district objects to are thrown out, it would change the ratio by two-tenths of one percent “at the most.”
At the same time, he expressed exasperation with the Pittsburgh Public Schools’ stance throughout the case.
“The school district has done everything it can to stop the process of fairness,” he said.
The county board of property assessment appeals and review will meet next week to decide whether to use the 63.5% in the 2022 appeals still pending before it, solicitor David Montgomery said.
Board members have yet to finalize thousands of appeals dating back to last year because of the controversy over the ratio.
Besides those cases, the local board must deal with 6,000 others from taxpayers who were given a second chance to appeal their 2022 assessments by the county because of Judge Hertzberg’s ruling.
Mr. Silvestri said one benefit of Wednesday’s tax equalization board action is that the 63.5% ratio should now be used in Common Pleas Court board of viewers hearings. That board typically uses the official tax equalization board ratio, he said.
Taxpayers and taxing bodies that are dissatisfied with county assessment rulings have the option to appeal to the board of viewers, which often tries to negotiate settlements. Mr. Silvestri said it also has been negotiating common level ratios because of the confusion over the 2022 number.
Even with the lingering uncertainties, Wednesday’s tax equalization board action is a big victory for Mr. Silvestri and the property owners who sued two years ago to lower the ratio. It provides a measure of clarity in a situation where there has been little.
“I think the system works,” Mr. Silvestri said. “You have to pursue the truth but the system works.”
The lawsuit was filed in June 2021. Mr. Suley said it was a “shame” that it had taken so long to get to this point.
“Why does it take two years to get an honest tax bill in Allegheny County?” he said. “We won every step of the way and government kept pushing back at us.”
Mr. Suley urged the Pittsburgh Public Schools to honor the tax equalization board recalculation.
“Quit playing rope-a-dope and start slapping this number on right now. This affects literally thousands of property owners,” he said.
The use of the lower ratio would make a big difference in property tax bills.
At the 81.1% ratio originally calculated by the tax equalization board, a house with a fair market value of $200,000 would be taxed at $162,200. At 63.5%, it would be taxed at $127,000.
While that could mean lower tax bills for some homeowners, it also could mean big losses for school districts and municipalities who rely on appeals to help generate revenue in lieu of a countywide reassessment.
The 54.5% computed for 2024 in Allegheny County could drive down tax bills even more. At that ratio, a house valued at $200,000 would be taxed at $109,000.
Mr. Silvestri has also filed a lawsuit seeking to lower the tax equalization board-calculated 63.6% ratio to be used in appeal hearings this year to roughly 57%.
He found support for his case in the agency’s 2022 and 2024 math.
“[2023] has to be between 63.5% and 54.5%,” he said.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.